Fox Chapel athletic director Michael O’Brien continues using player safety to tout what he perceives as a groundbreaking pathway for the WPIAL to institute a competitive balance formula into its football alignment.

His idea is to break the WPIAL into seven leagues using a formula that includes wins, losses, weighted wins and losses taking into account classification sizes of participants and roster size. It also opens the door for a return to the WPIAL for schools currently playing independent schedules.

It sounds amazing. O’Brien certainly thinks so. This is the third variation he’s come up with in the last two years that he’s attempted to sell to the WPIAL brass.

Only it’s completely and utterly flawed.

Advertise with us

If it were a diamond, a jeweler would throw it out because it wouldn’t be worth cutting and no one would buy it if they tried. It has no clarity.

Here is an extensive breakdown of why it won’t work:

It’s already being done

This is the big issue O’Brien has completely glossed over when peddling this proposal. The WPIAL already uses a competitive balance formula of its own when it makes its schedule.

Here’s how:

Every two years, the PIAA realigns its classifications based on enrollment figures given to the state governing body by the individual school districts. For football prior to the 2024 season, the PIAA split those 553 schools into six classifications of between 86 and 98 schools in each.

Advertise with us

When the WPIAL gets the breakdown, it then puts schools into conferences based on classification as well as geography so that schools don’t have to spend exorbitant amounts of money on travel costs that include overtime for bus drivers, gasoline and the like. It is also done in this manner because the winner of the WPIAL title in each classification represents the district in the PIAA tournament.

When everything is broken down, the most teams in any conference is eight. That means a team must play seven conference games in a nine-week span, so the WPIAL fills the gaps and gives each team its two-year non-conference schedule.

For those who don’t know, the only game the WPIAL does not schedule is the optional Week Zero matchup, which teams can use either for a game or for an additional scrimmage prior to the start of the actual season the following week.

What the WPIAL then does is schedule non-conference opponents for teams based on prior success — or failure.

Take McKeesport. The Class 4A Tigers were 22-4 in the two years prior to the last realignment, so their non-conference schedule included Class 5A Peters Township and Upper St. Clair, perennial Class 4A contender Thomas Jefferson and a Belle Vernon team that moved up to Class 4A after winning back-to-back WPIAL and PIAA Class 3A titles.

Advertise with us

Pine-Richland plays Class 6A Central Catholic (17-7), North Allegheny (24-4), Seneca Valley (9-11) and Class 5A Latrobe (15-9) as its non-conference schedule. Peters Township gets McKeesport, Class 6A Mt. Lebanon and Class 4A teams West Allegheny and Trinity.

Now let’s look at Fox Chapel. The Foxes were 0-20 in the same span, so it was paired off with Class 5A Baldwin (2-18) and Franklin Regional (12-9), Class 4A Knoch (9-12) and Class 3A East Allegheny (17-7).

In the last two years, Fox Chapel has four more wins than it had the previous two seasons.

Participation trophies galore

Because O’Brien has his system broken down ostensibly into seven classifications, it means there will be a lot of intermixing when it comes to teams’ conferences and their actual PIAA designation.

He also has a seventh classification for certain programs including Sto-Rox, Springdale, Rochester and Brownsville should it return to the WPIAL after playing an independent schedule.

Advertise with us

That seventh classification of nine teams is essentially a relegation division for struggling programs that have no chance of competing for the actual WPIAL playoffs but could be awarded a conference championship plaque.

There is also the problem of how playoff teams are determined.

Because WPIAL policy gives conference champions an automatic playoff berth, it would be problematic, as several of the teams would be playing down, something the WPIAL and PIAA frown upon.

In his example, O’Brien has a conference with Greensburg Central Catholic (Class 1A), Greensburg Salem (Class 3A), Albert Gallatin (Class 4A), Yough (Class 3A) and Uniontown (Class 4A).

So, Uniontown wins the conference. The Red Raiders could potentially earn a WPIAL playoff spot ahead of, say, Montour or West Allegheny by playing lesser competition

Advertise with us

Or the converse is true. The model would eliminate Uniontown from the playoffs and the team would get a conference championship plaque for not making the playoffs.

By using a weighted system of this nature, standings would not matter, conference championships would be pyrrhic victories for many, and it would invariably mean the complete overhaul of the WPIAL postseason selection process.

It’s not psychic

In any system like this there are bound to be drawbacks, but this one may be the biggest of them all.

