North Hills High School wrestling star Sam Hillegas

Sam Hillegas looks to be a most unassuming student at North Hills High School. A 5-foot-6, bespectacled teenager who considers pottery one of his favorite hobbies, Hillegas hardly cuts an imposing figure.

“A lot of people call him Harry Potter,” said Jason Hillegas, Sam’s father.

But put Hillegas on a wrestling mat and something happens. The kid who is a big fan of Avengers movies becomes a Transformer. He goes from nice little Sammy to Slammin’ Sammy. He throws kids to the mat, twists them into human pretzels and, to put it bluntly, just dominates.

Wrestling is Hillegas’ gig. And as great wrestlers go in Western Pennsylvania, Hillegas got next.

Advertise with us

Hillegas is a junior at North Hills with the brightest of futures. He has a legitimate chance at becoming only the 14th wrestler in Pennsylvania history (seventh from the WPIAL) to win four PIAA championships. He has accepted a scholarship to Virginia Tech.

Sam I Am is already an accomplished wrestler, winning two state championships as a freshman and sophomore. Hillegas has only one loss in his high school career and last week won the 132-pound division at the prestigious Powerade Tournament.

Western Pennsylvania has had some great wrestlers, like Cary Kolat of Jefferson-Morgan and, most recently, Franklin Regional’s Spencer Lee. No one is giving Hillegas legendary status now, but the greatness needle might already be pointing toward him.

And about that transformation when Hillegas gets on a mat …

“It’s all about training, the mental attitude and how he handles the grind,” said North Hills wrestling coach Jose Martinez. “You’ll see champions where that light bulb turns on after the second or third year of varsity. They get hungry. But Sam was hungry in middle school.”

Advertise with us

Hillegas has a reputation at North Hills as the nicest, most courteous of kids. He is studious, carrying a 3.6 grade-point average. He likes going to movies with his grandma and singing made-up songs with his friends next to a campfire. Many mornings before school, you might see Hillegas carrying heavy bags of clay to a classroom. Jason Hillegas is a longtime pottery teacher at North Hills and also is a volunteer assistant coach for the wrestling team. Sam has taken a liking to pottery and takes advanced pottery classes at North Hills.

“I carry 100-pound bags,” Sam Hillegas said of the clay.

When it comes to wrestling, Jason Hillegas says his son is wired a little differently than most kids. That’s evident when Sam talks about his mindset in his early years on the mat.

“Honestly, it was to make a kid cry,” said Hillegas. “I started realizing at a young age that if I can get after this kid and get in his head, I’m good from there. It was my goal: If I could make a kid cry, that was awesome.”

Sam is the oldest of four children to Jason and Leigh Hillegas. Dad wrestled as a freshman and sophomore at Baldwin High School, but was more into football. He played on coach Don Yannessa’s first team at Baldwin in 1989 and went on to play football at Mercyhurst University.

Advertise with us

Sam was young when Dad decided to sign him up for a youth wrestling program in Shaler (the Hillegas family lived in Shaler until moving to the North Hills School District when Sam was in sixth grade).

“At Shaler, you could start wrestling at 6 years old,” said Jason Hillegas. “He needed something to do in the winter. He was our first kid and he was so active. He was always climbing onto things and getting into something.”

Sam remembers that first practice as a 6-year-old.

“I thought it was going to be like the WWE,” said Sam. “It was nothing like I thought and I remember I was the smallest one there.”

It wasn’t long before Sam Hillegas was large in wrestling. By third grade, he won a state junior championship. Since third grade, he has been a state champion every year, either in juniors or the PIAA. He is a two-time WPIAL champ.

Advertise with us

During his elementary school years, Hillegas wrestled on a junior team with some of the top wrestlers around Western Pa., including Lee, a three-time state champ who lost once in his high school career and is now one of the top collegiate wrestlers in the country at the University of Iowa.

“It’s been kind of cool,” said Sam Hillegas, “being able to grow up at the same time as [Lee], wrestling with him, following him and saying, ‘OK, if he’s doing this and working at the highest level, I’ve got to do the same thing.’ I just want to dominate from everywhere.”

In other words, greatness rubbed off on Hillegas.

“You also have to give tribute to Sam’s dad for taking him to top-notch tournaments when he was younger,” said Martinez. “Because you either get whooped at those things or you get hungrier and hungrier. Sam just got hungrier. Now he’s so hungry.”

But Sam is modest also. Although he talks about goals of winning state titles, NCAA titles and possibly making the Olympics someday, he professes the one-match-at-a-time theme.

Advertise with us

“For sure I want to be one of the greats,” said Hillegas. “But sometimes people get ahead of themselves and say some things that are hard to believe.”

Martinez has been a believer for a while. In the fall of Hillegas’ freshman year, Martinez was telling people at North Hills that Hillegas had the makings of a four-time state champ and possibly another Spencer Lee. Some laughed, but not now.

Hillegas has molded himself into a star wrestler, kind of like those vases, cups and mugs he makes in pottery class.

“I made a nice chalice this year, too,” said Hillegas.

At North Hills, Hillegas breaks the mold.

Advertise with us

“Everyone says they want to win four state titles. So many come up short,” said Hillegas. “When you win the first one, you start believing in yourself more and then the second one happens. There are things to focus on. Anything can happen, like an injury tweak in practice. You just have to take one step at a time.”

And then transform.

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh