After losing to a team from Cincinnati at the Buckeye Elite Showcase over the weekend in Columbus, Andrew and Jacob Casey packed up their equipment and walked to their car, eager to get some rest and prepare for the next day of competition. But before they could go anywhere, they had to wait for their dad to finish taking pictures with the opposing team.
Such is life when your dad is former MLB All-Star first baseman Sean Casey.
He might not have been a bona-fide superstar during his playing days, but his steady play coupled with his friendly, charismatic demeanor endeared him to the fans of every team he played for — not to mention teammates and opponents alike. And other than his half-season stint with his hometown Pirates, it’s safe to say no fanbase appreciated him quite like that of the Cincinnati Reds, for whom he made three All-Star teams over eight seasons.
For Andrew, a rising senior at Upper St. Clair High School, and Jacob, a rising junior, there have always been pros and cons to being the son of a major leaguer, but the pros have typically outweighed the cons.
After all, most kids would probably be willing to wait an extra 15 minutes after a game if it means getting to meet legendary players such as Ken Griffey Jr. and Mike Trout.
“It gave us a really cool experience that other kids can’t say they had when they were younger,” Jacob said. “It’s really cool having him as a dad and getting the opportunity to meet really cool people like players and coaches when we were younger.”
Jacob and Andrew have reaped the benefits of being Sean Casey’s sons ever since they were little, and they’ll be taking everything they’ve learned into what will be their last season playing together at Upper St. Clair in the spring. The question is, will they step out of their dad’s shadow and establish their own legacy, or will they always be known simply as “Sean Casey’s kids”?
■ ■ ■
When he was playing first base at Upper St. Clair in the 1990s, not many would have penciled in Sean Casey for a 12-year career in the major leagues.
“I didn’t have much fanfare in high school — I had zero fanfare in high school as a matter of fact,” he said. “I had one scholarship offer to the University of Richmond. That’s how I ended up going there.
“It’s always good to fly under the radar and keep getting better at your craft, and eventually you pop up, and they say, ‘Where’d this guy come from?’”
Sean’s children won’t have that same luxury of catching people by surprise.
Andrew is a tall, wiry first baseman/outfielder who is already 6 feet 4 like his dad. According to former Mt. Lebanon coach Mark Saghy, who coaches Andrew and Jacob on their travel ball team, he’s starting to hit the ball like his old man, too.
“There’s no doubt Andrew this year has been our best hitter,” Saghy said. “He just hits the ball with a lot more authority. That ball makes a different sound off his bat, and he’s got a lot more confidence.”
That newfound power was evident in the tournament over the weekend, after Jacob struck out in one at-bat and handed the bat he shares with his brother to Andrew, who was standing on-deck.
“I’ve got your back,” Andrew told him, right before launching a home run.
Andrew has received a lot more attention from college scouts than his father did in high school, but those scouts’ eyes will have to focus elsewhere now. On April 26, he committed to play for the University of Dayton, getting his college decision out of the way now to focus on his senior year.
Not only will he be the anchor of Upper St. Clair’s lineup in baseball, he’s also expected to play a key role on the Panthers’ basketball team that looks like a WPIAL title contender.
“I’ve always played basketball through all my sports years, and I really enjoy it, so I’m going to play basketball my senior season and I’m really looking forward to it,” Andrew said. “I think we’re going to be pretty good.”
Although Andrew is forging his own path and going to a different college than the one his father attended, he’ll still be playing his college ball about 50 miles away from where his dad made a name for himself in the MLB. Which led Sean to ask Andrew the question, “Do you want to be in a place where you’re going to be known as Sean’s kid for a lot of people?”
Andrew responded, “Dad, I’ve been dealing with this since I was 5 years old.”
Jacob, meanwhile, is a 6-foot-tall infielder who has played shortstop his whole life but spent some time at second and third base this summer with the Steel City Wildcats, the travel team coached by Saghy. Time will tell if he grows to be as tall as his brother and his dad, but for now, he’s busy carving out his own niche as a quick, agile middle infielder — a far cry from what his dad was known for in the big leagues.
“Their movements are very athletic. Side-to-side, going for the ball, they’re a lot quicker [than their dad],” Saghy said. “Jake’s very fast. Andrew’s fast, but he doesn’t look it, because he’s got those long strides and he’s almost 6-5 now. Whereas Jake, he’s got those quick feet and that first step, and he utilizes that in the infield.”
Sean only stole 18 bases over 12 major league seasons, so where is all that footspeed coming from?
“They got their athleticism from their mother,” Saghy joked.
■ ■ ■
Despite the inherent competitive nature passed down to them by their parents, Andrew and Jacob have never butted heads, clashed egos or anything of that nature the way brothers typically do.
Saghy and his twin brother, Mike, an assistant coach for the Wildcats, just don’t understand it.
“We kid about it, because my brother and I coach together, and we always ask them, ‘Do you guys ever get in arguments or get in fights?’” Saghy said. “And they’re like, ‘Nope. Never.’ It’s really strange.”
Needless to say, Sean’s penchant for always being the friendliest guy in the room has rubbed off on his two sons.
“I think we’re just more than brothers — we’re just friends,” Jacob said. “We don’t really fight over things. I think Andrew’s quiet side is a big factor in that. He’s just a great guy, and there’s really nothing to fight about between us.”
Even though the two of them are as close as brothers can get, the time will come soon when they’re no longer teammates. After this season, Andrew will move on to Dayton, and Jacob has already decided he wants to go elsewhere when it’s his time to go off to college.
That means the two brothers will have to soak up every moment of the upcoming season together, knowing it will be their last as teammates.
“I think that knowing that this is the last season as high school players together, I’m going to take every moment in and not take anything for granted with him, because it’s going to go by quick,” Jacob said.
Steve Rotstein: srotstein@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SteveRotstein.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.