What does it take to build a football dynasty in one of Pennsylvania’s most competitive conferences? For Peters Township and Upper St. Clair, the answer is a decade of blood, sweat and an unrelenting rivalry in the WPIAL Class 5A Allegheny Six Conference.

“When we took over Peters Township 10 years ago, we were banging on doors just trying to get a rivalry,” coach TJ Plack said. “For you to say, ‘How is that rivalry?’ puts a smile on my face. It’s been back and forth for the last eight years.”

Five of the past six WPIAL Class 5A title games have featured Upper St. Clair or Peters Township. The one that didn’t? Moon still represented the Allegheny Six Conference.

The heavyweight duo entered its regular season showdown last year with both teams undefeated and looking to assert dominance in the conference. Upper St. Clair rolled Peters Township. The Panthers clawed for every bit of 43 first-half yards but managed to build a 7-0 lead. They struck twice more for a 21-7 victory.

Advertise with us

After that battle left Upper St. Clair undefeated, Peters Township had one goal: revenge. And this time, a championship berth was on the line.

The WPIAL Class 5A semifinal was an absolute slugfest. Neither offense scored a touchdown. The game was decided by a first-half kickoff return by Peters Township’s Nick McCullough that went 97 yards to the house.

“We won the one that mattered last year,” Plack said.

“We don't like each other much,” Peters Township senior quarterback Nolan DiLucia said. “So it's always a battle and you're putting a little effort more in that week, for sure.”

To Plack’s point, Peters Township didn’t have a tradition of success on the football field when he took over. He’s guided the program to its most successful era and done it in a sustainable way. Plack credits his youth camps and middle school programs with helping to build the foundation. Two years ago, Plack saw his hard work rewarded with the school’s first WPIAL championship.

Advertise with us

The hero last year, McCullough, is off to Carnegie Mellon this fall. Several other 2025 grads will be playing on Saturdays, as well, but Plack returns a strong core spearheaded by the Big Three: Stanford commit Lucas Shanafelt, Pitt commit Reston Lehman and Villanova commit DiLucia, the heart and soul of the team.

“We have a group chat, us three, and we talk a lot,” DiLucia said. “We’ve all been through it, so we talk a lot about the recruiting process, like with schools and everything. We have a joke where we try to predict guys and what school they're gonna commit to.

“We always talk about schools, talk about our futures. We push each other, too. We’ve all got the same mentality of wanting to be great, wanting to win. So having them next to me, behind me, pushing me all the time, it sucks, but it's always better for me.”

DiLucia, a senior quarterback, has started since his sophomore year and even made a push for the job as a freshman.

“He’s an alpha male,” Plack said. “He’s ran the locker room since he was a freshman.”

Advertise with us

“When you have a quarterback like that, who can do so many different things with his arm, you always have a chance, no matter how much the odds might be stacked against you, no matter who you're playing against,” Shanafelt said. “We always know we have a chance going to battle with Nolan just because of how many things he can do and all the different skills that he has.”

After the victory against Upper St. Clair, Peters Township came up short in the title game against Pine-Richland, the same team they beat for that first title.

“[Pine-Richland] did a really good job because what they gave us was the QB-run game,” Plack said. “I think Nolan took advantage of that, whether it was a called draw for him or whether he dropped back, saw that their guys had hands on our guys, disrupted our route and he just pulled down and [went]. ... I thought it was a heck of a game by Nolan.”

With the changes in personnel, Plack has adjusted the look of the offense. Shanafelt and Lehman, two dominant pass rushers, are going to be a major factor on offense, as well, as tight ends tearing through the heart of opposing defenses.

“This summer, we had a lot of 7-on-7, and to be quite honest, it didn't look pretty right away,” DiLucia said. “But it's been clicking recently. I mean, we had our most recent 7-on-7, and I think our offense looked pure and really good. Having those two guys at tight end is definitely a plus. They're both big targets and they're both fast, so having them is gonna really help me this year a lot.”

Advertise with us

Mickey Vaccarello, who is a freshman on Stanford’s roster in 2025, played on the opposite side of Lehman, a four-star prospect, last year. Shanafelt will be filling that spot this season.

“I think Lucas brings some physicality to the game, which we are excited about,” Plack said.

