Maybe it's all a matter of perspective. Not all that long ago, maybe Penn State fans wouldn't be happy with a recruiting class ranked anywhere from 25 to 35 in the country.
National Signing Day: The local list
But after four losing seasons in the past five years, a class teetering on the top 25 seems to be reason for optimism.
Penn State's recruiting class of 19 players is ranked by most recruiting services near the top 25. The class includes two of Super Prep's top 10 players in the country in receiver Derrick Williams of Greenbelt, Md., and defensive back Justin King of Gateway High School in the WPIAL.
Yesterday, Penn State also landed a talented linebacker when Jerome Hayes of Bayonne, N.J., announced he had signed with the Nittany Lions. They lost a recruit, though, when linebacker Steve Quinn of Philadelphia St. Joseph's Prep signed with Notre Dame. Quinn had made a verbal commitment to Penn State. Besides King, the other WPIAL player in this class is Upper St. Clair's Sean Lee, who was recruited to play linebacker.
The main question with Penn State's recruiting class is not with the headliners, such as Williams, King, Hayes or Lydell Sargeant, a receiver/running back from Lompoc, Calif. It's with the players who are below the headliners.
One recruiting analyst called the class "odd." Allen Wallace, publisher of Super Prep magazine and national recruiting editor for Scout.com, said, "I think this is one of the most difficult classes to look at. It makes a guy like me schizophrenic. You just don't know what to do with it.
"Williams and King are two of the most fantastic players in the country. They also have a few other top players. The problem is they have about 10 athletes who I would call only two- or three-star players. They aren't even ranked in the top 50 in the country at their position."
Jeremy Crabtree of Rivals.com said Penn State's class could be called "top heavy" with talent. Rivals ranked Penn State's class No. 26 while Scout.com ranked it 29th. Wallace said he would rank Penn State somewhere between 30 and 35.
But Penn State isn't done recruiting yet. Talented receiver Todd Nolen of Hampton, Va., still hasn't made a decision and might visit Penn State this weekend.
"Getting Hayes late was a big one for Penn State," said Bobby Burton of Rivals.com. "I would say it's a very solid group overall. What I think is interesting is would Penn State fans be happy with this class 15 or 20 years ago?"
As recently as five years ago, Penn State's class was ranked No. 6 in the country by Super Prep. Other recent classes have been ranked in the top 20, but that hasn't translated into victories.
One thing this class proves is Penn State coach Joe Paterno still has something left on his recruiting fastball. Phil Grosz runs G&W Recruiting in State College and believes Penn State's class should be rated between 15-20 in the country.
"I don't know a team that recruited better for need," Grosz said. "They got four cornerbacks and four receivers. If they get Nolen, they'll get more speed, too. Those are the positions where they had a need. They also have nine guys with 4.5 speed in the 40 or better."
Knowledge Timmons, a defensive back from York, Pa., is the defending PIAA Class AAA 100-meter champion in track.
But one area that's been a problem for Penn State's team is the offensive line. The Nittany Lions signed only two offensive linemen -- Dennis Landolt of Delran, N.J., and Matt Lowry of Springfield, Pa.
"Just about every guy that started for Penn State last year was the linemen of the year in their particular state as a senior," Grosz said. "I think a bigger question has to be why aren't the coaches developing the offensive line talent?"
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.