A year ago, the WPIAL crowned two three-time singles champions for the first time in its history.

One, Belle Vernon’s Gabby Dusi, the Class 2A victor, graduated. The other, Class 3A titlist Meriwether McCargo of Shady Side Academy, is back with an opportunity to once again stamp her name in the record book.

“Obviously I’m super excited and super glad,” McCargo said. “I’m happy to represent Shady Side that way, but I’m not really too focused on that. I just want to have fun and have a really great time with my team.”

Should McCargo take home the title this season — the finals will be held on Sept. 24 at a location that has yet to be determined — she would become only the second singles player ever to win in all four years and the first in the highest classification. Laura Greb of Knoch is the only player to accomplish the feat and she did it in Class 2A from 2017-20.

Advertise with us

“Obviously if that ends up happening, it’s best-case scenario,” McCargo said. “I would just be really honored to represent Shady Side like that. It would be unbelievable.”

Winning three consecutive titles in the highest classification has been no easy feat for the University of Chicago recruit. She won her first by as a freshman by upsetting a reigning WPIAL champion in Amelia Williams of Penn-Trafford 7-6 (7-1), 6-1 in 2023. McCargo then edged Williams out again in each of the last two seasons in a pair of three-set thrillers — 6-3, 4-6, 7-6 (7-5) in 2024 and 6-3, 2-6, 6-4 last season.

McCargo lost to West Chester Henderson’s Erika Dunwoody, who will be a sophomore this season, 6-4, 6-3 in the state quarterfinals, and the two could see each other again in the PIAA tournament at Hershey Racquet Club on Nov. 6-7. Before that happens, though, she will have to get through the WPIAL tournament, which has several familiar faces back who will seek to upset the three-time reigning champion.

Bethel Park senior Cami Fisher will certainly be one of the top challengers. She dropped a 10-8 decision in a pro-set match to McCargo in the quarterfinals in her freshman year and lost to Williams in the semifinals in each of the last two seasons. Fisher still advanced to the state tournament by winning the third-place consolation match both times.

As a freshman, Fisher also anchored the Black Hawks’ WPIAL Class 3A championship team.

Advertise with us

Shady Side Academy is also the reigning team champion after a 4-1 win against Bethel Park in the finals. The Bulldogs return No. 2 singles player Cassie Lapina, a junior who lost to Fisher in the quarterfinals a year ago, as well as No. 3 singles player Brooke Henderson, a junior who teamed with Alex Merkel to finish second in the WPIAL doubles tournament.

Shady Side Academy lost to eventual champion Lower Merion 3-1 in the state semifinals last year. No WPIAL team has won a PIAA title in either classification since Knoch took Class 2A in 2022, while Fox Chapel was the last team to bring home a state crown in Class 3A in 2019.

Shady Side Academy has not won a state championship since 2010, but with all three singles players having another year under their belts and with an influx of talent, the Bulldogs have an opportunity to end the drought.

“They’ve both definitely improved a lot,” McCargo said. “I think this year might be the year.”

Though it’s been 16 years since Shady Side Academy won a state championship, that dry spell is nothing compared to the one from the WPIAL in Class 2A singles. Since the split into two classifications in 1999, Annie Houghton of Quaker Valley, who took the crown in 2004, remains the only WPIAL player to win in the classification.

Advertise with us

Dusi gave it a pretty good shot last year but came away empty in a 6-2, 4-6, 6-1 loss to Montrose’s Cara Evans.

Evans will be a senior and likely back in the field this year. She could once again see Quaker Valley’s Avery Allan in the tournament. Allan, who lost to Dusi in the WPIAL finals a year ago and is the top returning player, lost to Evans in the first round of the state finals 6-1, 6-0.

Allan, a junior, will be among those who will vie for the crown vacated by Dusi. Oakland Catholic senior Mollie Sclichter, who lost to Allan in the semifinals and won the third-place consolation match to earn a state tournament berth, is back this season.

So, too, is Winchester Thurston sophomore Veronica Zinski, who upset No. 4-seeded Anna Mrkonja of Beaver Area and made a run to the semifinals before losing to Dusi.

Quaker Valley and North Catholic have faced off in the team final in each of the last two years, with the Trojanettes winning in 2024 and the Quakers last season. While Allan will lead Quaker Valley, North Catholic should have its top two singles players back in juniors Evelyn Marche and Macaria Stall.