“Last year, I took the chance going inside, just to get on the field because I just wanted to play so badly,” Shanafelt said. “So I moved inside, took the risk, and it worked out for me, for sure. I loved it in there, in the trenches. Outside linebacker, I feel like, is where I can really shine. I get to play in space, which I'm best at. I'm excited to see what me and Reston can do, for sure.”

Shanafelt is eager to join Vaccarello at Stanford next year, and the two remain close.

“I knew wherever I was going, I was gonna use it to better my academics,” Shanafelt said. “I was gonna use it to better my life after football. I had my fair share of choices and I could have picked a couple of schools that have good academics but not Stanford academics.”

Advertise with us

Last season, Cole Neupaver, a hockey player, returned to the football field for the first time since seventh grade, but his season was derailed just as he was starting to pop because of a hand injury. Now fully healthy for his senior season, Neupaver figures to be a key cog in the offense at running back.

“He's gonna be an animal this year, I will attest to that,” DiLucia said of Neupaver.

The star of the Panthers’ regular season win against Peters Township, Julian Dahlem, is preparing for his first season at John Carroll University, a common theme for the Panthers. Upper St. Clair graduated a large, talented and influential senior class, including nine young men heading off to play college ball, making it easy to wonder what is left.

“That’s kind of been my goal since I got here: to stack classes,” coach Mike Junko said. “It kind of protects you from those years where you might have lower numbers. A lot of the work I did when I arrived, with youth camps and our middle school programs, is paying dividends now.

“We still have a lot of guys who have played Friday night football.”

Advertise with us

First and foremost, it always helps to have your quarterback back. Ethan Hellmann is a four-year starter for the Panthers.

“He plays his best football when he is right on the edge,” Junko said. “He has the ability to be a gunslinger and when he plays emotional, he plays his best football. He loves to compete.”

Some will be quick to point to the rushing attack led by Dahlem and the Peters Township game in the regular season, in which the Panthers didn’t complete a pass. But Hellman totaled 17 passing touchdowns and zero interceptions last year. And Hellman believes he has a lot to prove this year.

Senior Dante Coury and junior John Banbury will look to take a step forward as the primary ball carriers for the team.

Bloodlines run deep at Upper St. Clair.

Advertise with us

A trio of little brothers will be making big plays in various capacities this year. Ryan Robbins is a mountain of a man at 6-foot-8. His older brother, Tyler, is at Miami (Ohio) for his freshman year after his outstanding basketball career was capped with a selection to the Post-Gazette’s Fabulous 5. Bill Fralic award winner Nate Stohl made the jump from Panthers to Tigers and is now at Princeton. His younger brother, Will, is hoping to continue the family tradition of dominant linemen. And Dante Coury’s younger brother, Luca Coury, is a promising back, as well.

The Allegheny Six Conference will not be easy for anyone to win.

“[Class] 5A, in my opinion, is the hardest classification in PIAA football, and our conference, I believe, is the hardest conference in PIAA football,” South Fayette coach Marty Spieler said.

“It’s like the SEC,” Moon coach Ryan Linn added.

“The depth of coaching in our conference is very strong,” Junko emphasized.

Advertise with us

Bethel Park returns a lot on defense, and while the offense may have lost a bit, the Black Hawks have some younger guys ready to step in. That starts at quarterback for Bethel Park. With Tanner Pfeuffer off to Frostburg State, the Black Hawks have an open competition for their next QB1. Competing for the job are senior Evan Devine, junior Brady Bruckner and sophomore Max Novak, who transferred in from Southern Columbia. Duquesne commit Santino LaMolinare, a first-team All-Conference two-way player, will anchor the trenches.

David Dennison was the starter in camp last year at running back, but an injury limited his role.

“He’s going to have a breakout senior year,” Bethel Park coach Phil Peckich said.

Will Sabatos had a sophomore campaign to remember at safety. He earned first-team All-Conference honors after posting 43 tackles, one interception, one defensive touchdown and two tackles for loss. Colleges are starting to pay attention, as he holds a Miami (Ohio) offer, and Peckich believes everyone will be paying attention to Sabatos this year.

In Spieler’s first year as coach at South Fayette, he directed the six-time WPIAL champion Lions back to the playoffs after a three-year absence.

Advertise with us

South Fayette brings in highly touted freshman running back Aayden Wright, whom Spieler described as “explosive.” Combined with senior back Bo Stover and tight end duo Jacob Bostian and Tyson Wright, the tools are in place to run a powerful and explosive offense around senior quarterback Drew Welhorsky.

