Take a look at the projected starting lineups for Pitt, Penn State and West Virginia for their season openers Saturday and the dearth of starters from the WPIAL and City League is startling.
One hand. That’s all you need to count the district players who will most likely start for the three teams — only two at Pitt, two at Penn State and one at West Virginia.
That doesn’t say as much about the recruiting success of the three colleges as it does the lack of big-time talent that now comes out of Western Pennsylvania. The number of Power Five recruits from the WPIAL and City League has been dropping considerably in the past 10-15 years. Having only five starters at Pitt, Penn State and West Virginia just proves the fact even more.
Pitt’s depth chart lists only offensive linemen Jake Kradel (Butler) and Gabe Houy (Upper St. Clair) as the starters from the WPIAL. Penn State coach James Franklin isn’t releasing a depth chart to the media for whatever reason, but projections have the Nittany Lions starting two WPIAL players at defensive back — Jaquan Brisker (Gateway) and Joey Porter (North Allegheny). West Virginia will start James Gmiter (Bethel Park) on the offensive line.
Sure, Pitt, Penn State and West Virginia have lost out on some big-time recruits who decided to go elsewhere in recent years. That always happens. But remember those days when especially Pitt and Penn State were loaded with WPIAL players? Huh. Those days are long gone.
Still, I was wondering if this year’s list of WPIAL starters at Pitt, Penn State and West Virginia was really all that much different than maybe earlier in the 2000s. Some searching turned up depth charts from previous years. Consider this: Ten years ago, the depth chart for Pitt’s season opener had 11 WPIAL players in the starting lineup. That’s nine more than this season. West Virginia had only two WPIAL starters that year and Penn State one. All told, that’s 14, or nine more than this season.
Read More
Go back to 2005 and Pitt had seven starters from the WPIAL or City League, Penn State two from the WPIAL and West Virginia four from the WPIAL and City League.
Go back to the 1960s, 70s or early 1980s and you’ll find loads of starters from the WPIAL at Pitt and Penn State.
This is not to say Western Pennsylvania doesn’t have talented players any longer. Many colleges still recruit this area and also the state of Pennsylvania. But Western Pa. just doesn’t produce as many big-time players as years ago. Consider that in the past three years, the WPIAL and City League have produced a total of only 24 Power Five recruits and 58 FBS recruits. Now consider that from 2006-08, the WPIAL and City League produced 70 Power Five recruits and 116 FBS recruits. My, how things have changed.
But it’s just not the WPIAL that is producing fewer big-time recruits. Two years ago, SouthernPigskin.com, with the help of Dave Campbell’s Texas Football, did a study on the number of FBS recruits in all states from 2008 through 2019. Pennsylvania was tied with Arizona for 16th with a total of 724 (60.3 a year). But the number of FBS recruits from Pennsylvania had gone down almost every year since 2008. In 2008, the state had 73 FBS recruits. Eleven years later, Pennsylvania had only 47, possibly the lowest total ever.
It’s hard to say why Pennsylvania is producing fewer big-time players. There is not one reason. Maybe it’s just a cyclical thing. Whatever the reason, here’s to hoping those WPIAL and City League players at least have big years at Pitt, Penn State and West Virginia.
Pennsylvania rates for wins
While Pennsylvania doesn’t produce as many big-time college recruits as years ago, this state sure does have teams that win with regularity. Before the season, MaxPreps.com published a list of the winningest programs in the history of U.S. high school football. Seven of the top 64 were from Pennsylvania, including three from the WPIAL. Mount Carmel was seventh, Easton eighth, Berwick 16th and Steelton-Highspire 34th. Those are all eastern Pa. teams. But the WPIAL had Jeannette (52nd with 766 wins), New Castle (61st with 747) and Aliquippa (64th with 744).
Also, Southern Columbia from eastern Pa. is No. 2 in the U.S. for wins in the past 10 years with 140. Southern Columbia is third for wins in the past 20 years (263) and first for the past 30 years (387).
Future of the Showcase
Ron Coursey has staged a football showcase at Woodland Hills’ Wolvarena the past few years, matching teams from outside the area against teams from the WPIAL and City League on the first weekend of the season. Coursey put together the Western Pa. Vs. Everyone event while he was athletic director at Woodland Hills. The event had some top games. One of the best this year was Central Catholic vs. Imhotep Charter of Philadelphia last Friday.
But Coursey took the job as Chambersburg High School AD earlier this summer. Chambersburg, a District 3 school, is in the middle of the state. So is the event at Woodland Hills dead?
“The plan is to do a showcase style event next year (at Chambersburg),” Coursey said. “What I’d really like is to explore an event with District 7 (WPIAL). You look over the years with the state champions, with the exception of some private schools and some public schools, the majority of state champions come out of District 7 and District 3.
“I think it would be great if Woodland Hills continued to support an event. Myself and (Woodland Hills football coach and assistant athletic director) Tim Bostard have actually talked about a dual event, but we also talked about rotating it. One year, it’s here in Chambersburg, and the next it’s there. That’s on the table.”
Coursey also started the Martin Luther King Weekend Stand Against Violence Basketball Showcase in 2019. In 2020, that event had 43 games over four days with some teams from out of state. Coursey said he is taking that event to Chambersburg.
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.