PIAA executive director Bob Lombardi has made it quite clear that the organization has absolutely no intention of separating Catholic/private/charter school sports teams from public school teams. But that doesn’t mean the WPIAL can’t.
This would be the perfect time for the WPIAL to do what most of its member schools want, and that’s to address what they perceive is an unfair competitive advantage for Catholic/private/charter schools. Those schools don’t have geographic boundaries to draw students, while public schools can only take students in their own districts.
The reason this is the perfect time for the WPIAL to lead a change is because the league is looking for a new executive director after Amy Scheuneman resigned from the job last week, effective June 1. The WPIAL’s board of directors also have a few new members. And the list of complaints about public and private schools continued to grow recently. On top of all that, a group of athletic directors from boundary and non-boundary schools have come up with two proposals that would separate some boundary and non-boundary schools, at least for the regular season in basketball. And remember, that committee was formed by the WPIAL board.
So, here’s a message for the new WPIAL boss and also the league’s board of directors:
Do something!
I’m not talking about having separate playoffs for boundary and non-boundary schools, although that is what the large majority of schools want. Just look back at a WPIAL survey of all member schools four years ago that showed almost 90% favor separate playoffs. But it is virtually impossible to have separate playoffs in the WPIAL right now when the PIAA doesn’t.
Read More
It is also close to impossible to do anything for the next two-year cycle of all WPIAL sports when sections and schedules have already been made — except in basketball. The WPIAL has yet to align sections and make schedules for boys and girls basketball the next two years, and a change in basketball alignment for public and Catholic/private schools is included in the recent proposals from the committee of athletic directors.
So, to use a basketball term, the ball is now in the court of the WPIAL brass. Maybe the WPIAL can’t make a slam dunk and create separate playoffs for boundary and non-boundary schools, but the league still can make a play on this issue, even if it’s just for the regular season. It might be the impetus to push other districts around the state to make changes and maybe push the PIAA just a little more to address the issue in the future.
What will you do, WPIAL, stand up and make some sort of change, even just for the regular season? Or will you just pay lip service to the issue again and kick the can farther down the road because the PIAA isn’t doing anything?
“Whoever is the next WPIAL executive director, if they’re going to make decisions based on the desires of membership, then a move toward separate playoffs has to be at the forefront of their job in the first 100 days in office,” said Ralph Blundo, basketball coach and also assistant principal of New Castle High School.
Blundo has been outspoken about the unfair advantages that non-boundary schools have. Blundo isn’t just “talking” about change. He’s trying to affect change. In recent weeks, he has had discussions with Lombardi, Scheuneman and others about change.
“There are segments of people everywhere right now trying to do something, whether it’s that committee of athletic directors, whether it’s a lawyer or some legislators having conversations with the PIAA oversight committee,” Blundo said. “We all have to acknowledge at the end of the day that District 7 [WPIAL] isn’t the one to make the final decision on separate playoffs. But the groundswell has to be significant and we have to give everything we have from this district to try and create change.”
But getting back to those proposals from the committee of about 20 WPIAL athletic directors. Scheuneman said last week that changes in sectional alignment could only be made for the next two-year cycle in basketball and the AD’s proposals would be forwarded to the WPIAL basketball committee, which formulates section alignments. The basketball committee can decide whether to separate boundary and non-boundary schools in any section alignments and pass a recommendation to the WPIAL board.
But here we go again. The WPIAL board of directors shouldn’t let the basketball committee decide whether to make changes. If the WPIAL board really wants to listen to membership, it should demand the basketball committee comes up with sections that separate many — if not all — boundary and non-boundary schools.
I’ve seen the proposals. Without getting into particulars, I don’t particularly care for one that creates a three-tiered system for teams in the regular season. The second proposal makes much more sense and even goes as far as formulating a system that comes up with qualifiers if the PIAA does ever go to separate tournaments for boundary and non-boundary schools. But that proposal doesn’t address charter schools.
Well, let me save the WPIAL basketball committee and board of directors some time. May I offer the Mike White System:
This system doesn’t keep non-boundary schools from playing for WPIAL championships. It simply places those schools in sections with similar schools. In boys basketball, all WPIAL non-boundary schools would play in three sections, with the exception of Summit Academy, a school for adjudicated youth. Summit would continue to play in a section with boundary schools.
The sections might not make geographic sense for a few schools, but so what? Some sections currently aren’t the best for some schools geographically.
One boys section would have Central Catholic, North Catholic, Lincoln Park, Seton LaSalle, Shady Side Academy, OLSH, Imani Christian and Bishop Canevin. Due to the fact, that these teams come from five classifications, they would all make the WPIAL playoffs in their respective classifications.
The second section would include Sewickley Academy, Eden Christian, Nazareth Prep, Propel Montour and Aquinas Academy. The third section would have Serra, Greensburg Central Catholic, Propel Braddock Hills, Winchester Thurston, Neighborhood Academy, St. Joseph’s and Propel Andrew Street. The top four teams from the second and third sections would make the playoffs and play in their respective classification tournaments.
A similar system could be formulated for WPIAL girls basketball.
These systems won’t please everyone because they don’t have separate playoffs for boundary and non-boundary schools. But one of the complaints earlier this year from a group of more than three dozen athletic directors at smaller schools is that they don’t want to play non-boundary schools in the regular season. This system at least addresses that.
And every journey has to have a first step, right? So, how ‘bout it, WPIAL? It’s your move.
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.