Bethel Park was 2-0, but this is a team that probably proved itself most Friday night — in a loss.

Bethel Park stood toe to toe with the WPIAL’s No. 1 Class 6A team. Bethel Park was pretty much even with Central Catholic in a lot of areas and even outgained the Vikings, but Bethel Park couldn’t match Central Catholic’s big plays.

Central Catholic had three big plays that resulted in touchdowns — and one of them came from the Vikings’ defense. Those big plays were the difference in Central Catholic’s 31-22 victory against the host Black Hawks in a WPIAL nonconference game.

The win gave Central Catholic, which also is the Post-Gazette’s No. 4 Class 6A team in the state, a 2-1 record. The loss came in the season opener to St. Edward’s of Ohio.

Advertise with us

“These last two weeks, we played Mt. Lebanon and Central Catholic, and we scrimmaged McDowell earlier,” said Bethel Park coach Brian DeLallo, whose team had a winless season only two years ago. “We battled with all of them. That was our weakness last year. The big, physical teams, we struggled with sometimes. We’re starting to feel like we can battle with these physical teams.”

Central Catholic actually had to come back from a 15-7 deficit after the first quarter. Junior quarterback Payton Wehner was key to the win, throwing for two long touchdowns. Wehner, who finished 14 of 19 for 201 yards, threw a nice 63-yard touchdown pass to Jayden Thrift in the first quarter and then a 48-yarder to Gavin Stanek on a third-down play that iced the game with 2:57 left.

But the defense might have provided the biggest score. Bethel Park had moved to the Central Catholic 47 late in the first half and completed a pass that was brought back because of offensive pass interference. Two plays later, Bethel Park sophomore quarterback Tanner Pfeuffer tried a short pass to the left sideline, but Central Catholic sophomore linebacker Bradley Gompers jumped in front of the receiver, intercepted and then it was a Gomp romp 45 yards for a touchdown.

“Gompers is a player. He’s got potential,” Central Catholic coach Terry Totten said. “That kind of turned the game for us.”

Besides the interception, Pfeuffer was impressive, completing 21 of 31 throws for 271 yards. On the first play after Central Catholic’s first touchdown, Pfeuffer hooked up with Dinari Clacks on a 73-yard pass play. Pfeuffer also scored on two 1-yard QB sneaks. Sophomore receiver Ryan Petras caught eight passes for 89 yards.

Advertise with us

“I was standing right there, and when the ball was in the air and I said, ‘Why did you throw it?’ ” DeLallo said of Pfeuffer’s interception. “But you’re going to have that mistake in a young quarterback sometimes. I thought he came back and really responded well in the second half. He’ll learn from it.”

Bethel Park actually outgained Central Catholic in yards, 356-311. But, oh, those big plays. Bethel Park also had a few key penalties, and Kaden Wetzel missed a 30-yard field goal on the last play of the first half. Central Catholic led at halftime 24-15.

“We proved that big plays, turnovers and penalties are killers,” DeLallo said. “High school football is so much about those three things, and we were on the short end of too many. We didn’t execute cleanly, and that’s on me more than anyone.”

Central Catholic played without standout junior linebacker Anthony Speca, who was out with an injured shoulder. Speca expects to be back for next week’s game against Mt. Lebanon. Totten also hopes talented junior receiver Anthony Gonzalez will be back soon from a knee injury.

“We’re still searching,” Totten said of his team. “I don’t know my team yet. That’s a gutsy (Bethel Park) team. They move the ball well. They have a lot of seniors. I’m happy to get out of here with a win. I really don’t know anything about us. You know how teams get that feeling in high school football and it just means everything? We’re not there yet.”

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1975 and Twitter @mwhiteburgh.