The day before the biggest game in James Madison’s brief time as a member of the Football Bowl Subdivision (FBS), Curt Cignetti turned to one of his trusted motivational messages to rally his team.
The words came not from Vince Lombardi or George Gipp, but someone even more closely associated with football — Mahatma Gandhi.
Strength doesn’t come from physical capacity. It comes from an indomitable will.
One day after Cignetti centered a discussion in a Friday team meeting around that quote, the Dukes overcame a 28-3 second-quarter deficit to win on the road on Sept. 24 against an Appalachian State team that had stunned then-No. 6 Texas A&M just two weeks earlier.
The idea behind those words didn’t just propel James Madison to a thrilling win. It helps tell the story of a team and program doing things few, if any, have ever seen in college football.
In their first season as an FBS member, the Dukes are undefeated and ranked No. 25 in the Associated Press poll. They’re the first team since 1978 — when Division I split into I-A and I-AA levels — to be ranked in its first season transitioning to a higher level and with a win Saturday at Georgia Southern, they would become the first team to get to 6-0 in its first FBS season.
Read More
At the center of one of the most compelling and astonishing stories in the sport is Cignetti, a Pittsburgh native and former IUP head coach who’s in his fourth season at James Madison, located in Harrisonburg, Va. While cognizant and appreciative of the barrier-breaking nature of his team’s success, everything that has unfolded through the first five games is only so much of a surprise.
“Our guys expect to win,” Cignetti said Monday in a phone interview. “That’s just the culture here.”
The Dukes’ early season tear has given Cignetti the kind of national attention he hadn’t previously received, but he was a consistent winner long before this season began.
Having grown up around the game — his father, the late Frank Cignetti Sr., was a College Football Hall of Fame inductee after coaching at West Virginia and IUP, and his brother, Frank Jr., is the offensive coordinator at Pitt — Cignetti found a life in what became the family business, working for nearly the first 30 years of his career as a college assistant coach.
While the quarterbacks and tight ends coach at N.C. State, he recruited an undersized-but-intriguing quarterback from Richmond, Va., named Russell Wilson. He was a member of Nick Saban’s first staff at Alabama, working from 2007-10 as the program’s wide receivers coach and recruiting coordinator, a time in which he helped sign two No. 1 classes that paved the way for the Crimson Tide to win three national championships in a four-year stretch.
In his first head-coaching job — at IUP, where his father is the program’s all-time winningest coach — Cignetti’s teams went 53-17 in six seasons and made three Division II playoff appearances. From there, he went to Elon, where he engineered a similar turnaround, going 14-9 in two seasons after the Phoenix had mustered just a 12-45 record in its previous five seasons.
After being hired at James Madison in 2018, he was faced with a different type of mission — not rebuilding a program, but maintaining one. The Dukes were royalty at the Football Championship (FCS) subdivision level, with 10 playoff appearances in a 15-year span before Cignetti’s arrival and two national championships, the second of which came in 2016.
With excellent facilities, a devoted fan base and substantive donor support — “There’s money here,” Cignetti said — James Madison’s move to FBS made sense when it was announced last November, especially after it made it to at least the FCS semifinals in Cignetti’s first three seasons.
“This was a program that was really poised to make the jump,” Cignetti said.
Even for the best-prepared programs, however, the transition to FBS is typically a daunting one. Coastal Carolina, one of the best Group of Five programs over the past several years, went 13-23 in its first three FBS seasons, from 2017-19. Old Dominion, a comparable school to James Madison given its enrollment and location in Virginia, has finished with a winning record just once since becoming an FBS member in 2014.
Compounding those inherent hurdles was a compressed timeline. Where schools moving to FBS typically play a schedule with half FBS opponents and half FCS ones, James Madison joined the Sun Belt Conference a year earlier than originally announced and has 11 games (of a possible 12) against FBS foes.
Starting with a 44-7 season-opening victory against Middle Tennessee State, the Dukes have not only adapted to their new surroundings, but thrived in them.
Through five games, they’re No. 6 nationally in scoring offense and No. 14 in scoring defense, making them just one of four programs to be in the top 15 in both categories. The others? Alabama, Ohio State and Michigan. Their run defense is the best in the sport, giving up just 41 yards per game and a ridiculous 1.4 yards per carry. A reflection of Cignetti’s process-based approach, which he said he learned from Saban, James Madison is also one of the nation’s most disciplined teams, as one of the top 15 FBS squads in fewest penalties per game.
“We really didn’t change the way we did things,” Cignetti said. “We talked to the kids in the spring about committing to a higher standard and that some of the things we’ve been able to get away with in the past we may not be able to get away with anymore.”
A storybook season hasn’t come without pain, though. In September, Cignetti’s father died at 84 years old after experiencing declining health the past year and a half. When Curt was a high school senior, his father, then coaching West Virginia, was diagnosed with lymphoid granulomatosis, a rare form of cancer. On two different occasions, Cignetti said, his father was administered his last rites, only to live four more decades.
The strength his father displayed and the high-character ethos he embodied not only shaped Cignetti, but they’ve stayed with him, helping him navigate a demanding, high-profile job during a time of intense grief.
“I feel like his inspiration and the lessons I learned from him live on daily,” Cignetti said. “While he’s not here in a physical sense, the memories and the things I learned from him live on until this day.”
With the regular season not even halfway over for James Madison, Cignetti’s work continues. The Dukes still have to traverse a difficult schedule in the Sun Belt, perhaps the best and most competitive non-Power Five conference, which includes a season finale against a currently undefeated Coastal Carolina team. As things stand now, James Madison won’t be able to play in the postseason, as NCAA rules mandate that new FBS arrivals complete two transitional years.
It won’t be that way forever, though, something that feeds into Cignetti’s larger dreams and ambitions. Overseeing a well-resourced program at a large school (with an undergraduate enrollment of 20,070) in a populated, talent-rich state, Cignetti believes that James Madison’s fast start might just be that — a start, with an even brighter future awaiting.
“I think we have unlimited potential, to be honest with you,” Cignetti said. “These are unprecedented times in college athletics. Things are very fluid and changing fast. With the playoff going from four to 12 in a couple of years, I really believe we can be a part of that. There’s going to be a spot there for a Group of Five, non-autonomy school. I think we’re very capable of being that school.”



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.