After one of the best football seasons in school history, Peters Township had plenty to be proud of in 2018.

The Indians won 10 games and made it to the WPIAL semifinals for the first time in 42 years and only the third time ever. They knocked off one of the strongest teams in Class 5A in the most thrilling game of the quarterfinal round, ending Penn-Trafford’s season with a last-second field goal in a 38-35 win.

Still, the returning players from last year’s team can’t help but dwell on the one that got away.

“Aw, that game — it’s still in my mind,” junior linebacker Corban Hondru said. “I remember every play from it.”

Advertise with us

“It’s in my mind every day when we’re out there,” senior wide receiver Josh Casilli said. “I’m sure it’s in our defensive coaches’ minds, too. We just ran out of gas.”

“It’s rough thinking about it, but what can you do now? We just use it as motivation and keep working hard,” junior running back Ryan Magiske said.

Peters Township led by two touchdowns against eventual WPIAL and PIAA champion Penn Hills in the WPIAL semifinals, but gave up 22 unanswered points and lost 22-14. It would have been the Indians’ first WPIAL championship game appearance had they held on to win.

So how often does junior quarterback Logan Pfeuffer replay the memories of that loss in his head?

“Sometimes — every night,” Pfeuffer said. “I watch the film of that game, just all the throws I could have made that would have helped our team. We had injuries, not everyone was 100 percent. Hopefully this year is different.”

Advertise with us

Indians coach T.J. Plack hasn’t forgotten about the heartbreaking defeat, but that doesn’t mean he’s second-guessing himself over it, either.

“I wouldn’t have done anything differently. We prepared for that game just as much — probably even more, if I’m being honest,” Plack said. “Those are big, high-stakes games. Our kids were ready to go. We played well, and they’re a good team, and the clock ran out on us … we gave everything we had.”

While the loss to Penn Hills haunted Peters Township all offseason, the Indians can take solace in the fact that they have almost all of their key players back from last season. Penn Hills, meanwhile, lost 14 starters from last year’s unit.

The teams don’t play each other in the regular season, but if they happen to cross paths again in the postseason, Magiske believes Peters Township would be the rightful favorite to emerge from the rematch victorious.

“I have faith that we’re the better team this year,” Magiske said.

Advertise with us

Offensive weapons galore

Pfeuffer will resume quarterback duties after passing for 2,045 yards and 24 touchdowns in his first season as a starter last year. Meanwhile, Magiske and Adrian Williams, the team’s two leading rushers from 2018, are both returning to the backfield. Magiske ran for 1,085 yards and scored 21 touchdowns a year ago, while Williams ran for 404 yards and a pair of scores.

Casilli, a Penn recruit, is back after catching 47 passes for 877 yards and 14 touchdowns last season, while the rest of the receiving corps will mostly be comprised of new faces. Hondru caught 15 passes for 259 yards in 2018 and will likely line up at receiver from time to time, but he’s a defender at heart. He’s started every game at middle linebacker since the first scrimmage of his freshman season.

“I’ve heard about this kid, and sometimes the legendary status is not all it’s hyped up to be,” Plack said. “But when he came up here, we had an injury over the summer, and he jumped into our Mike position over the summer … he has never left that position.

“ … He’s a guy that I haven’t seen many like him, at all. He’s just a tremendous young man.”

Advertise with us

Swiss army knife

Plack has mostly kept Hondru under wraps on offense, but sooner or later, he may have no choice but to unleash him — the only question is, where?

“Corban’s probably our second-best tailback, he’s probably our second-best receiver, he’s our best tight end, he’d be our best guard, great center — he could probably be our second-string quarterback,” Plack said. “We rest him on offense — he plays our H-back for us — but big games, he plays a bunch of different positions for us.”

Taking the next step

With the slate wiped clean and the start of a new season just a few days away, Pfeuffer thinks what the team accomplished last year is only the beginning. With so many talented players returning, Peters Township’s rapidly ascending program may finally be ready to play for a championship.

Advertise with us

“I think it’s special,” Pfeuffer said. “We have something here, and we can do something big this year. We’ve just got to put it together.”

Steve Rotstein: srotstein@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SteveRotstein.