One in a series on top high school football players in the WPIAL and City League.
There have been plenty of WPIAL football players over the years with enough talent to pick and choose among scholarship offers from the most prestigious college football programs in the country.
Chances are none of them saw their stock rise as rapidly as that of Peters Township’s Donovan McMillon during his junior season.
One of the most heavily recruited WPIAL players in recent memory, McMillon verbally committed to the University of Florida Saturday, choosing the Gators over other blue-bloods such as Oklahoma, Oregon, Texas A&M and Virginia Tech. The 6-foot-2, 193-pound safety/wide receiver was barely on the radar of mid-major Football Bowl Subdivision schools going into last season, but by the end of it, McMillon had nearly every school in the country attempting to secure his services.
“It was definitely always a dream for me to go play where I can watch myself on TV and everything,” McMillon said. “But when I was small and everything, I was always just bummed, and my mom just said, ‘Be patient. It’s coming.’”
Naturally, there was one question on the minds of most observers — where did this kid come from?
Read More
“He was our ball boy for a while, and I still think of him as ‘Little Donnie,’” Peters Township coach T.J. Plack said with a laugh.
McMillon spent his entire freshman year and the first half of his sophomore year playing for the junior varsity team before finally cracking the varsity starting lineup midway through the 2018 season. Shortly after, the growth spurt his mother kept telling him was coming finally arrived.
Still, not even Plack saw this kind of a breakthrough coming when McMillon was just a 5-foot-9 sophomore.
“Then during the [2019] season and after the season, things started to increase for him. Bigger schools, he started to catch their eye,” Plack said. “His tape speaks for itself, and then once you talk to the young man, he’s got a great personality. He comes from a great family.”
McMillon didn’t spend much time on offense last year, although he did catch 10 passes for 102 yards. Unlike many top-flight recruits who play at the skill positions, his tenacious and aggressive play on the defensive side of the ball is what made college scouts — and opposing coaches — take notice.
“He’s an explosive player,” said Gateway coach Don Holl, whose Gators defeated Peters Township, 21-20, in last year’s WPIAL Class 5A championship game. “I call them flesh bombs. They just come flying out of the secondary and blow things up. When you watch him on the tape, that’s what he is.”
McMillon went into that WPIAL championship game with a team-high 78 tackles — including 7 tackles for loss — to go with 2 sacks, 2 interceptions, 4 forced fumbles and 2 fumble recoveries. He also made a couple of bone-jarring hits in the game that Holl remembers vividly.
“Something my old running backs coach used to say is, ‘There’s going to be a lot of guys showing up over there in a ticked-off mood, so don’t run that way,’” Holl said. “When you watch his highlights, you see him showing up in a bad mood to a lot of receivers and ball carriers.”
Of course, it’s not hard to tell where McMillon’s penchant for punishing enemy ball carriers comes from.
McMillon was also one of the best wrestlers in the area last year, placing second at both the WPIAL and PIAA Class 3A championships in the 182-pound weight class. The two-sport star finished the season with a record of 41-4, with three of those losses coming against Canon-McMillan’s Gerrit Nijenhuis, a two-time PIAA champion and the all-time WPIAL wins leader.
“I think we all thought wrestling was his meal ticket moving on, but he loved football,” Plack said.
Still, for all his defensive prowess, some still wonder why he wasn’t more of a focal point on offense last year. According to Plack, it mostly boiled down to Peters Township having seniors Ryan Magiske, Josh Casilli and Aidan McCall already firmly entrenched as the team’s go-to playmakers.
This season, though, things should be a bit different for the Indians.
“He’s a guy we’re going to try to be creative with and get him the ball in different situations,” Plack said. “Whether it be on jet sweeps, deep post routes, play action passes — trying to get him deep. Trying to play to his strengths more.”
Time will tell whether Peters Township can find a way to unleash McMillon’s abilities on offense the way he impacted the game on defense last year. But no matter how often the Indians get the ball in McMillon’s hands, Plack insists it won’t change his defense-first mentality.
“He’s definitely a defensive player,” Plack said. “There’s just some of those kids that enjoy hitting, enjoy tackling, that are really good at it also, and he thrives on that side of the ball.”
Never was that more clear than in the Indians’ 28-10 win in the WPIAL Class 5A semifinals against top-seeded Penn-Trafford last season.
Late in the third quarter, with Peters Township clinging to a 7-3 lead, McMillon made a huge tackle on a Warriors receiver and knocked the ball loose, which Magiske scooped up and ran 43 yards for a touchdown that would prove to be the difference in the game. McMillon also tacked on an interception late in the game to seal the win.
“He did the same thing against Woodland Hills, stripped the ball and I think Magiske picked it up as well,” Plack said. “He had a huge blocked punt against Bethel Park in their territory and set the tone in that game. … He made splash plays for us on defense, he really did.
“And the big thing for him is, when anybody else is scoring, he was the first one running by everyone to celebrate in the end zone. We’re just so blessed with team players. Our guys, they love each other, they’re great, and he was just another part of it.”
Steve Rotstein: srotstein@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SteveRotstein.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.