One in an occasional series on top players, athletes and teams in WPIAL and City League sports since 2000.

With the City League championship complete and the WPIAL championships only a week away, what better time to come up with the list of the best teams in the district since the turn of the century.

The top 10 includes some teams from smaller classifications and there’s no way those teams would be a strong 5A or 6A team in a straight up game. But when deciding the 10 best WPIAL and City League teams since 2000, I decided teams should be considered on how they fared on their own level. Some WPIAL teams were terrific and dominant in a smaller classification and deserve top 10 status.

I also decided it would be tough to put a team in the top 10 that didn’t win a state championship. But one exception was made for the No. 10 team that lost in the state final.

Advertise with us

This top 10 list includes some perfect teams and memorable players.

1. SCHENLEY 2007

This was an easy pick for No. 1. This should go down as one of the best teams ever in the City League or WPIAL. The individual talent was off the charts and the team dominated in the postseason, winning five PIAA games by an average of 21.2 points and the first state title for the Pittsburgh City League since 1991. Schenley finished 29-3, but one loss was by forfeit and the other two were to Lincoln (N.Y.), which won the New York City championship and a state championship, and Lake Howell (Fla.), which had two University of Florida recruits and won a 5A state title.

Schenley's DeJuan Blair kisses the PIAA championship trophy after the Spartans won the 2007 Class 4A title. (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The talent on coach Fred Skrocki’s team ran deep. DeJuan Blair became an All-American at Pitt and played seven years in the NBA. D.J. Kennedy played at St. John’s, two games in the NBA and had a long career professionally overseas. Only three other teams in WPIAL and City League history have had two players go on to the NBA. Also Deandre Kane was a junior guard who played at Marshall and one year at Iowa State, making a few All-American teams. He also played professionally overseas.

Schenley’s point guard was a legendary City League player nicknamed “Onion.” Jamaal Bryant was only 5 feet 8, but played a gigantic role in the Spartans’ success. The fifth starter was Greg Blair (DeJuan’s brother), who played Division I football at the University of Cincinnati.

Advertise with us
New Castle players celebrate after winning a state championship in 2014 and becoming the first WPIAL team to finish a season undefeated since the 1980s. (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

2. NEW CASTLE 2014

This team didn’t have a future Division I basketball player, but New Castle won a state championship with a perfect record in the highest classification and that puts this team near the head of the class. New Castle finished 31-0, the first WPIAL team to go through a season undefeated since Sto-Rox in 1982-83. The previous WPIAL team to win a state title with a perfect record in the largest class was a legendary Ambridge team of 1967.

Coach Ralph Blundo’s New Castle team didn’t have a Division I basketball player, but had a future NFL player and supreme athlete in Malik Hooker. Anthony Richards was a point guard as tough as a $5 steak and played at Division II Le Moyne. He is still third in 3-pointers in WPIAL history with 304. Twin brothers Stu (Duquesne) and Drew Allen (Robert Morris) played Division I football and Jake McPhatter played football at Ball State and California (Pa.).

3. ALIQUIPPA 2016

In the 2014-15 season, Aliquippa was undefeated until losing in the Class 2A state championship. The Quips came back a year later and finished off the perfect run with a 30-0 record. They won five PIAA games by an average of 20 points. Standout guards Jassir Jordan and Sheldon Jeter both scored 22 in the state championship. Chuckie Humphries was a smooth, athletic forward and coach Nick Lackovich’s other starters were Robert Crute and football star Kaezon Pugh.

Advertise with us

4. O.L.S.H. 2021

The state playoffs were shortened slightly because of COVID-19, but nothing could stop the Chargers from perfection as coach Mike Rodriguez’s Our Lady of the Sacred Heart team finished 24-0 and won seven WPIAL and PIAA Class 2A games by an average of 26.5 points. The team featured senior guard Dante Spadafora and junior guard Jake DiMichele. Spadafora finished that season with 1,792 career points and DiMichele 1,813, with a year left in his career.

Lincoln Park's Meleek Thomas, left, and Brandin Cummings were a superb guard tandem on the 2024 Lincoln Park team. (J.J. LaBella / For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

5. LINCOLN PARK 2024

This 28-3 team won a Class 4A state title and lost to only Philadelphia power Neumann-Goretti and two out-of-state teams. Coach Mike Bariski had one of the most talented guard tandems in the WPIAL in many years in junior Meleek Thomas and senior Brandin Cummings. Thomas now plays at Arkansas and Cummings at Pitt.

6. O.L.S.H. 2022

Advertise with us

One season after winning a state title with a perfect record, Our Lady of the Sacred Heart ran the table again, winning WPIAL and PIAA championships with a 28-0 record. The Chargers won nine WPIAL and PIAA games by an average of 26.2 points. DiMichele finished as the third-leading scorer in WPIAL history with 2,642 points and fifth in 3-pointers with 301.

7. LINCOLN PARK 2014

The Leopards finished 30-1 with the only loss coming to undefeated New Castle. Sophomore Maverick Rowan, who would play at North Carolina State, scored 37 points in the PIAA championship game. Nelly Cummings was a freshman guard for coach Mark Javens team and Elijah Minnie and Ryan Skovranko were two formidable forwards.

8. IMANI CHRISTIAN 2023

Imani Christian had a 23-6 record, but played a tough nonsection schedule against teams in higher classifications. Coach Omar Foster’s Saints dominated in Class 1A like few from the WPIAL have. They won four PIAA playoff games by 30 or more points and the championship by 17. Alier Maluk was a 6-11 sophomore who scored 22 in the PIAA final. He is now playing at Florida State. The Saints also had talented guards in Dame Givner, Avery Wesley and R.J. Sledge.