Add to the mix senior receiver Daniel Speca, who transferred back from Central Catholic this summer, and it’s clear the Lions are building a dominant pride.

On the defensive side, the mantra is “six seconds of chaos,” with Minnesota commit Anthony Charles and Cornell commit Colton Astorino leading the charge.

“You’ll hear us break down on, ‘Go hunt,’ ” Spieler said. “Nowadays, you can’t be timid. If you want to eat, you have to go out and get your food.”

Moon’s Linn believes the Tigers have the best group of skill-position players he’s had at Moon. Paul Bronaugh, who has plenty of college interest already, is a key piece to that talent. The receiver was injured for last year’s playoff loss to Penn Hills, but he still managed 671 all-purpose yards and eight touchdowns on the year. Receiver/running back Braeden Stuart is a Navy commit. Senior quarterback Andrew Cross is ready to take advantage of that skill. The Tigers are battle tested, with two playoff appearances in the last two years. And they have a new weapon in Daiveon Taylor, a Kent State commit, who is a running back and linebacker who transferred in from Aliquippa.

Advertise with us

Baldwin hasn’t had a winning season since 1999. They have a young team that is continuing to grow and develop. Quarterback Noah Mickolay was a freshman last year and he is ready to take that next step in Year 2. After being ruled ineligible last year, junior Dre’on Fuller is ready to roll for the Highlanders.

In the Allegheny Six, there are no easy games. Peters Township and Upper St. Clair have set the standard, but the chase never ends. With star-powered recruits, revenge-minded rivals and a conference where every Friday feels like a playoff game, only one thing is certain: The road to a WPIAL title still runs through the Six.

BALDWIN

Coach: Dana Brown Jr.

Years at school: 3

Advertise with us

2024 record: 0-10

Returning starters: Offense 4, Defense 3

Key returners: Noah Mickolay (6-0, 170, So., QB), Noah Saccani (5-9, 160, Sr. ATH/DB), Max Galentine (6-0, 240, So. ATH/OLB), Dre’on Fuller (6-0, 225, Jr., RB/LB)

BETHEL PARK

Coach: Phil Peckich

Advertise with us

Years at school: 3

2024 record: 10-3

Returning starters: Offense 4, Defense 7

Key returners: David Dennison III (6-2, 200, Sr., RB/CB), Will Sabatos (6-2, 195, Sr., RB/S), Santino LaMolinare (6-4, 275, Sr., OL/DL), Santino Nowozeniuk (6-0, 165, Jr., WR/DB)

MOON

Advertise with us

Coach: Ryan Linn

Years at school: 9

2024 record: 5-6

Returning starters: Offense 6, Defense 6

Key returners: Andrew Cross (6-0, 190, Sr., QB), Braeden Stuart (5-11, 195, Sr., ATH/DB), Austin Knox (6-2, 270, Sr. OL/DE), Paul Bronaugh (5-10, 195, Sr., ATH/DB)

Advertise with us

PETERS TOWNSHIP

Coach: TJ Plack

Years at school: 10

2024 record: 11-2

Returning starters: Offense 8, Defense 6

Key returners: Nolan DiLucia (6-2, 210, Sr., QB/DB), Lucas Shanafelt (6-4, 235, Sr., TE/OLB), Reston Lehman (6-4, 240, Sr., TE/OLB), Alex Klein (5-10, 210, Sr., OL/DL), Lucas Rost (5-11, 185, Sr., WR/S)

SOUTH FAYETTE

Coach: Marty Spieler

Years at school: 2

2024 record: 6-5

Returning starters: Offense 7, Defense 6

Key returners: Anthony Charles (6-5, 196, Sr., TE/DE), Colton Astorino (6-6, 274, Sr., OL-DL), Evan Earley (6-3, 245, So., OL/DL), Jacob Bostian (6-3, 225, So., TE)

UPPER ST. CLAIR

Coach: Mike Junko

Years at school: 7

2024 record: 11-1

Returning starters: Offense 6, Defense 5

Key returners: Mason Geyer (6-3, 280, Sr., OL/DL), Nico D’Orazio (5-10, 185, Sr., WR/DB), Ethan Hellmann (5-11, 160, Sr., QB/DB), Kenny Davis (6-2, 280, Sr. OL/DL)