Indiana had everything it wanted heading into the third period of the Class 1A Pennsylvania Cup final.

It had a one-goal lead over Flyers Cup champion West Chester East, had a goaltender playing out if his mind in Seamus O’Connor and had a solid defensive game plan against a high-powered Vikings attack.

All that changed in the span of 22 seconds.

Defenseman Henry Thornton scored on a rebound to tie the game at 3:52 of the third period and Chase Becnel notched his second of the game at 4:14 to give West Chester East its first lead of the game. From there, Penguins Cup champion Indiana wilted under the onslaught of the Vikings attack as they scored four third-period goals and the Little Indians dropped a 6-3 decision in their first ever state finals appearance.

Advertise with us

“To be honest, they had so much depth and we were tired,” Indiana coach Jordan Haines said. “After the break going to the third period, they came out flying and we couldn’t stop it.”

It was the first loss of the season for Indiana (20-1-0), which came into the game riding a 28-game winning streak dating back to last season. The Little Indians would have played Thomas Jefferson in the 2020 Class 1A Penguins Cup final, but the game was cancelled because of the COVID-19 shutdown.

No team from the western half of the state has won the Class 1A state championship since Quaker Valley defeated Bayard Rustin in 2012. It was also the first state title for West Chester East since 2013 when it defeated the Quakers in the finals.

Bayard Rustin had also won the previous six state championships that were contested, from 2014-19.

“We lost a couple of those games (against Byard Rustin) in the Flyers Cup for the right to play in this,” West Chester East coach Eric Wolf said. “High school hockey is cyclical and you have a new group of kids that come in and, those kids who lost as freshmen (in 2018) are seniors and it’s just quite the walk-off for them.”

Advertise with us

Despite getting tagged with the loss, O’Connor was masterful between the pipes for Indiana. The senior netminder stopped 27 of 29 shots in the first two periods, including several of the spectacular variety, before West Chester East finally took control with four goals on its first 13 shots of the third period.

“We broke down a lot of things that they did,” Haines said. “Seamus O’Connor played his [butt] off and they should have had three goals in the second period he made saves on.”

West Chester East outshot Indiana, 47-19, in the game as the Vikings rolled their four lines throughout and just wore the Little Indians down.

“Normally you only see two solid lines in Single-A hockey and that team could stay with a lot of Double-A and triple-A teams in the PIHL,” Haines said. “They just kept coming and we gave them a hell of a fight and they came out in that third period ready to go and I just didn’t have enough guys on the bench to play to that ability.”

On the first shift of the game it appeared Indiana was in for a long afternoon. West Chester East was rolling through center ice at will and had several quality scoring chances before the Little Indians found their legs and got into the game.

Advertise with us

Those opening seconds were critical as the game went on, though, as it gave Indiana an opportunity to shake off any residual jitters and really get focused in on the task at hand.

Muddling through that first shift unscathed propelled Indiana in the early going and it culminated in its first lead when Ben Nettleton whipped a wrist shot past West Chester East senior goaltender Jake Godhsall at 1:57 to put the Little Indians ahead, 1-0.

“Do you know how many times that has happened to us this year? We would own the first two or three shifts and, all of a sudden, they would get one crazy opportunity and, boom, we’re down, 1-1,” Wolf said.

“I don’t like getting used to that thing, but it’s not the first time it happened.”

Like it has in those previous situations, West Chester East was able to answer Indiana throughout most of the first two periods

Advertise with us

Becnel got the Vikings back to even at 1-1 when he roofed a shot over O’Connor on the power play at 14:01 of the first period. Indiana again took the lead, this time on a one-timer from the low slot by Zach Eisenhower at 7:56 of the second period, but that lead lasted less time than the first as, 1:25 later, Tristan D’Elia scored the first of his two on the afternoon when he snuck one past O’Connor at 9:21 to tie it.

Undaunted, Indiana took advantage of a power play opportunity, a defensive breakdown and poor goaltending to take the lead heading to the third period. Defenseman Ethan Agnello rolled down the right wing and flipped a weak backhander on Godshall that somehow sneaked through the arm and the body at 13:58 of the second period to put Indiana ahead, 3-2.

Godhsall had only allowed three goals on 51 shots in three games in the Flyers Cup tournament. Bu that was all Indiana could muster as the Vikings took control in the third period.

“We just never got opportunities the whole game and, when we did, they countered back,” Haines said. “It was one of those games that was just back-and-forth and back and forth.”