Advertise with us
Beaver Falls' Lance Jeter lets go of his famous half-court shot that beat Aliquippa in triple overtime in the 2005 WPIAL Class 2A championship. (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

9. BEAVER FALLS 2005

This team, coached by Doug Biega, finished 29-3. Although the Tigers didn’t dominate in the postseason as much as other teams in the top 10, Beaver Falls had something special – Lance Jeter. His postseason heroics were unforgettable, especially the last-second shot near half-court that beat Aliquippa in triple overtime in what might be the best WPIAL championship ever. Jeter went on to play at Nebraska and Beaver Falls also had a talented guard in Jack Anderson, who went on to a nice career at Carnegie Mellon.

10. SCHENLEY 2006

This is the only team in the top 10 that didn’t win a state championship. But the strength of this team makes it deserving of a top 10 nod. Blair and Kennedy were juniors and Schenley finished 30-2. What kept the Spartans from a state title was a 60-58 loss to Lower Merion (Kobe Bryant’s alma mater) in the championship game. To this day, I still wonder what happened at halftime that made Schenley keep Kennedy on the bench for a good portion of the second half? If that didn’t occur, Schenley very easily could have won back-to-back titles.

New Castle's Kai Cox (12) and Upper St. Clair's Jake Foster (3) met in last year's WPIAL Class 6A championship. If they meet again this year, it will be a rare rematch. (J.J. LaBella / For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

JUST SAYIN’

• This is not to say it will definitely happen, but if the Upper St. Clair and New Castle boys basketball teams (No. 1 and 2 seeds, respectively) make it to the WPIAL Class 6A championship, it will certainly be a rematch for the ages. Upper St. Clair beat New Castle in last year’s title game and only five previous times in more than 100 years of WPIAL basketball have two teams met back-to-back years in the largest classification championship. It happened in 2019-20 with Butler and Mt. Lebanon, 2013-14 with New Castle and Hampton, 1954-55 with Farrell and McKeesport, 1923-24 with Homestead and Monessen, and 1914-15 with Butler and Peabody.

Advertise with us

• Lincoln Park’s upset loss to Ringgold Tuesday means Lincoln Park will not have any “success points” under the PIAA competitive classification formula and will drop down to Class 4A next season. Under the formula, Lincoln Park had been bumped up to 5A the past two seasons. Of course, Lincoln Park could choose to stay in Class 5A if it wanted.

• Louisville has shown plenty of interest in Indiana High basketball player Aaron Webb, a 6-foot-7 junior who has a few major scholarship offers. But Marquette also apparently likes Webb. Marquette assistant Nevada Smith flew in to watch Webb and Indiana play Gateway Tuesday in the WPIAL playoffs. Neill Berry, another Marquette assistant, came to watch Webb play against Shaler a few weeks ago. Will Louisville and Marquette eventually pull the trigger and offer?

• In football recruiting, Central Catholic junior Jimmy Kalis is one of the most heavily recruited offensive linemen in the country and he recently named his top six colleges – and they are heavy hitters. They are Ohio State, Georgia, Texas, Miami, Clemson and LSU, but Kalis also says he hasn’t ruled out Penn State. That means Central Catholic’s offensive line this season will have Kalis, Notre Dame recruit James Halter and Jon Sassic, who has offers from Pitt, West Virginia and Virginia Tech, among others.

Shaler coach Brian Junker, left, celebrates with Miguel Hugas after the Titans won the 2023 Class 5A state championship. (J.J. LaBella / For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

• The first play date for baseball in Pennsylvania is less than a month away (March 13) and there was one major offseason coaching change in WPIAL baseball that pretty much flew under the radar. Brian Junker resigned as Shaler’s coach last June after 16 seasons on the job. He won three WPIAL titles, a state championship and lost in a PIAA final. But he didn’t stay out of coaching long. In the fall, his coaching odyssey took him just a little North on Route 8, where he has taken over the Hampton Talbots.

BIG 33 ‘EARLY’ WOES

Over the past few years, it seems more and more standout high school football players are leaving their senior years early and enrolling at their college for the spring semester. The practice has really hurt the Big 33 high school football all-star game. The annual game, which matches top Pennsylvania seniors against top players from another state, used to be a late July event and goal for any player in Pa. Things began to change years ago when high school seniors started enrolling at their colleges in June after graduation. So the Big 33 moved the game up to Memorial Day weekend. Now, with many players enrolling in college in January, the Big 33 misses out on just about every top player in Pa. The 2026 Pa. Big 33 team was announced last week. This is not to say the team doesn’t have talented players, but consider this: Of the 40 players on the team, only three are ranked among the top 50 seniors in the state by On3.com. This year’s game, which matches Pennsylvania against Maryland, is set for May 24. The head coach of the Pa. team is Gateway’s Don Holl.

Advertise with us
Quaker Valley's Mimi Thiero has a chance at 2,000 points and 1,000 rebounds. (Matt Freed / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

DATA WAY

1,279

Career rebounds for Quaker Valley senior Mimi Thiero. Rated one of the top 50 players in the country, the 6-foot-4 Thiero had 1,924 career points heading into Wednesday’s WPIAL quarterfinal game. She has a chance to be that rare high school player to have 2,000 career points and 1,000 rebounds.

REMEMBERING WHEN

Forty-three years ago, Shawn McCallister, a fiery little junior point guard at Bishop Boyle High School in Homestead, set a WPIAL boys basketball playoff record when he made 23 free throws in an 87-77 victory against Monessen in the 1983 WPIAL Class 2A quarterfinals. The record still stands today. McCallister attempted 27 free throws in the game and scored 37 points. McCallister started three years for Boyle, won a state championship in 1982 and these days is the longtime athletic director at Steel Valley High School.

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and @mwhiteburgh on X.