Don Hartman comes across as a pleasant, salt-of-the-earth kind of guy. For someone who eschews a lifestyles-of-the-rich-and-famous vibe, he sure is draped in gold a lot.

Hartman is the man with the Midas touch, whether he’s coaching softball or baseball. As head coach of the Frazier softball team, he collected another trinket to add to his collection by leading the Commodores to the first PIAA championship in school history.

Thanks to his latest successful run, Hartman is the Post-Gazette Softball Coach of the Year.

It was a family effort for the Hartmans. Don’s assistant coach is his wife Mandy. Their daughter, Logan, is the ace pitcher and leadoff hitter for the Commodores.

Advertise with us

Hartman formerly coach the California baseball team, but stepped down so that he could coach his daughters — Logan is the oldest of three — at Frazier. During his 16 years leading the Trojans baseball team from 1998-2013, Hartman went 229-92-1 with WPIAL titles in 2001 and 2006. He has coached Frazier’s softball team for three years and is 56-14 with two WPIAL runner-up finishes and now the state crown.

Q: In nine tries in the PIAA playoffs, you reached the state semifinals twice as a baseball coach before finally winning the championship this year. How does it feel to win it as a coach, and also a husband and father?

A: For me, personally, it’s been a dream come true. It’s been the one thing I’ve never been able to capture. I still have chest pains, seriously. There’s times Mandy and I have woken up in the middle of the night and ask each other, ‘Did this really happen?’

We’ve always talked about this. To do it with our daughter in the circle? It’s been surreal.

Q: There were a lot of close games along the way. Do you have any fingernails left?

Advertise with us

A: I really, honestly do not have fingernails left right now. My wife was like, ‘Your hands are atrocious, just stop it.’ The stress and anxiety that goes along with these games and the thrill of victory. … We were a bloop or a pop up away from going down, but we never lost.

Every game was pretty much in dramatic fashion. Over the last few days, it’s been like a storybook ending. It’s like any athletic movie you’ve ever watched.

Q: How did you get the team to regroup after falling to Laurel again in the WPIAL championship?

A: We really never spoke of it. We never talked about it coming into the season, either. It sat on our shoulders and we never talked about it.

I wanted to make a run at states. And that was about all that was said about it. We were actually kind of happy to play a new opponent that you know nothing about. It’s like, ‘Let’s get out there and play.’

Advertise with us

Q: What is your approach to coaching and why does it work?

A: My approach is based on discipline. They know every day they are going to come here and work. But on the other hand, it’s fun. I don’t yell. I love to coach, my wife loves to coach. The girls who play for us truly love us. We call ourselves a family every day. We have each other’s backs, whether good or bad. That’s our philosophy.

Q: Family is a perfect description considering you carpool with a portion of the team in Mandy and Logan.

A: [Laughs] Games don’t end when you get off the bus, because you have to come home. It’s a 24/7 household. Sometimes we have to go in our own rooms for a while, but I wouldn’t change it for the world.

Q: You had plenty of success coaching baseball, too. How hard was it to leave that behind and start over?

A: The hardest thing I ever did was walk away from California. I did it because I knew I had three daughters coming through. I’d been coaching all these other great people’s kids all these years. How could I not coach my own kids?