Reston Lehman looked around at his teammates in the nearly silent Peters Township locker room at halftime.

“I was emotionless,” Lehman said. “I wasn’t sad. I wasn’t ready to get back on the field. I was just like, ‘What’s going on?’ ”

It’s not surprising the Indians were in shock. The team had only allowed 20 points in a game once all season and was staring down the barrel of a 19-point deficit to reigning champion Pine-Richland in a game in which they had been dominated in nearly every facet.

“We have a great locker room. No one points a finger. We just look in the mirror and say we’ve got to do better, and that’s what happened at halftime,” Peters Township coach TJ Plack said. “I told the kids that we screwed everything up. We got manhandled, and that’s uncharacteristic, so let’s find a way and get this done.”

Advertise with us

What happened next will go down as one of the greatest comebacks in WPIAL championship game history.

Senior running back Cole Neupaver gave the team the spark it so desperately needed when he broke off a 74-yard touchdown run with 7:47 remaining in the third quarter and capped off the comeback with his third score from 1 yard out with 4:50 remaining in regulation, as No. 2 Peters Township (13-0) came all the way back for a 20-19 victory against top-seeded Pine-Richland (11-2) in the WPIAL Class 5A championship game Saturday at Acrisure Stadium.

Neupaver finished with 25 carries for 107 yards and three scores.

“That was a huge turn of events right there, and it gave us a ton of energy,” Neupaver said. “We went into halftime and we didn’t want to go out like that again, and that was just huge right there.”

It was the third consecutive year the two teams met in the WPIAL finals, with Peters Township taking the 2023 meeting and the Rams winning in 2024. But the drama was certainly ramped up after Pine-Richland took the Indians to the woodshed in the first half in a dominant performance.

Advertise with us

“We just didn’t execute in the second half. We won one half of football, and they came out and outplayed us in the second half,” Pine-Richland coach Jon LeDonne said. “We had a couple missed assignments and a couple of missed opportunities, and at the end of the day, not having a kicker cost us.”

Pine-Richland kicker Alex Mestre, who had 62 extra points and three field goals this season, was injured in the semifinals against Moon and was a midweek scratch from the game. The Rams missed a pair of two-point conversion attempts in the first half before Brody Walkowski, a sophomore on the soccer team who was added this week, knocked an extra point home with 4:19 remaining in the first half to put Pine-Richland ahead 19-0.

But that was all Pine-Richland had, as Peters Township stymied the Rams offense and junior quarterback Aaron “Oobi” Strader throughout the second half.

Strader ran for 56 yards and a touchdown in the first half and threw for 36 and another score. But in the second half, he was limited to 42 yards passing and 7 yards rushing and was sacked twice.

“We knew our linemen would get blocks, we knew our running back would find holes and we knew we would take shots,” Peters Township quarterback Nolan DiLucia said. “We knew nothing was going to be easy in this game and we had to work hard all four quarters.”

Advertise with us

Game flow

Peters Township won the toss and deferred to the second half, which gave Pine-Richland a golden opportunity to showcase its offense. All it took was three plays, the last of which being a 24-yard run from Jay Timmons, to put the Rams into Indians territory at the 40.

From there, Pine-Richland methodically ran its offense, utilizing running back Maclane Miller and alternating with Strader on the run-pass option until, on a brilliant 15-yard scramble on 4th-and-7 from the Peters Township 19, the Rams had a first down at the Indians 2.

From there, on 3rd-and-goal, Timmons ran a jet sweep around left end for a 1-yard touchdown and Pine-Richland was out to a 6-0 lead 4:56 into the game.

Peters Township couldn’t do anything on its first possession, and after a 15-yard Lehman punt, Pine-Richland was back in business at the Indians 45. After what could have been a game-changing Strader interception by Jeremy Poletti at the Peters Township 4, the Indians again went three-and-out and gave the ball back to the Rams at the Peters Township 39.

Once again, Pine-Richland unhurriedly drove the field until, on 2nd-and-2 from the 3, Strader scrambled untouched into the end zone for a 12-0 advantage with 10:55 remaining in the first half.

Advertise with us

With 4:13 left in the second quarter, Pine-Richland struck again. This time, on 4th-and-12, Strader found Khalil Taylor in the back-left corner of the end zone for a 23-yard touchdown and a 19-0 lead at the intermission.

Key stats

• Pine-Richland ran 36 plays in Peters Township territory before the Indians picked up their first first down of the game with 3:33 remaining in the second quarter.

• Peters Township did not cross its own 30-yard line until its final drive of the first half.

• Pine-Richland outgained Peters Township 205-38 in the first half and went 3 for 3 on fourth down.

• Peters Township did not cross midfield until Cole Neupaver’s 74-yard touchdown with 7:47 left in the third quarter.

Advertise with us

Quotable

“I told them at halftime that we knew that this wasn’t where our story ends with this team. We knew we had to make adjustments and we did.” — DiLucia

What it means

Peters Township will play Bishop McDevitt (11-1), which defeated Solanco 38-20 in the District 3 championship game, in the PIAA semifinals at a site and time to be determined. The Crusaders, the reigning state champions, defeated Pine-Richland 28-14 in last year's semifinals.