The governing body of Pennsylvania high school athletics is close to adopting a new rule that would make some high school football and basketball teams move up in classification if they go far in the postseason and do it with transfer student-athletes.
But it’s questionable if the new rule would affect all that many schools and whether it would bring satisfaction to those clamoring for separate postseason tournaments for public and private schools.
The PIAA board of directors’ summer meeting is Wednesday in Mechanicsburg. One of the main topics on the agenda is a vote on a “competition success formula” for football and basketball. The rule has passed one reading and needs to pass two more before becoming part of the PIAA bylaws, but executive director Bob Lombardi said the board could suspend protocol and adopt the rule after only two readings. That is a definite possibility, and if the PIAA approves the rule, teams could be bumped up in classification starting in the 2020-21 school year.
Another rule the PIAA will consider deals with postseason ineligibility for student-athlete transfers. The PIAA is considering making a student-athlete ineligible for district and state playoffs if they transfer after the start of ninth grade. However, the PIAA might push back the ineligible period to the start of 10th grade, and there would still be some exceptions.
The proposals would be major rule changes and part of the PIAA’s answers to growing complaints about private/Catholic/charter schools winning too many championships and having an advantage because, unlike public schools, they don’t have geographic boundaries. Transfers are having a big effect on sports at some private/Catholic/charter schools, especially in Philadelphia.
Using the past two school years as an example, the competition success formula would affect — at the most — about one dozen schools in football and boys and girls basketball.
Read More
Many Pennsylvania superintendents have called for the PIAA to establish separate postseason tournaments for boundary and non-boundary schools. The PIAA has shown reluctance to the idea, and Lombardi has said the competition success formula rule should address some of the complaints.
“Is this the best answer or what everyone wants? No,” said Bob Palko, longtime West Allegheny football coach. “But at least it’s something.”
More than 100 superintendents and principals across Pennsylvania will attend a “playoff equity summit” July 24 in State College to come up with solutions to the public vs. private issue and to formulate a formal plan to give to the PIAA. One point of discussion will be pulling out of the PIAA.
John Sarandrea, superintendent of New Castle Area Schools, has helped put together the summit.
“Leaving the PIAA is only a point of discussion. It’s not the focus of the summit,” said Sarandrea. “Our goal is to explore other options, come up with a few plans and we want to be heard on those plans.”
Explaining the rules
The PIAA competition success formula, if passed, might be confusing to some, but it would apply to only football and boys and girls basketball in Pennsylvania. “We feel like those are the sports where most of the complaints come from, so our thought was to address only those sports right now,” said Lombardi.
Under the formula, teams could be bumped up in classification only if they do two things: advance far into the postseason in two consecutive seasons and exceed the maximum number of student-athletes allowed in that sport. If the PIAA votes to adopt the rule in 2018, it would not affect football or basketball teams until the 2020-21 school year.
In explaining the rule, it should be noted classifications for sports teams in Pennsylvania are based on enrollment. The basic points of the competition success formula are:
• Advancing to a district championship — such as the WPIAL — would give a team one point; the PIAA quarterfinals two points; the PIAA semifinals three; and a PIAA championship four. It’s important to note that points are not cumulative. For example, if a team makes it to the PIAA semifinals, it is assessed only three points. If it goes to a PIAA title game, it gets only four.
• If a school reaches six points or more over a two-year span and also exceeds the maximum number of transfers allowed, the school moves up one classification. The maximum number of transfers allowed over a two-year span is two in basketball and five in football.
• A school must hit six points and also have the maximum number of transfers before that school will be moved up one classification. Teams that are successful and don’t reach the maximum number of transfers would be unaffected, as would be teams that might have a number of transfers, but don’t go far in the postseason.
In other words, a team that wins without transfers is fine. But consider that a team could have 10 transfers in two years; if that team doesn’t go at least to the PIAA semifinals once in a two-year period, it will be unaffected. Teams must reach that round at least once in two years to reach six points.
Who would be affected?
The Post-Gazette used the past two school years as an example to see how many teams would be affected by the competition success formula. Only 36 teams — 12 in football, 10 in boys basketball and 14 in girls basketball — would have reached the minimum six points needed to be bumped up one classification. Remember, those teams would also have to hit the maximum number of transfers (five in football and two in basketball) in order to be bumped up in class. Starting this school year, the PIAA will institute an online portal this fall to track transfers. All schools must register all transfers.
On the WPIAL level, not one football team hit six points over the past two years in the competition success formula. Pine-Richland, Mars, Quaker Valley, Sewickley Academy and Our Lady of the Sacred Heart had six points in boys basketball. In girls basketball, only North Allegheny and Bishop Canevin had six.
Around the state, some highly successful basketball teams with a history of transfer students did not reach six points the past two years. Among them were Philadelphia schools Archbishop Carroll, Roman Catholic and Math, Civics & Sciences.
Here are the teams outside the WPIAL that would have had six points in the success formula the past two years:
Football — St. Joseph’s Prep, Archbishop Wood, Berks Catholic, Bethlehem Catholic, Erie Cathedral Prep, Imhotep Charter, Middletown, Southern Columbia, Wilmington, Bishop Guilfoyle, Farrell, Steelton-Highspire.
Boys basketball — Abington Heights, Imhotep Charter, Neumann-Goretti, Constitution, Kennedy Catholic.
Girls basketball — Souderton, Archbishop Wood, Lancaster Catholic, Villa Maria, Neumann-Goretti, West Catholic, Minersville, Bellwood-Antis, Lebanon Catholic, Jenkintown, Juniata Valley, Bishop Carroll.
Good and bad
Lombardi said the transfer rule and the competition success formula, if passed, will address some of the perceived advantages that private/Catholic/charter schools have in athletics and attracting transfer students.. Also, the teams that win with regularity and do it without transfers are not penalized. That’s a good thing.
But the success formula has its flaws, and one has to wonder if it will have much of an effect. First off: the points system used for playoff success. If teams have to get to six points over two years to be bumped up in class, one point is meaningless, because the most a team can get in a year is four (if they make it to the PIAA championship). The bottom line is a team has to get to the PIAA semifinals at least once in two years to reach six points over two years.
Also, do you think a Philadelphia school like Neumann-Goretti, which has been known for using a number of transfers for girls and boys basketball success, really cares if it has to move from Class 3A to 4A? Of course not. Do you think Erie Cathedral Prep’s football team would care if it had to move from 4A to 5A? Probably not.
Another knock against the success formula is what happens to a team in 6A if it needs to get bumped up, like St. Joseph’s Prep of Philadelphia in football; Lombardi said a separate classification (7A) would be used, but over the past two years, St. Joseph’s is the only football team in 6A that had enough points. Pine-Richland was the only such boys basketball team in 6A.
Lombardi’s counter: Teams can play up in Class 7A under their own choosing. But eight football teams and 16 basketball teams would be needed to create a 7A tier. Does the PIAA really think that six or seven football teams will “choose” to play in 7A, and 14 or 15 basketball teams will do the same? That’s highly unlikely.
So even if the new rules are passed, the problems and complaints about private/Catholic/charter school sports will not go away.
“We plan to come up with several plans [at the superintendent summit],” said Sarandrea. “One is separate the public and private schools for the playoffs until the end when you have only one private and one public team. One is to have two totally separate tournaments. We feel like what is being proposed now is like kicking the can down the road or putting a Band-Aid on it.”
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.