There cannot be predictability.

These are high school kids. They play four years, graduate and matriculate to the next level. Schools may not have replacements on the horizon.

Advertise with us

It’s a problem the Pennsylvania Interscholastic Hockey League (PIHL) has had to deal with for years. Teams have success in a lower classification and even win championships but lose top players to graduation and cannot recover.

Plum won the 2017 Class 2A Penguins Cup and was moved up to Class 3A the following year. The Mustangs went 1-9-0 in their first 10 games, finished 7-10-0 and were back in Class 2A two years later.

Matt Sieg is a generational talent at Fort Cherry. The Penn State recruit recently became the WPIAL all-time scoring leader, has accounted for more that 170 touchdowns in his career, and has led the Rangers to the last two WPIAL Class 1A titles.

According to the Modified Harbin Computer Points model that this entire proposal is based on, Fort Cherry would likely have to play a tougher schedule in the next realignment because of their success the last three years. But unless head coach Tanner Garry has another Sieg sitting on his bench or in eighth grade, there is going to be some slippage that might not be as evident against Serra Catholic, but might be against a Keystone Oaks or even Waynesburg if they were forced to move up.

And Sieg is just one example.

Advertise with us

Clairton had its 66-game winning streak end when many of the players involved, including future NFL wide receiver Tyler Boyd, went on to the next level. The Bears had another player waiting in the wings in LaMont Wade, who tied Boyd with 117 career touchdowns, and the team ended up winning eight WPIAL Class 1A titles in nine years. But 2013 was the transition year when Wade was a freshman the year after Boyd graduated.

Like a rock

Computer models like this take into account wins, losses, classifications and roster size but skim over the thing that football teams need to perennially contend in an ever-evolving landscape:

Consistency. And that starts at the top.

Look at the top teams in the WPIAL.

Tanner Garry was a quarterback at Fort Cherry and had success before taking over the program six years ago. Wayne Wade was the quarterback at Clairton, was an assistant coach with the Bears during their lengthy winning, and has been the head coach for 12 years.

Advertise with us

Avonworth coach Duke Johncour, who won the WPIAL Class 3A title last season and is the frontrunner in 2025, has been with the Antelopes for 16 years and played his senior year as the first quarterback in Woodland Hills history under legendary coach George Novak. Another Novak product is Bill Cherpak, who played for him at Steel Valley before going to Pitt and spending the last 30 years at Thomas Jefferson, building a dynasty that has won him a record 10 WPIAL titles

McKeesport’s Matt Miller has been the head coach for 10 years after playing for the Tigers under another legend, George Smith and has been to three WPIAL title games. Peters Township turned the program over to T.J. Plack and has rewarded the district with 10 years on the sideline, the 2023 WPIAL Class 5A title a state championship game appearance and a WPIAL finals run in 2024.

That doesn’t even include Art Walker and his 21-year stint at North Allegheny, or Mike Junko, who took over for his mentor Jim Render after serving as his assistant.

Success foments success and, to have it, you need to establish consistency and a solid feeder program, things that a computer rendering cannot see.

But what you can see is that the two teams that went to the forefront by negotiating with opponents for the mercy rule to be applied prior to games, Baldwin and Fox Chapel, have had a revolving door of coaches for decades.

Advertise with us

It’s a program, not an algorithm

In the end, the model fails for one basic reason. Nobody wants it.

Athletes who want to be the best want to beat the best. They don’t want a computer model dropping their teams down so they can have cheap wins and even cheaper conference championship trophies. They want to test themselves against the best their opponents have to offer, not go up against the junior varsity because some administrator begs an opponent to take it easy on his kids.

Let’s even take into account the argument of student safety. If a student was so concerned about potential injury, they would not go out for the team. If any parent was so paranoid about their child getting hurt, they would neither sign the permission slip to allow them to play or take them to the doctor for their mandatory preseason physical.

If Fox Chapel, Baldwin and schools that are struggling want to improve, they have to do it at a grassroots level by bringing in a coach who instills a desire to play for a successful program at the middle school level on up and be an organization that realizes it will take five or six years to see results.

These programs also have to be willing to allow the coaches to coach without administrative or school board interference. Nothing kills a potential turnaround more than a parent trying to get a coach ousted because their kid isn’t, in their opinion, seeing enough playing time.

Advertise with us

That’s the only real way these schools will ever be successful.

No computer model can do that.