From virtually the moment that Brett Brumbaugh broke the WPIAL career passing record earlier this season, an unavoidable question was raised -- how long will this mark actually stand?

It wasn't any kind of indictment against the South Fayette senior, who has pieced together a remarkable career. If anything, it was just a reflection of a pedestal that's been on a shaky foundation of late.

The player whom Brumbaugh surpassed with his 304-yard outing against Steel Valley on Oct. 3, Sto-Rox's Lenny Williams, had set the record only last year. Williams had broken the record previously set by Brumbaugh's older brother, Christian, just three years earlier.

So, naturally, there might be a little skepticism about the longevity that Brett Brumbaugh's accomplishment might have.

Advertise with us

But should such pessimism exist? In the case of the younger Brumbaugh, maybe it shouldn't.

Last Friday in a victory against South Park in the WPIAL Class AA quarterfinals, the Lions quarterback threw for 382 yards, becoming the first player in WPIAL history with 10,000 career passing yards (he has 10,036).

How much higher can that figure get? This season, he is averaging 243.6 passing yards per game, meaning that even if South Fayette wins this week and loses in the WPIAL championship on Nov. 21, he is on pace to finish with 10,523 career yards. If the Lions make it back to the state championship, as they did last season, that projection would jump to 11,252.

Either one of those totals would put him well past Williams' 8,508 yards, effectively placing Brumbaugh on an island in the WPIAL record books, far away from any ambitious and able passer who would try to catch up to him.

For a quarterback to get close to five-digit passing totals, an almost perfect set of circumstances has to exist.

Advertise with us

One doesn't have to look further than Brumbaugh for proof. He started three games as a freshman and has held the position ever since. He's played in a well-designed, pass-heavy spread offense. And, obviously, he has the talent needed to excel in that kind of a big way.

Here's another way to look at it. If a quarterback started every game of his high school career and made the WPIAL championship each of those years, he would need to average just shy of 200 passing yards per game to reach where Brumbaugh is right now, a pretty unlikely scenario, even from a hypothetical standpoint.

Obviously, nothing can ever be ruled out. Modern offenses are increasingly geared toward throwing the ball -- 39 quarterbacks in the WPIAL and City League passed for at least 1,000 yards this season -- and there could very well be a once-in-a-generation talent playing youth football whose name we won't know about for years.

But for someone to surpass the bar set by Brumbaugh, they're going to need to be awfully special. And even that might not be enough.

Chayse Dillon: A senior running back for West Allegheny, he rushed for 153 yards and two touchdowns in the Indians' 37-14 victory against Franklin Regional. In two postseason games in 2014, the senior has rushed for 284 yards.

Advertise with us

Jason Dambach: It came in a loss that ended his team's season -- a 31-14 setback against Avonworth -- but Riverside's starting quarterback threw for 274 yards and two fourth quarter touchdowns. Dambach, a junior, had 2,332 passing yards and 18 touchdowns this season.

Nick Ponikvar: South Fayette's 39-21 win against South Park was a little closer than some may have expected, but Ponikvar, a junior wide receiver played a key role in helping his team win, catching six passes for 173 yards and two touchdowns.

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG