A group of WPIAL athletic directors has made two proposals to the league’s hierarchy that would address the concerns of some public schools that no longer want to play Catholic/private/charter schools in the regular season.
And one of the proposals would put teams from WPIAL non-public schools in their own football and basketball sections in Class 2A and 1A.
The proposals came from a committee of about 20 ADs and were sent to WPIAL executive director Amy Scheuneman on Monday and Tuesday. The committee was formed recently by the WPIAL after a group of more than three dozen ADs from Class 1A, 2A and 3A public schools got together and asked the WPIAL to no longer schedule their sports teams against Catholic/private/charter schools that don’t have geographic boundaries to draw students.
Public schools feel those schools have an unfair advantage in sports because public schools can only draw students from their own geographic district.
Brian Geyer, athletic director at Peters Township, is the head of the AD committee appointed by the WPIAL. Geyer is also a member of the WPIAL board of directors, and he informed the board about the proposals at a meeting Wednesday. He talked mainly about the first proposal that is for basketball only and is being called a “pilot” for the 2022-23 season. But that proposal does not separate boundary and non-boundary schools for the regular season or playoffs.
The second proposal was for football and basketball and gave specific details of separate sections for Class 1A and 2A non-boundary teams in both sports. Those sections would have playoff qualifying standards the same as the sections with public schools. Under the proposal, Central Catholic, a Class 6A school, and North Catholic, a Class 4A school, would continue to play in sections with public schools because they are the only Catholic schools in those two classifications.
Read More
The WPIAL board decided to have the first proposal forwarded to the WPIAL basketball committee for examination. The WPIAL basketball committee makes recommendations for the WPIAL to consider. WPIAL executive director Amy Scheuneman said the second proposal was only received Tuesday and she and the board would need more time to examine it before deciding what to do.
“The (ADs) group knows it would be very aggressive to have this (first proposal) in for the upcoming two-year cycle (2022-24), but at least they want to get the juices flowing now,” Geyer told the board.
The first proposal would be a total overhaul of the WPIAL’s current system. The proposal has basketball teams deciding themselves where they want to play in a three-tiered system. Tier 1 would be for teams that are most competitive and expect to go far in the playoffs. Tier 2 would be for teams that are “middle of the road.” Tier 3 would be for “inexperienced, young teams that may have trouble competing at a high level.”
Sections would then be created by the tier selected and also classifications. But this system doesn’t separate boundary and non-boundary schools. The playoffs would be an “open” tournament with all teams eligible to participate. There would not be separate playoffs for boundary and non-boundary schools.
“The short version of this is that sections in the regular season would be based more on competitiveness,” Geyer said.
But the second proposal might get more traction with the WPIAL and other schools. It has Bishop Canevin, Serra, Seton LaSalle, Shady Side Academy, Greensburg Central Catholic, Imani Christian and Our Lady of the Sacred Heart playing in the same football conference and then qualifying teams for the regular WPIAL tournament.
In basketball, there would be two sections of non-boundary schools. The Class 2A section would have Greensburg Central Catholic, OLSH, Serra, Sewickley Academy and Winchester Thurston while the Class 1A section would have Aquinas Academy, Eden Christian, Imani Christian, Neighborhood Academy and St. Joseph. Playoff qualifiers would then play in the WPIAL tournament with boundary schools in the appropriate classification.
The committee formed by the WPIAL had athletic directors from both boundary and non-boundary schools. They met last week in person and on Zoom video Monday.
“The good thing is I think we were able to make some progress and even the non-boundary ADs agree that there is a problem,” said Carlynton athletic director Nate Milsom, who is a member of the committee. “Do I think something could happen by this basketball season? No. I think everything might be happening too fast. But do I think we’re headed in the right direction? Absolutely.
“If we would wait two years to start this project, I think it would lose steam. But something has to be done.”
Don Holl is the athletic director/football coach at Gateway High School who was most responsible for coming up with the language for the second proposal that puts Catholic/private/charter schools in their own sections for the regular season. Holl has a rather unique perspective. He is an AD at a public school, but attended Cathedral Prep in Erie as a youngster and also coached and was AD at that Catholic school.
“Everybody has said there is no way (PIAA executive director) Bob Lombardi will act on any of this,” Holl said. “Well, OK. But let’s at least put something forward and propose something that can at least be read or considered now. We felt like we had to at least get something going.”
Holl’s proposal even includes a plan for WPIAL teams if the PIAA wanted to have separate state playoffs for boundary and non-boundary schools in the future.
“We are not asking private, charter or parochial schools to leave the PIAA,” Holl said. “Part of what we are saying is that when the state law was put in place in 1972 to allow (non-boundary) schools in the PIAA, it was a whole different world of Catholic education. There were so many more Catholic elementary schools and even Catholic high schools that had geographic boundaries to draw kids. It’s a different model for those schools now.
“The other thing that nobody could’ve foreseen back in 1972 was the addition of charter schools, like Lincoln Park (in the WPIAL) or Imhotep (in Philadelphia). I’m not picking on them. But seeing the Catholic school model of then in 1972, and now in 2022, and the charter schools now, that’s what changes the game, no pun intended.
“We know these proposals aren’t something Bob Lombardi will say, ‘OK, we’ll do that.’ But is it a feasible, plausible system that might get support? We think so.”
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.