The world of college football recruiting has been about “early” for the past 25 years or so. There are early scholarship offers, early commitments and this is the sixth year of the early signing period.

Thus, for most top prospects, all of the scholarship offers are usually on the table before the start of their senior seasons, and many have made verbal commitments before they ever play a game as a senior.

But sometimes, a senior season can still matter greatly for a player’s recruitment. Steel Valley High School’s Cruce Brookins is a case in point.

Brookins signed with Pitt on Wednesday morning, proving it’s better late than never. Brookins was a standout quarterback and defensive back at Steel Valley and was recruited by Pitt to play safety.

Advertise with us

“If you end your career on a good note and your team is good, you might get opportunities,” Brookins said. “If you don’t end on a good note, people don’t always know how good you are. My senior season definitely mattered.”

Brookins came into his senior season thinking his recruitment was pretty much done after making a verbal commitment to Kent State of the Mid-American Conference in July. Brookins had displayed potential as a junior and a handful of FBS colleges liked his athletic ability enough to offer scholarships. West Virginia was the only college from the Power Five conferences to offer, but Brookins was recruited more by colleges on lower levels. He certainly wasn’t overloaded with offers, though. Besides Kent State, Brookins also had offers from Akron, Fordham and North Carolina A&T

But Brookins (6-foot-1, 180 pounds) had a superb senior season, leading Steel Valley to a WPIAL Class 2A championship. He did a little bit of everything as a quarterback, defensive back and kick returner. He showed speed, explosiveness and versatility. For the season, he completed 35 of 69 for 711 yards, but his athletic ability really showed when he ran with the football or played defense. He rushed for 1,625 yards on 123 carries (13.2 average) and intercepted seven passes on defense.

Although he played in a smaller classification, bigger colleges took notice as the season went along. In the WPIAL title game at Acrisure Stadium, Brookins rushed for 170 yards on 17 carries and intercepted a pass. In the regular season finale and three playoff games, Brookins had rushed for 910 yards.

In the week after the WPIAL title game, Pitt and Syracuse offered scholarships. Cincinnati also offered during the season. Brookins backed out of his commitment to Kent State and signed with Pitt.

Advertise with us

“I just feel like I was way overlooked before,” Brookins said. “Our team wasn’t always that good in previous years, so not many people were looking at me. Plus, I wasn’t working as hard as I did the past two years.

“I just had to show myself my senior season. I had to ball out. I had been dreaming of Power Five schools since I was young. I always wanted to play at a Power Five school. It felt great to finally get those offers, but it wouldn’t happen without this year.”

Brookins was one of only seven WPIAL players from the class of 2023 to sign with a college from a Power Five conference, and there doesn’t figure to be another sign in February, either. That fact proves again how the number of big-time recruits in Western Pennsylvania has dropped considerably in recent years.

This is the fourth time in five years that the number of Power Five recruits from the WPIAL-City League has been less than 10. The classes of 2022 and 2020 had only six Power Five recruits and 2019 had eight.

From the classes of 2000 through 2018, the WPIAL and City League never had fewer than 11 Power Five recruits and there were 14 or more 14 different times. The highest number of Power Five recruits since 2000 was 26 in 2007. The class of 2008 had 24, the class of 2004 had 23, and the class of 2006 had 20.

Advertise with us

To give you a better idea how things have changed with the big-time talent level of WPIAL and City League football in recent years, one can look at the five-year period of 1986-1990 as an example. The number of Power Five recruits in those classes were 30 in 1986, 31 in 1987, 27 in 1988, 31 in 1989, and 27 in 1990.

The Power Five recruits from the WPIAL and City League in the class of 2023 are: Brookins, Leechburg DB-LB Braylan Lovelace (Pitt), Chartiers Valley DB Lamont Payne (Penn State), Brashear linebacker Ta’mere Robinson (Penn State), Laurel Highlands WR Rodney Gallagher (West Virginia), Thomas Jefferson DE Jordan Mayer (Wisconsin) and Washington linebacker Davon Fuse (Rutgers).

Overall, 18 players from the WPIAL and City signed with FBS colleges. That’s a few more than last year’s 13, which is the lowest in the history of the WPIAL-City League. The class of 2020 had only 15 FBS recruits.

To put those numbers in perspective, consider that from 2000 through 2014, the WPIAL and City produced at least 25 FBS recruits 12 different times, and more than 30 six times. Now consider that the WPIAL-City classes of 1986-90 produced 40, 37, 47, 42 and 50 FBS recruits (FBS is the old Division I-A).

Pitt signed only two WPIAL recruits from the class of 2023. It is the fourth time in five years that Pitt signed two or less from the district, and Pitt has signed only nine over the past five years. In the previous five classes from 2014-18, Pitt signed a total of 29 recruits from the district.

Advertise with us

So things have definitely changed in Western Pennsylvania football recruiting. But sometimes a big senior season can still bring major colleges calling.

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh