Thomas Jefferson dominated its way to a WPIAL title, barely challenged by any opponent, winning every game by at least three touchdowns.

But life changed dramatically for the Jaguars when it was time to act in a stately manner.

For the second consecutive season, Thomas Jefferson’s hopes for a PIAA championship were dashed by Erie Cathedral Prep. A year ago, it was in the PIAA semifinals. This year, it was a little earlier. The Thomas Jefferson team that been so impressive was rambled by Ramblers again.

Cathedral Prep came to Pittsburgh Friday night and thumped Thomas Jefferson, 30-13, in a PIAA Class 4A quarterfinal game at Baldwin High School. Thomas Jefferson ended the season with a 12-1 record.

Advertise with us

A year ago, Thomas Jefferson lost to Cathedral Prep by a touchdown. This time, Thomas Jefferson fell behind, 20-0, at halftime. The Jaguars closed to within a touchdown in the third quarter, but got no closer. Cathedral Prep, the Post-Gazette’s No. 2 Class 4A team in the state, mostly stuffed Thomas Jefferson’s strong running game and got another big performance from Joe Mischler, son of coach Mike Mischler, who finished with 276 yards offense.

PIAA Playoffs: Thomas Jefferson vs. Cathedral Prep

Thomas Jefferson coach Bill Cherpak wasn’t surprised his team lost. He knew the Jaguars faced a mighty task against a Cathedral Prep team that had eliminated the WPIAL Class 3A champ four of the previous six seasons. But Cherpak kind of threw his hands up after the game, as if to say, “What can you do?”

“I don’t know if this appropriate or not to say,” Cherpak said, pausing for a few seconds. “but this is about what it is for a public school like us. The days of public schools winning state championships are dying because you can’t compete with these schools that have no [geographical] boundaries and get can get players from anywhere.

“As good as they are, it’s hard. They have size, they have skill players, they have everything it takes. I don’t know what to do. I just think the days are gone of public school districts winning, especially in a  class like 4A.

”It was an impressive showing by a Cathedral Prep team that held Thomas Jefferson to 46 yards rushing in the first half. Thomas Jefferson senior halfback Quinton Hill came in with more than 4,300 career yards rushing. Although he finished with 113 yards on 14 carries, most of those came late in the game on a few long runs.

Advertise with us

“We knew they had great linebackers and great defensive linemen,” said Zane Zandier, Thomas Jefferson’s standout senior receiver-defensive back. “Their players in the box on defense were phenomenal.”

Joe Mischler was pretty good, too. A junior, Mischler completed 18 of 31 for 208 yards and also ran for 68 yards on 17 carries. He hurt Thomas Jefferson in a variety of ways after the Jaguars hurt Mischler on the fourth play of the game. Mischler also punts, and Thomas Jefferson was called for roughing the kicker. Joe Mischler, who came in with more than 2,300 yards passing, rolled around on the field in pain after the hit with a knee injury. His father had a lump in his throat.

“I was terrified,” Mike Mischler said. “He goes out, it changes everything we are. … He’s everything you want in a quarterback, especially when he’s your kid. I’ve been waiting my whole life to have this opportunity with him. It’s special having him do this stuff.”

Joe Mischler returned to the game a few plays later and had a great impact. He completed 12 of 22 for 171 yards in the first half, threw for two touchdowns and ran for one. One touchdown pass came on a fourth-down play and another with 6 seconds left in the half. On fourth-and-4 at the Thomas Jefferson 20, Tyler Oedekoven ran a slant  and caught the ball on his knees for Cathedral Prep’s first touchdown.

Cathedral Prep moved 70 yards in seven plays for another score in the second quarter. Mischler capped this march with a 16-yard run with 2:24 left in the half.

Advertise with us

Thomas Jefferson moved the ball with some success in the first half, but had problems in Ramblers territory. The Jaguars moved to the Cathedral Prep  8 early in the second quarter, but an illegal-procedure penalty was followed by a delay-of-game penalty. Those two miscues were followed by a sack that moved the Jaguars back to the 23. A fourth-down pass fell incomplete.

With six seconds left in the half, Mischler threw to Terry Roberts for the first time all night, and Roberts hauled it in for a 34-yard touchdown.

Thomas Jefferson got on the scoreboard in the third quarter when Bobby Kelley hit Jake Gregerich with a 3-yard touchdown pass on a fourth-down play. Zandier, who finished with seven receptions for 113 yards, caught a 27-yard touchdown pass from Kelley to make it 20-13 with 3:28 left. But Thomas Jefferson never seriously threatened again.

“Honestly, I think we had plenty of opportunities in the first half, but self-destructed,” Cherpak said. “we had penalties, got sacked and I don’t know how many passes we dropped in the first half.”

Zandier summed things up.

Advertise with us

“Part of me is saying we did a lot, but part of me is saying we did the same thing as last year. I think we should’ve made it further than we did.”

Mike white: mwhite@post-gazette.Com and twitter @mwhiteburgh.