HERSHEY – West Allegheny junior Shawn Taylor and Chartiers Valley senior Dylan Evans have had several classic battles this season.
Heading into the PIAA Class 3A 160-pound final at the Giant Center, the two had gone toe-to-toe four times with three of them going to overtime.
Even last week, in the WPIAL finals, the two went to an ultimate tiebreaker.
Once again, the two battled through overtime and into an ultimate tiebreaker. But no one could have foreseen how this one would end.
With Evans on top after the reset trying to ride it out and Taylor trying to escape, Taylor was assessed a point-penalty for stalling that gave Evans the title in a 3-2 decision.
“Yeah, it’s great to win states, especially for the second year in a row, but that’s not how I wanted it to end,” Evans said. “I didn’t ask for that call. I didn’t ask for a thing. I’m grateful, but not overly ecstatic.”
According to PIAA officials, because Taylor was on the bottom and took Evans’’ whole weight in standing up, it caused a stoppage and a warning. When he did it a second time, with 15 seconds remaining in the 30-second sudden-death period, he was dealt a penalty point for stalling that gave Evans the title.
Both wrestlers and coaches were left looking around, wondering what had happened. It took more than a minute of explanations from the referee before he raised Evans’ hand and declared him the winner.
“I was just stunned really,” Taylor said. “I didn’t think the match was going to end that way. I was confident that I was going to get out of it.”
Even with the win, Evans couldn’t bring himself to really celebrate and had a rather somber demeanor afterward.
“Shawn is a great competitor and we went to four overtime matches for a reason,” Evans said. “Am I grateful that I achieved it? Totally. Is that how I wanted to achieve it? Not really.”
There wasn’t any consternation for Latrobe senior Vinny Kilkeary. In fact, he experienced something the afternoon before the 127-pound final that he never had in his three previous trips.
Relaxation.
“I was just laying in my bed and I was like, ‘Oh my God. I’m not shaking like a leaf right now. I feel cool.’” Kilkeary said. “Freshman year I was pacing in my room and I even told my dad this is the coolest I ever felt.”
His pre-bout chill quickly gave way to on-mat fire.
Kilkeary, an Ohio State recruit, came out with three first period takedowns against Canon-McMillan junior Andrew Binni and rode him out for an 8-5 victory in the 127-pound final to win his third state championship.
He was the state champion at 106 pounds in 2020 and 120 pounds in 2022.
“It’s the world,” Kilkeary said. “You see how many where people who win three state titles really go to college and that’s just a huge stepping point for me.”
Kilkeary defeated Binni, 10-4, in the WPIAL championship match and knows facing him such a short time ago helped in the quick turnaround from the morning semifinals to the evening finals.
“It’s a huge confidence-builder having a match like we had at WPIALs and a match like (this),” Kilkeary said. “I felt controlled in both matches. It’s a huge boost to know what the kid’s gonna do and wrestle like I did last weekend.”
Kilkeary wasn’t the only WPIAL wrestler with an opportunity to join the three-time state titlist club. Waynesburg senior and Virginia Tech recruit Mac Church , who won at 120 in 2021 and 132 last season, was the top seed and favorite to close out his high school career with a victory against Quakertown sophomore Collin Gaj at 145.
But nothing went Church’s way, from a penalty point being assessed against him in the first period to him suffering a knee injury midway through the second. He then took another penalty point that gave Gaj a 3-1 lead with 1:51 remaining in the match before dropping a 7-1 decision.
“He’s a good wrestler and he outwrestled me,” Church said. “I think, in the long run, I worked my butt off this year but he’s a good wrestler and he outwrestled me.”
West Allegheny senior Ty Watters was able to close out his final season undefeated and with a second state championship as he opened up a 5-0 lead and rolled to an 11-3 victory over Central Dauphin junior Ryan Garvick at 152. Walters won the title at 145 last year.
Waynesburg senior Rocco Welsh also defended his title at 172 with a 9-2 victory over Canon-McMillan’s Mattherw Furman in a rematch of the WPIAL final.
Thomas Jefferson sophomore Maddox Shaw had a rough finish to his first-ever finals appearance. He gave up and escape 59 seconds into the second period for the only point of the match and took a tough 1-0 loss to Central Mountain junior Luke Simcox.
Keith Barnes: kbarnes.pg@gmail.com and Twitter @kbarnes_pghsprt






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.