Aliquippa has had its fair share of battles with the PIAA over the years in determining which classification the football program would be assigned.

This time, however, the two parties didn’t have to go to court to figure it out.

On Wednesday, Aliquippa was informed it had won its appeal to the state sports governing body to drop down from Class 4A to Class 3A for the upcoming biennial realignment that will include the 2026-27 and 2027-28 school years.

“Just based on the competition formula and based on our success points and enrollment and the health and safety issue as well as the lack of transfers, that’s where we should be,” Aliquippa football coach Mike Warfield said. “We appreciate them hearing our arguments and agreeing with us based on the facts.”

Advertise with us

Aliquippa is the reigning WPIAL Class 4A champion and lost to Twin Valley in the state semifinals in November.

But while Aliquippa is moving down, Baldwin has opted to move out. The Highlanders football program has struggled mightily over the years, one of the low points being its current 29-game losing streak.

So, in hopes of becoming more competitive, the Baldwin-Whitehall School District announced Wednesday that it will leave the WPIAL and compete as an independent football program for the next two seasons.

“After evaluating roster composition, participation levels, and long-term program development, district leadership determined that competing independently for the next two years best supports student-athlete safety and competitive growth,” a press release from the district explained.

The statement pointed to the WPIAL’s new conference alignment, one that would once again have Class 5A Baldwin competing against the likes of Peters Township, Upper St. Clair and Bethel Park, as being one of the reasons for the move.

Advertise with us

“Our responsibility is to make decisions that prioritize student safety and sustainable development,” superintendent Randal Lutz said in the statement. “We are very excited about the large freshman class entering our program. However, we must also recognize the physical and competitive realities of asking 14- and 15-year-old student-athletes to compete weekly against senior-dominant teams. This two-year window allows our players time to grow, develop, and build confidence.”

This past season was a particularly tough one for Baldwin, which finished 0-10, was outscored, 558-74, and lost five games by at least 50 points. Things got so bad that, in late September, athletic director Tony Cherico emailed a letter to Baldwin’s final five opponents, asking them to play the games under a running clock and to use junior varsity players more than usual.

“I know you are all aware of our struggles, so I am asking a favor or two,” Cherico wrote then.

One of the major hurdles has been getting students to participate. Baldwin had only about 30 players on the team last season, an extremely low number for a Class 5A school.

While Baldwin will be an independent for at least two seasons, the district is leaving the door open for a return in 2028.

Advertise with us

“This is about long-term stability,” Lutz added. “At the conclusion of this two-year cycle, we fully intend to evaluate re-entry into WPIAL conference competition when our current freshman class transitions into upperclassmen leadership roles.”

Baldwin’s decision comes after four schools — Albert Gallatin, Brownsville, Connellsville and Uniontown — announced that they will be returning to the WPIAL in the fall after playing independent football schedules in recent seasons. Albert Gallatin went 10-0 last season.

Aliquippa could have been in the same boat, at least in the short term.

When the PIAA last realigned before the 2024 football season the organization had determined because of its success points system and the number of transfers into the school Aliquippa should move up from Class 4A to Class 5A, which prompted a court battle between the two that ended with injunctive relief that allowed the Quips to remain in Class 4A for 2024 and 2025.

“It was based on the health and safety of our kids and, playing teams two and three times our size, added stress and pressure, not just physically but mentally,” Warfield said. “Unfortunately in previous years, some of the rules they applied for health and safety didn’t take into account kids who are transient, coming and going and some of our kids who are going to charter schools. [This time] they looked at the facts and the facts spoke for themselves”

Advertise with us

When the PIAA increased from four to six classifications before the 2016-17 school year Aliquippa, which was at the time a Class 1A school in attendance and was competing in Class 2A opted to play in Class 3A. The Quips played in the WPIAL Class 3A championship game every year from 2016-19, winning both the WPIAL and state championships in 2018, which prompted a move up to Class 4A.

Despite the controversy, Aliquippa thrived in Class 4A. The Quips played in five of the six WPIAL championship games -- the only exception being in 2024 – won four titles (2021-23 and 2025) and won state championships in 2021 and 2023.

According to the latest numbers Aliquippa would be classified as a Class 2A school with 158 male students expected to be enrolled. Beaver Falls, with a 200-student male population, is the smallest Class 3A school in the state not playing up.

But even though Aliquippa is moving down in classification, it doesn’t mean the competition will be any easier. The Quips lost to Avonworth last season, likely a conference opponent when the WPIAL unveils its updated alignment in the next couple of weeks, and the Antelopes are the reigning WPIAL and PIAA Class 3A champion.

“I have a lot of respect for coach [Duke Johncour] and he and I text at times and I have mad respect for how he runs his program,” Warfield said. “They’re going to be a challenge and we have other teams that are going to be a challenge. [Playing easier competition] is not the purpose. What is the purpose is the health and safety of the kids and we’re happy for that.”