There has been much debate over the past week about what to do when it comes to competitive balance within WPIAL football.

And Fox Chapel athletic director Michael O’Brien believes he has come up with a solution, one that he has been peddling to the WPIAL for approximately two years.

His plan is to use a combination of a competitive balance system, geographic location and roster size to radically alter the current conference classification system.

“Our position as athletic directors and coaches is to put kids in the best possible position to have success,” O’Brien said. “We’re still an educational league. This is still part of the classroom. It’s an extension. So, I don’t see why we can’t meet programs where they’re at to give them the opportunity to find some kind of success to keep programs going.”

Advertise with us

Hot-button issue

Last week, Baldwin High School sent a letter to the athletic directors of the five remaining schools on its schedule asking them to intersperse junior varsity players into their lineups and asking if they would be willing to play with a running clock throughout the games. The Highlanders lost to South Fayette on Friday night, 49-13, their 25th consecutive loss, in a game that started normally and ended with a running clock via the 35-point mercy rule that states that whenever a 35-point deficit is reached in the second half of a game, the clock is only stopped for called timeouts, injuries, penalties, scores and changes of possession.

A couple of days later, Pine-Richland football coach Jon LeDonne sent a letter to parents explaining that his school and its opponent, Fox Chapel, had discussed something similar. The two teams would play a normal 12-minute first quarter, an eight-minute second quarter and two eight-minute quarters in the second half with a running clock.

Prior to the game, the teams opted to play a normal first half but did play with eight-minute quarters against a running clock in the second half after Pine-Richland took a 42-3 lead at the intermission.

But the question of how to even things out to eliminate some of the disparity remains unanswered.

“I think a lot of folks have been trying to figure that out,” LeDonne said. “At the end of the day, you have to fill a 9- to 10-game regular season schedule and, based on classification alone right now, it’s tough.”

Advertise with us

Relegation model?

In Fox Chapel’s proposal, there would be seven “leagues” with the top four split into three divisions each and two with four sections. The seventh and last would consist of two sections and be something of a developmental league for smaller schools that are currently struggling to rebuild their programs and get to the point where they can compete with better teams.

Playoff qualification would be based on the modified Harbin Computer Points System, which is a computer rating system that awards points for wins with bonus points added for victories against teams considered to be stronger. In this instance, it could be used if a team that is deemed by the PIAA to be smaller — say, Class 4A — beats a team in Class 5A, it would receive more points. But if a Class 5A team loses to a Class 3A team, it would take a bigger hit and have a tougher time qualifying for the postseason.

Though it could create a more competitive landscape, it could also prove problematic.

“You can’t have the top eight teams in a conference and have them beat the heck out of each other every week and then expect them to compete in the playoffs,” LeDonne said. “It’s a real hard question.”

O’Brien has previously shopped this idea to the WPIAL football committee, but the organization opted against implementing it.

Advertise with us

“We’re constantly looking at different ideas and solutions in order to make the league better. We continue to do it and continue to have talks about that,” WPIAL chief executive officer Vince Sortino said. “Our existence is to try to get qualifiers to go on to the state tournament. It’s not our job to help high schools where they may be deficient to build their programs. It’s up to them.”

Example on ice

This new system would have quite a few similarities with how the Pennsylvania Interscholastic Hockey League (PIHL) handles its alignment. The PIHL retools its divisions every year with teams moving up or down in classification depending on team success.

There are no cross-classification games, so teams only play teams in their designated class. The league re-evaluates every year based on a team’s success over a certain period of time — when the league first began utilizing this system, it was three seasons — and uses a formula with wins weighted on classification.

At the end of the season the points were added and teams would be moved up or down according to the final point total. That’s why Canon-McMillan will play in Class 1A this season and Thomas Jefferson will play in Class 3A in the PIHL.

Utilizing this in the WPIAL would have an obvious drawback. The PIHL does not have to follow the PIAA classification mandates for state competition. To make it to the state finals against the Flyers Cup representative, a team only has to win the Penguins Cup championship in its classification.

Advertise with us

Independent thought

Though the Fox Chapel plan would be difficult to implement, it does have supporters. Several schools have left the WPIAL in recent years because they could not compete in their classification, most notably Butler, which was among the first to opt to play an independent schedule.

Several other schools, including Uniontown, later joined Butler but are now considering a return to the WPIAL. If a plan like this was put into play, it would make the transition that much simpler.

“It’s going to take us another year or two for us to be competitive, and it’s definitely been discussed,” said Uniontown coach Tim Bukowski, who helped turn around the Southmoreland program before leaving after last season. “Going back into the WPIAL makes sense because it creates a lot more excitement for the kids to come out.”

Even so, this remains a proposal and there would be quite a bit to be worked out before anything of this sort would be implemented. Ideally, this would be the time, as the PIAA will soon be announcing classification adjustments for its biennial realignment, which begins in the 2026-27 school year.

More likely, however, any major shift would take place a minimum of two years down the road and would require immense negotiations, as there are logistical concerns that would have to be addressed in addition to competitive balance.

“We’ve talked about being as creative as possible and making some changes if we can,” Sortino said. “We’re constantly looking. No one ever says, ‘We’re just going to keep it the way it is,’ because everything changes and you have to change, which is why this last cycle we went to a more competitive approach.”