This Week in High School Sports — Clutch QBs, Ben or Zane and more
The list of WPIAL football champions goes back 105 years, and every champion of every year is named on the WPIAL web site. But for the largest classification in 1979, the WPIAL list has only one word in capital letters.
“VACANT.”
As in unoccupied. Empty. Abandoned. No champion.
Oh, there was indeed a champion in the largest class that year. There was a championship game, too. And the kids who wore helmets with big stars on them won the title on a snowy Friday night in late November to add a little more to the dynasty that was Penn Hills football in the 1970s.
The 1979 Penn Hills team is considered one of the WPIAL’s better teams in the past 50 years. It had two future NFL players in Bill Fralic and Tom Flynn, other future Division I college players and a legendary coach in Andy Urbanic. Too bad the WPIAL still doesn’t recognize Penn Hills as the champ.
This is the 40-year anniversary of one of the strangest, most memorable, controversial championship runs in the history of WPIAL sports. It is a tale worth revisiting, a story of the championship that wasn’t, at least according to the WPIAL.
Read More
It all started when the WPIAL made Penn Hills forfeit three victories during the regular season because a seldom-used junior offensive guard played on special teams in three games when he should’ve been academically ineligible. The saga included many twists and turns. How’s this for a one-of-a-kind postseason story: Penn Hills had to win two court cases just to get a spot in the postseason; the WPIAL delayed the playoffs a week while the court cases played out; the WPIAL lost the court cases and Penn Hills won a fourth consecutive WPIAL title.
Then a year-and-half later the WPIAL won another court appeal and vacated Penn Hills’ championship.
Vacating the title was like what the NCAA did to the University of Michigan basketball team’s two Final Four appearances in 1992 and ‘93. The WPIAL made Penn Hills return the 1979 championship trophy, like the Heisman Trust made Reggie Bush do with his 2005 Heisman Trophy. And no WPIAL records recognize Penn Hills as the 1979 champ.
Maybe after 40 years, guys now in their mid-to-late 50s who were on that Penn Hills team wouldn’t be bothered so much by the vacancy sign at the WPIAL championship hotel. Think again.
Flynn, the star quarterback-defensive back of the 1979 team, is a Super Bowl champ, winning one as a defensive back with the NFL’s New York Giants. He and some of his old Penn Hills teammates would also like to be known as 1979 WPIAL champion.
“You can’t undo time and you can’t turn back the clock,” said Flynn, who resides in Murrysville and works in the real estate business. “What I really think should be happening is we should have that championship reinstated. If people aren’t familiar with the story, maybe this story will educate them. They may think there were no playoff games because of a flood or something.
“But there were games. We won the championship. I mean, a junior who played three games on kickoff teams … and we get the championship taken away. I understand the WPIAL wanted to be in charge, but with that responsibility also comes a certain amount of patience and empathy. That championship should be reinstated.”
Maybe then there would be closure for these former Penn Hills players. Fralic died of cancer last year. Some of his former teammates visited him in Atlanta two weeks before he passed. The 1979 subject came up.
P.J. Murray was a starting defensive end who played next to Fralic on the Penn Hills line in 1979. Flynn was the best man in Murray’s wedding years ago.
“A lot of us from that time, I don’t want to say we’re bitter,” Murray said. “But every time we look in a newspaper or something and see the vacancy sign for 1979, that’s not right. We know we played and we know we won. It’s not vacant.”
Urbanic said, “That trophy may have been taken away, but they’ll never take away what it’s in our minds and hearts.”
Hoagies and the court cases
Maybe if it wasn’t for a hoagie sale, who knows what would’ve happened in the WPIAL Class 3A playoffs in 1979.
From 1976-78, Penn Hills had a 37-1-1 record with 19 shutouts and three WPIAL titles, including one co-championship (Penn Hills tied Butler, 7-7, in the 1977 title game). The Indians shut out Dan Marino and Central Catholic in the 1978 WPIAL playoffs. In 1979, Penn Hills was trying to become the first team in WPIAL history to win four consecutive titles in the WPIAL’s largest classification.
