In the coming weeks, Rachel Martindale will pack her bags and head off to Akron, where she received a scholarship to play basketball. Tucked away in those belongings will be a well-worn softball glove. She just can’t let it go.

“I’ll probably make my roommate play catch with me,” Martindale said with a laugh.

No kidding, the Division I basketball player Martindale just wrapped up her senior season at North Allegheny as the Post-Gazette’s Class 6A softball player of the year.

Martindale is just that good in both sports. Also a two-time Fab 5 basketball player, Martindale led the Tigers softball team with a .479 batting average with 9 doubles, 5 homers and 21 RBIs. She was moved to the leadoff spot for the first time and scored 35 runs.

Advertise with us

“Some people feel rusty when they have the bat in the basement for a week,” said North Allegheny coach Morgan Vescovi, who led the Tigers to WPIAL and PIAA titles during her playing days and then went on to play at Pitt. “She goes a whole basketball season. I think that says a lot about that natural, raw athletic talent she has. A lot of girls couldn’t do that. I couldn’t do that.”

As one of the best two-sport athletes in recent memory, Martindale was bound to be a Division I athlete. The sport was up to her. She had previously committed to play softball at Pitt, but later decided her heart was with basketball and pursued that as her sport of choice.

As if all of those numbers and accolades weren’t impressive enough on their own, consider this: Martindale did not play softball her junior year. She tore her ACL during the 2018 WPIAL basketball championship game, won by the Tigers. If there was a comeback player of the year award, Martindale would have collected that, too.

Because of the injury, Martindale went about a year and a half without swinging a bat, she said. Coming back from a catastrophic injury was new ground. She knew her knee was holding up just fine because she had completed another stellar basketball season. But the timing and coordination required for hitting a round ball squarely off a round bat requires hours of practice and repetition for most players. Martindale, however, is a player like no other.

The second game of the season was against formidable Hempfield, the defending WPIAL and PIAA champion. Martindale went 3 for 3 with a grand slam and a double to lead the Tigers to an 11-6 victory and emphatically announce her return to the diamond.

Advertise with us

Martindale kept crushing the ball throughout the season, including a game-changing, three-run shot against Norwin to put the top-seeded Tigers into the WPIAL Class 6A championship.

She also was a slick-fielding shortstop with a powerful arm who turned balls that looked like surefire hits into easy outs.

“I think so much of it is the eye test. She just has that swagger about her, that kind of confidence, where everything looks easy for her,” Vescovi said. “When you watch her play the infield, she gets to balls that nobody else could. They should not be plays. They should be hits.”

Martindale comes from a diamond-loving family. She played baseball from ages 4 to 12, sometimes on her older brother’s team, before joining the softball team in middle school. Outings to Pirates games are a summer tradition and her grandfather, Jim Dentel, played in the minor leagues for the Los Angeles Dodgers organization.

Martindale molded the Tigers into a family atmosphere as well. She led sing-alongs before each game to loosen up the team and was a constant positive influence, even during her most trying of times. When her injury prevented her from being a player, she turned herself into a coach for the other girls.

Advertise with us

“I want people to remember me as someone who always put the team first and stayed positive,” said Martindale. “It’s important to me because in 5, 10 years you’re not going to remember what game you played. You’re going to remember the people that were in your life.”

Martindale certainly was an unforgettable player. Here is the rest of the Post-Gazette players of the year by class:

Britney Wilson (Steph Chambers / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Class 5A

• Britney Wilson, West Allegheny, catcher

All she does is win. Wilson is a three-year starter for the Indians and each time she has suited up, West Allegheny has claimed a district title. She batted .527 with a team-best 22 RBIs while leading the Indians to yet another district title in what looked like a rebuilding year early on. The Indians went just 8-7 in the regular season before ripping off five consecutive postseason wins. A rising senior, Wilson has committed to play at California (Pa.).

Advertise with us
Carolyn Alincic (Lake Fong / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Class 4A

• Carolyn Alincic, Mount Pleasant, pitcher

Plenty of people had a seat to watch Alincic work this season. Most of those people were opposing batters. This hard-throwing Morehead State recruit averaged nearly two strikeouts for every inning thrown her senior season, with 209 in 121 innings. She went 15-2 with a 1.16 ERA for the WPIAL-finalist Vikings. Behind Alincic, Mount Pleasant registered a perfect regular season with its only two losses coming to WPIAL champion Elizabeth Forward in both the WPIAL and state playoffs.

Maya Kozup (Steph Chambers / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Class 3A

• Maya Kozup, Avonworth, pitcher/center field

Advertise with us

A couple of players on this list are dual threats. Kozup, on the other hand, is a triple threat. She’s an ace pitcher, a tremendous hitter and a talented center fielder. She was 9-0 in the circle with a 2.05 ERA. The Edinboro recruit batted .487 with 10 doubles, 4 triples, 3 homers and 38 RBIs with a .636 slugging percentage and .529 on-base percentage. The speedster also scored 35 runs. In the outfield, she boasted a .980 fielding percentage.

Kayla Ruperto (Pam Panchak / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Class 2A

• Kayla Ruperto, Laurel, pitcher

Plagued by injuries throughout her career, Ruperto stayed healthy her senior year and put a hurting on her opponents. She was an ace in the circle and one of the most fearsome sluggers in the area with a penchant for extra-base hits. As a pitcher, she went 16-3 with 160 strikeouts and a 1.94 ERA as the Spartans collected a second consecutive WPIAL crown by outdueling eventual state champion Frazier. The Ashland University recruit bashed 14 homers and 51 RBIs while batting .605.

Jade Renner (Steph Chambers / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Class 1A

Advertise with us

• Jade Renner, West Greene, pitcher

Jade was a jewel on the diamond for West Greene all season long. Her ability to win games with her arm and bat steered the Pioneers to a WPIAL crown for a third consecutive year. They also reached the PIAA semifinals. Only a junior, Renner has been a district champion every year she has played and also has a pair of PIAA gold medals. This season, she fired her way to 20-5 record with 11 shutouts. She struck out 122 while posting an ERA of 1.68. From the plate, she led the Pioneers with 37 RBIs and batted .506.