North Allegheny had Malvern Prep on the ropes in the early moments of the Class 3A Pennsylvania Cup finals.

Not only did the Tigers have an early one-goal lead, they were generating a ton of scoring chances and were working on their first power play with a chance to stake claim to the state title.

Only it was the Friars special teams who converted on that penalty, and with that goal, went the Tiger's chances of their first state title in 14 years.

Quinn Daugherty scored a back-breaking shorthanded goal at 7:09 of the first period that began a string of four straight Malvern Prep goals and helped the Friars to a 4-2 victory over North Allegheny. The Tigers were looking for their first state title since 2013 after losing in the finals in 2019.

Advertise with us

“If there’s anything you can ask of your players, is for them to do their best,” North Allegheny coach Mike Bagnato said “We are certainly disappointed we didn’t win the state championship, but when push comes to shove, life goes on. They gave it their best shot.”

Malvern Prep won its third state championship overall and ended a 17-year drought. The Friars' last victory came against Mt. Lebanon in 2004.

“This program’s been building for years and, these last couple of years, it’s been a good ride,” Malvern Prep coach Bill Keenan said. “The Flyers Cup was our goal and states was a good addition and, this year, we knew we had a little depth and it’s nice to see the kids come out on top here.”

Things actually started off well for North Allegheny as the team took it to Malvern Prep in the opening minutes of the first period. Friars goaltender Anthony Perti came up big on a couple of opportunities, but after he stopped a slapshot from defenseman Trey Gallo, he could not contain the rebound and Nathan Spak slammed it home to give the Tigers a 1-0 lead at 3:17 of the first period.

“We started out on fire, we get that first goal and we had that power play and you figure we can get something going there,” Bagnato said. “Honestly though, I thought we hung tough and kept ourselves in this game.”

Advertise with us

North Allegheny appeared ready to take control of the contest just over two minutes later when Malvern Prep’s Travis Buckley was sent off for cross-checking at 5:18. But that penalty turned into a nightmare for the Tigers when Dougherty converted a 2-on-1 and drove a shot into the top left corner past goaltender Josh Bailey to tie the game, 1-1, at 7:09.

“We’ve had shorthanded goals a couple times this season and it just sparks a team from the low point of taking a penalty and kill it off and guys are anxious getting pucks out,” Keenan said. “Then you score one shorthanded, it changes the whole momentum, both mentally and physically in the pace of the game.”

That was where it all started crashing down around North Allegheny.

Just 26 seconds later, Jack Costabile put Malvern Prep ahead for good when he chipped one past Bailey to put Malvern Prep ahead, 2-1. He added his second of the game at 9:38, just 2:03 after his first goal, for a 3-1 Friars lead.

Malvern Prep extended it to a three-goal edge when Jimmy Kirk converted on the power play 20 seconds into the second period, but North Allegheny got some hope at 2:40 when Connor Chi scored on the man-advantage to get the Tigers back within two, 4-2.

Advertise with us

North Allegheny, though, never really had an opportunity to get back into the game as the team had to kill off six minutes in penalties in the first nine minutes of the third period.

“You just can’t take them and we deserved them,” Bagnato said. “You can’t take penalties in the third period and I thought we’d come out and come at them, but the we got a couple penalties right off the bat. We killed them, but that’s all the momentum you wanted to get back in the game”