Dan Miller is the baseball coach at Penn-Trafford High School and was a backup defensive back on the 1979 team. Penn Hills beat Latrobe, 30-9, in a big game in the seventh week of the season. Miller and other Penn Hills players vividly remember the highly-successful Urbanic almost reduced to tears when he addressed the team in the locker room after the game.
“We didn’t know why. He didn’t tell us,” Miller said. “But it was because he knew what might be ahead of us. We might have to forfeit.”
Penn Hills administrators and Urbanic turned themselves in to the WPIAL after finding out a backup offensive guard played sparingly in three games when he shouldn’t have because he was academically ineligible. It was a clerical error made by the Penn Hills district.
In many newspaper stories and in the court proceedings, the ineligible player was never named. But the WPIAL, then led by Charles “Ace” Heberling, ordered Penn Hills to forfeit three victories, which would knock the Indians out of the WPIAL playoffs and send Kiski Area to the postseason instead as the Foothills Conference champion. The PIAA backed the WPIAL in its ruling.
But Penn Hills wasn’t going down without a fight — or at least a hoagie sale. The parents and boosters filed a complaint against the WPIAL and PIAA in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court.
“For the last couple weeks of the regular season, our parents ran this giant hoagie sale to pay for the attorneys,” Flynn said. “I don’t know how many thousand hoagies we sold.”
On Nov. 3, exactly one week before the playoffs were to begin, after testimony from Penn Hills, the WPIAL and PIAA, Judge Nicholas Papadakos ruled Penn Hills did not have to forfeit the three victories, which opened the door for the Indians to go to the playoffs. A small group of Penn Hills players were in the courtroom when Papadakos made his ruling.
Steve Hecht of the Post-Gazette reported Papadakos saying, “By applying their standards rigorously, without regard to mitigating circumstances, the PIAA is unreasonably denying the participating student, and more importantly, the entire innocent team from participating fully in all of the educational activities and facilities for which each can qualify in accordance with their individual talents and abilities.”
But the case wasn’t over. A few days later when the WPIAL announced playoff pairings, the league also announced the Class 3A playoffs — the largest classification then — would be delayed a week because the WPIAL and PIAA were appealing Papadakos’ ruling.
Then on Nov. 15, one day before Penn Hills’ first playoff game, Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court Judge James Bowman upheld Papadakos’ ruling.
Penn Hills went on to win three WPIAL playoff games and the championship on Nov. 30, 1979, when it defeated Gateway, 3-0, at Mt. Lebanon Stadium.
But the WPIAL and PIAA wouldn’t let the matter rest. They filed another appeal. And in March of 1981, about 15 months after Penn Hills won its championship, a three-judge panel in Commonwealth Court ruled that Penn Hills should not have been allowed to compete in the 1979 playoffs. That opened the door for the WPIAL board of control to vacate the title a few weeks later.
“We feel we were exonerated,” Heberling told the Pittsburgh Press. “We’ve maintained that a voluntary association has the right to manage its own affairs according to its constitution as long as it uses discretion in those matters.”
The championship run
Penn Hills’ 1979 team outscored opponents, 255-79, and finished with a 12-1 record. The only loss was in the season opener to Cincinnati Moeller, 30-13, in front of 20,000 fans at Nippert Stadium in Cincinnati. Moeller was a nationally-renowned program under coach Gerry Faust, who would be the head coach at Notre Dame only two years later.
The 1979 Penn Hills team was loaded with size, athleticism and big-time talent. Flynn was a superb athletic quarterback in the days when teams didn’t pass much. He also was a standout defensive back.
“I know I’m biased because he’s my friend, but Tom Flynn is the best athlete to ever come out of Penn Hills,” said Murray, now a Pittsburgh lawyer. “He played basketball and ran track. He was a good baseball player when he was younger, too.”
Penn Hills also had the man, er, teenager Fralic on the lines. One of Western Pennsylvania’s all-time greats, Fralic was a varsity starter as a freshman, which was unheard of back then. He was a junior on the 1979 team.
