Fish eat food, not feathers. Fly anglers test themselves by intentionally increasing the difficulty of hooking up while developing skill sets to compensate.

That’s the attraction. That’s the challenge.

That’s also a self-defeating strategy when feather-and-hook sportsmen forget the fundamentals. Fly fishing guide Lance Wilt teaches his clients to remember the basic principles they learned during their bait fishing days.

“The most inefficient tool you can fish with is the fly,” said Wilt, who will offer “tips and tricks from a guide’s perspective” at 11 a.m. March 21 at International Angler in Robinson. “Some of the things I’ve done in the last 12 or 18 months have taken me back to what I started with as a 4-year-old kid fishing bait. … I’m trying to make fly fishing easier. If you approach it the right way, you’re not giving up [knowledge] that you started with.”

Advertise with us

Wilt was about 5, growing up on the banks of Big Fishing Creek in Clinton County, when his dad taught him to cast a fly rod. He drifted away from fishing as a sports-oriented teenager, but was guiding anglers in Central Pennsylvania by the time he was 18.

Wilt coached the 2011 U.S. Youth Fly Fishing Team that picked up America’s first gold medal in international youth fly fishing competition. These days, as owner of Outcast Anglers, he guides fishing trips in Pennsylvania, Montana and Arkansas, as well as Patagonian trout streams in Chile and Argentina.

“Central Pennsylvania — Spring Creek, the Letort — it’s a great playground for fly fishing, no question about it,” said Wilt. “High fish population, good water, grass and food bank to bank. But it’s also some of the most heavily pressured water in the Northeast. [Fly anglers] walk in and stand in the middle and fish the biggest, deepest pool and never look at the bank. They’re forgetting what they learned about fishing before they started using flies.”

Wilt tells clients to remember how they fished with live bait when they were kids. How the worm was swept deep under an overhanging bank. How the minnow wafted in the current. How the trout waited patiently in shallow, grassy, near-shore water before the strike.

“This demands attention to detail,” he said. “What it demands is your understanding the power of observation, the constant wanting to learn.”

Advertise with us

A case in point: On a recent bait-fishing trip in Arkansas, Wilt filled a minnow trap with Saltines and watched about 150 minnows gather.

“A 12-inch rainbow trout circled around for an hour,” he said. “One minnow turns on its side to get a Saltine and gets waylaid by the trout. It was fascinating to watch that happen, which minnow the trout went for, and when and how that happened.”

Fly anglers, he said, too often get stuck on color — attempting simply to match the hatch or imitate a minnow instead of understanding the feeding dynamics.

“In the last 12 months, I’ve been thinking about why fish commit to one thing and not the other,” said Wilt. “You’re fishing marginal water that might hold larger fish. Or you’re fishing high-quality water that might hold more fish. The fish will respond differently in different situations, something you probably noticed when you were bait fishing as a kid. But a fly fisherman, he might just go to a different color.”

Wilt said his clients benefit from his time on different kinds of waterways in different parts of the world. Those experiences, he says, offer insight that he applies to fishing in Pennsylvania streams.

Advertise with us

“One of the things that sticks out in my mind — there’s a stream in South America, in Patagonia, that I work in,” he said. “High banks, very narrow. Guys there all bank fish with live bait — grasshoppers drifted under the bank. If you throw out in the current, they’re not there. You’re right on top of the fish.”

That bait-fishing experience, Wilt said, helps him to get his Pennsylvania fly fishing clients in position on the bank to drift their patterns through undercut banks right below them.

Fly fishing or bait fishing? Wilt says either way works for him. He supports catch-and-release but not Fly-Fishing Only and Delayed Harvest Artificial Lures Only restrictions. Fishing mortality is no greater, he said, whether the fish was ripped in on 15-pound line with bait or fought to near exhaustion on 2- to 3-pound line with fly.

“Most of what I do isn’t about catching fish, but creating an experience,” he said. “Some guys are stuck for so long fishing fly, fly fly. But there are some good reasons to do something a little different and learn something you might have forgotten from a long time ago.”