Going into the 2021 season, Gateway coach Don Holl had a tough decision to make with the much-publicized transfers of brothers Brad and Brett Birch from Jeannette.

Brett, a senior, would slot right in as a starting receiver and defensive back — no issues there. As for Brad, a sophomore quarterback who shattered records while leading the Jayhawks to a WPIAL title as a freshman, many wondered how Holl would manage the team’s quarterback situation with returning starter Carsen Engleka going into his senior year.

Once the dust had settled from preseason camp and scrimmages, Holl had a conversation with Engleka to let him know Birch would be taking over as the Gators’ starting quarterback, and that Engleka’s services would be needed as a safety on defense.

“I’m sure there was an element of disappointment in his reaction, but as far as the reaction that he had with me, it was all we hoped to get,” Holl said. “There aren’t any better kids than Carsen.”

Advertise with us

For some established starting quarterbacks going into their senior season — especially those coming off productive years from both an individual and team standpoint — getting supplanted as the starter by a sophomore transfer would feel like a punch to the gut. Instead, Engleka has taken the shift in stride and resorted to dishing out hits on defense rather than receiving them.

“This year, we may have needed him on defense even if he was playing quarterback,” Holl said. “He’s a tough kid, he’s a smart kid, [has a] good football IQ. He can come and hit you. He’s versatile. He understands the game. He’s a captain, and he does everything we’ve asked him to do during his time at Gateway.

“He was excited about playing defense this year. Maybe that was a little bit of a consolation in the sense that he wasn’t going to be playing quarterback anymore.”

And how has Holl’s decision paid off for Gateway? The team’s 7-3 record in the regular season is a bit below the lofty standards set by the Gators in recent years, but from an individual standpoint, it’s hard to argue with Birch’s results.

Birch became the second consecutive sophomore and only the fourth sophomore ever to lead the WPIAL in passing yardage, finishing the regular season with 2,355 yards passing and 24 touchdowns to go with 11 interceptions. Armstrong’s Caden Olsen, who finished second to Birch with 2,222 passing yards in the regular season, turned the trick for the River Hawks last year.

Advertise with us

“He’s really talented and he continues to get more and more comfortable with what we’re doing,” Holl said. “As you would hope and expect, at the end of the year with a whole year under his belt, he’s more comfortable and obviously, he’s in a pretty good place right now.”

Birch has had no shortage of weapons to spread the ball around too this year, including his older brother, Brett, who has 33 catches for 482 yards and a pair of touchdowns. His top receiving target has been senior Patrick Body, a speedy Cincinnati recruit who has 39 catches for 771 yards and five scores. Body finished fifth among all WPIAL players in receiving yards during the regular season.

Sophomore running back Jaquon Reynolds has 24 catches for 351 yards, and junior wide receiver Dallas Harper has 22 grabs for 330 yards. Reynolds also has 576 yards rushing on 136 carries, and he and Harper are tied for the team lead with six total touchdowns.

“We’re not run-and-shoot,” Holl said. “Obviously, we like to have a balanced approach with the ability to throw the ball with our weapons, and [Birch] has done a good job operating that system.”

During Holl’s six-year tenure at Gateway, playing deep into the postseason has become standard procedure. The Gators have reached the WPIAL semifinals in each of the past five seasons, winning a pair of WPIAL championships in 2017 and 2019. Over the previous four seasons, Gateway compiled a record of 43-7, losing only three regular-season games combined during that stretch.

Advertise with us

This year, the Gators lost three regular-season games for the first time since Holl’s debut season in 2016, but Holl doesn’t view the losses as any cause for alarm. After all, the defeats came against powerhouse programs Penn-Trafford, Pine-Richland and Thomas Jefferson, and all three games were competitive until the end.

Gateway still managed to receive a No. 4 seed for the WPIAL playoffs and a first-round bye, which Holl spent picking the brains of revered coaches like Mt. Lebanon’s Bob Palko and New Castle boys basketball coach Ralph Blundo, searching for ways to best spend the week off while keeping his team sharp.

“We talked about what to do during the bye week and how they handled it,” Holl said. “Even talked to some college and pro guys about the bye week, and it was interesting. I thought we had a good, solid week.”

Awaiting the Gators on Friday night coming out of the bye is a high-stakes rivalry matchup vs. No. 5 seed Penn Hills at Antimarino Stadium. Gateway defeated the Indians, 41-13, earlier this season, but Penn Hills is one of the WPIAL’s hottest teams right now, having won five games in a row. The Gators have won eight of the last nine meetings between the teams, including all three playoff matchups.

“This group is young, so I think there is a little bit less certainty of how they’re going to respond in the postseason,” Holl said. “I guess we’ll see when we play. I think they understand what it takes. I think they’re excited to take on the challenge, but then you’ve got to go do it.”

Steve Rotstein: srotstein@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SteveRotstein.