“We didn’t watch a lot of our game tape back then because we were winning so much,” Murray said. “But when we did, there wasn’t a defensive tackle who didn’t look like he was going backward on roller skates because Billy was blocking him. And on defense, if you didn’t double-team him, he was in the backfield.”
But Penn Hills had so much more than Fralic and Flynn, who eventually went to Pitt as did senior Tom Johnson (linebacker) and junior Bob Lawson (receiver). Senior Leon Rhodes (lineman) went to Virginia Tech. One of Penn Hills’ assistant coaches was Neil Gordon, who would eventually become head coach eight years later and went on to win a WPIAL title in 1995.
“We had some outstanding players but we also had a bunch of darn good players who thought they were better than they were — and played that way,” Urbanic said. “It was ingrained in them that they were darn good and they played above their capabilities. Add that with the super players, and it made a good recipe for a championship.”
Urbanic won’t say which of his four championship teams was the best. But the 1979 WPIAL playoffs started for Penn Hills with an easy 31-0 victory against Southmoreland. The Scotties never made the playoffs again until this season.
Then came a semifinal game against North Hills in front of a packed house at Valley High School. This was coach Jack McCurry’s first outstanding team at North Hills, which had allowed only one touchdown all season. Penn Hills got a 20-yard field goal from Mike Holodonik on the team’s first possession, the first points North Hills gave up since the second game of the season. Penn Hills scored again in the first quarter, but the touchdown was produced by the defense. Lineman Kevin Ewing intercepted a short Norb Dietrich pass and returned it 23 yards for a touchdown.
Penn Hills never scored again, but still won, 10-7. Holodonik’s field goal was an all-important three points. And think of it: North Hills gave up only two touchdowns all year and didn’t win a title.
In the championship game, Penn Hills met rival Gateway on a cold, snowy November night.
“I remember them blowing snow off the field before the game,” Urbanic said.
Neither team’s offense could do much in the cold. Penn Hills moved to the 1-yard line early in the fourth quarter, but Flynn fumbled the ball away. But Penn Hills drove deep into Gateway territory once more in the fourth quarter to set up Holodonik for a field-goal try. He had missed from 24 and 35 yards earlier in the game. But Holodonik, who used a straight-on kicking style, made good on a 28-yarder with 3:31 left and Penn Hills celebrated a fourth consecutive title.
The Indians were definitely a dynasty, going 49-2-1 over four seasons. The Indians had 26 shutouts and allowed teams an average of only 4.8 points in those 52 games.
“The common denominator with all those great teams we had back then was Andy and the coaching staff,” Flynn said. “Andy is one of those people I am glad I came in contact with in my life. We weren’t easy on him. He put up with a lot of mischief from us. We didn’t get in trouble with the law, but just mischief.”
There were no PIAA playoffs back then, so Penn Hills’ season was over after the Gateway game. The Indians took their championship trophy home — until the WPIAL demanded it back.
No one knows whatever happened to that trophy. Penn Hills has a banner in its gym listing the WPIAL championships the school won. The year 1979 is listed. So, Penn Hills still calls itself a champion even though the WPIAL doesn’t.
Penn Hills didn't win the WPIAL in 1980, losing to Mt. Lebanon in the semifinals. Fralic went off to be an All-American at Pitt and an All-Pro in the NFL. Urbanic left after the 1980 season to become an assistant at Pitt. He later became an assistant under Faust at the University of Akron before becoming an athletic administrator for two decades at Florida State. Urbanic, 82, is retired and living with his wife in Land O’ Lakes, Fla.
Some former Penn Hills players, including Miller, Murray and Ewing, have gotten together and started a Bill Fralic Lineman of the Year award that will be given to one WPIAL lineman in December. Urbanic plans to come to the banquet for the award.
It’s a safe bet the 1979 Penn Hills Indians will come up in conversation. After all, they were champions, even if the WPIAL says not.
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.