Sewickley Academy golf coach Win Palmer has a real dilemma on his hands.
Before every match, he has to look down a list of 11 players, nine of whom have single-digit handicaps, and has to decide who gets to fill out the six slots for the day.
"Throughout the season we're shifting lineups all the time," Palmer said. "It doesn't matter if it's a section match, a non-section match, we're shifting all the time and we rarely put out our 'best' lineup on the course, because I don't know what it is."
It's a quandary most WPIAL coaches would give up their own short game to have. With such a powerful lineup boasting incredible depth, it's little wonder the Panthers rolled to their second consecutive WPIAL Class AA team title last week -- and fifth in the past nine years -- with a 20-stroke win against Burgettstown at the Cedarbrook Gold Course in Rostraver.
"It's really different when you're playing individually because there's nobody relying on you and it's all about what you do," said Sewickley Academy senior Anthony Muscato, who was the Class AA medalist in the finals with a 2-over-par 74. "There's a lot less pressure playing individually because you're the one who has to suffer if you don't play well and you're not affecting anyone else."
To say Muscato was the epitome of consistency would be an understatement. Playing on the Gold Course in the final at Cedarbrook, he made an incredible 17 pars and one double-bogey on No. 8, a 389-yard par 4.
"It felt pretty good and I knew the back nine was going to be a little harder," Muscato said. "I just played solid in kind of tough position and it felt good to shoot a decent number and put my team in position."
Muscato may have had the low score of the round, but Sewickley Academy wouldn't have won were it not for tremendous efforts by four other starters. Following Muscato were sophomores Jason Li (78), Declan Hickton (82), Sam Sauter (82) and senior Chris Johnson (86).
"The biggest thing about the success we've had the last couple years is that it's not just a sport we like to play, but we're very passionate about the game, being together and playing together," Johnson said.
"In the spring and summer, we're playing together almost every day, so the 11 of us just spend a lot of time together and it's just a lot of fun to be a part of it."
That summertime dedication shows up in the results. And it's also highly recommended by their coach.
"We tell our kids that they have to play in tournaments in the summer, and that's what separates who's really ready to go," Palmer said. "I have them email me the scores so I know they're playing in the tournaments."
Still, winning the WPIAL title is only the precursor for a team that has thoughts of a state championship. In 2013, the Panthers also made an appearance in the finals, but came up short by six shots after Holy Redeemer, won the title in a playoff against Wyomissing.
When Sewickley Academy tees off Oct. 22 at Heritage Hills in York, though, it will be the true test as to whether that extra practice, camaraderie and depth pays off with a state title.
"I always tell the kids, I'm not going to change your swings, that's for your swing coaches, but I can help you with the mental approach," Palmer said.
"I can tell you when you're gambling too much or where you're in a position to make bogey and instead press and make double and those are the types of conversations that I have with the kids."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.