Any high school sophomore, junior or senior athlete in Pennsylvania who transfers schools faces ineligibility for postseason play at their new schools.
And any football or basketball teams that go far in the playoffs the next two years and also use a number of transfers, might have to move up in classification under a new “competition success formula.”
Those two situations are realities after the PIAA board of directors passed two new rules Wednesday at a meeting in State College. Usually, a proposal must pass three readings, but the PIAA suspended protocol and made the rules part of the PIAA by-laws after only two readings. The success formula passed unanimously and the transfer rule by a 27-2 vote.
The two new rules could be considered major changes, but they are the PIAA’s attempt to address, at least partially, growing complaints about private/Catholic/charter schools having a perceived athletic advantage because they don’t have geographic boundaries to draw students. Public schools can draw students only from their geographic district. Many superintendents in Pennsylvania have called for the PIAA to make separate playoff tournaments for public and non-public schools.
“These are absolutely major changes,” said PIAA executive director Bob Lombardi. “This is a major paradigm shift. Not only did we address transfers, but competitive balance. In my opinion, this is one of the biggest changes in the landscape in the last 30 years I’ve been [with the PIAA].”
The three WPIAL representatives on the PIAA board voted for the new rules — North Hills School District superintendent Pat Mannarino, Mars athletic director Scott Heinauer and Hopewell principal Mike Allison.
Read More
“I voted yes because my thinking is that it’s not so much a private school vs. non-boundary rule in my mind,” Mannarino said. “It’s a transfer issue and a matter of how can we slow the transfers that are motivated by athletics. There is no magic bullet to the question of whether the transfer rule is effective. Maybe we’ve captured some of that group that may be transferring for athletic purposes.”
The transfer rule says any athlete who transfers schools after the start of their 10th-grade year will be ineligible to compete in district or PIAA playoffs in any sport they participated in the previous year. The rule goes into effect Aug. 6. Those who transfer before Aug. 6 will not be affected.
The ineligibility could be waived by a district committee for a hardship. But the rule says academic needs and “development, spiritual, and/or social reasons” are not hardship reasons. A change in residence necessitate by employment may qualify as a hardship.
The competition success formula rule that was passed deals with postseason success and transfers and is only for football and boys and girls basketball teams. Under the formula:
• Advancing to a district championship — such as the WPIAL —would give a team one point, the PIAA quarterfinals two points, the PIAA semifinals three and a PIAA championship four. It’s important to note that points are not cumulative in a season. If a team goes to a PIAA title game, it gets only four points.
• If a football and basketball team reaches six points or more over a two-year span and also exceeds the maximum number of transfers allowed, then the school moves up one classification when the PIAA realigns every two years. The maximum number of transfer students allowed on a team over a two-year span is two in basketball and five in football.
• A school must hit six points and also have the maximum number of transfers before that school will be moved up one classification. Teams that are successful and don’t reach the maximum number of transfers are unaffected by the rule. Also, teams that might have a number of transfers, but don’t go far in the postseason will not be affected.
A question in the competition success formula is what will happen if a Class 6A team needs to be bumped up in class? The PIAA’s original plan hoped to create a seventh class for those teams. But that idea was dropped. So, nothing will happen if any 6A team reaches six points and the maximum number of transfers.
The PIAA will start to track playoff success and transfers over the next two school years. Starting this school year, the PIAA is requiring schools to register all student-athlete transfers in an online portal. Teams hitting six points and also reaching the maximum number of transfers would be bumped up in classification starting with the 2020-21 school year.
Would this new rule affect many teams? A Post-Gazette examination of the last two school years showed only 36 teams — 12 in football, 10 in boys basketball and 14 in girls basketball — would have reached the minimum six points needed to be bumped up one classification. Remember, those teams would also have to hit the maximum number of transfers. No WPIAL football team reached six points the past two years. Five WPIAL boys basketball teams and two girls basketball teams would have reached six points.
On Wednesday, 11 of the most successful coaches in WPIAL football history — some active and some retired — got together for an informal luncheon at the Grand View Golf Club in Braddock. When they learned of the PIAA’s new competition success formula rule, most were not in favor.
“It’s going to be insignificant because it’s going to affect so few teams,” said Thomas Jefferson coach Bill Cherpak, who has won six WPIAL titles and has been outspoken against non-public school teams. “The teams that would be affected, they will find a way around it.”
Former North Hills coach and school principal Jack McCurry said: “It still doesn’t address the real problem and that is the schools with no boundaries. If they want to give public schools a chance, they should have separate playoffs.”
West Allegheny coach Bob Palko, whose eight titles are the most in WPIAL football history, said, “There has to be an issue or [the PIAA] wouldn’t be addressing this. At least maybe they’re trying to do something about it. That’s better than doing nothing.”
Lombardi has made the point before that the PIAA has no interest in having separate playoff tournaments for public and non-public schools because he claims it would go against a state legislature ruling passed in the early 1970s. He reiterated that point Wednesday, going against critics that don’t believe the new rules address the public vs. private issue.
“We don’t agree with the naysayers,” said Lombardi. “We’re going to comply with the law. Private, charter and parochial schools are part of our membership and need to be treated as full members. We are not segregating unless the legislature changes the law.”
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh
Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.