Going into last season, Peters Township coach T.J. Plack said his team was finally on people’s radar.
A conference title and 10-win season later, and the Indians aren’t just on the radar … they now have a target on their back, too.
Fresh off winning its first conference title in 43 years, Peters Township returns most of its top skill players, giving the Indians the look of a team that might not just contend for another conference title, but perhaps win the program’s first WPIAL championship.
“I don’t know where we’ll be in the mix,” said Plack, who is in his fourth season. “Our goal is to make the playoffs and win the conference. By that time, we hope to have our line ready and we can make a run.”

Solidifying the lines is the team’s biggest challenge. The Indians graduated all five starters — two of them all-conference picks — from their offensive line and return only one starter along the defensive line. Senior defensive end Zach Magnotti was an all-conference performer last season. Magnotti will start somewhere on the offensive line and junior Austin McKinnon should see considerable time on both sides, but who joins them is anybody’s guess.
“We have a whole bunch of guys with no experience,” said Plack, whose team shared the conference title with West Allegheny. “We’ve got 10 guys, but I don’t know which of those 10 guys will play. The five toughest guys will be in there.”
That was the question mark. Now comes the exclamation point … Peters Township is loaded at the skill positions. Junior quarterback Logan Pfeuffer is the top returning passer in Class 5A, senior Josh Casilli the top returning receiver and senior Ryan Magiske the No. 3 returning rusher.
Those three headline an offense that should be one of the best in the class. Peters Township averaged a conference-best 32.2 points per game last season when it finished 10-3. After a 16-14 loss at Upper St. Clair in their second game, the Indians won nine of their next 10 before falling to eventual WPIAL and PIAA champion Penn Hills, 22-14, in the WPIAL semifinals.
Pfeuffer (6 feet 1, 170 pounds) excelled a year ago in his first season as a starter, throwing for 2,045 yards and 24 touchdowns. One of his best games came in a 33-21 win against Moon when he threw for 308 yards and four touchdowns. Plack said he will ask Pfeuffer to do more this season. Last year’s passing attack was heavy on screens and short routes, but expect more passes downfield as Pfeuffer has become more comfortable running the offense.
Casilli, one of only seven seniors on the team, has been a starter since Week 3 of his freshman season. As a junior, he led the team with 47 receptions for 877 yards and scored 14 touchdowns on his way to all-conference honors.
“He’s tremendous,” Plack said. “The one thing people overlook is he’s strong. He’s hard to bring down. He’s fast. He’s explosive. He’s competitive. Everything you want in a guy on the outside. He’s a guy we have to target 15 times a game. If we didn’t do that, we’d be bad coaches.”
Senior Adrian Williams was second on the team with 404 yards rushing last season, but will move to wide receiver this season. By doing that, the Indians add an explosive slot receiver who can make big plays on screens and short routes, and can then pair promising junior Michael Peyton with Magiske at running back.
“I think it’s a better fit for him and we get another skill player on the field,” Plack said.
Magiske rushed for 1,085 yards on 164 carries a season ago, an average of 6.6 yards per carry. He also scored 21 touchdowns, which ranked second to only Gateway’s Derrick Davis among returning players.
On the other side of the ball, Peters Township returns eight starters, three of them who earned all-conference recognition last season — Magnotti at defensive end, junior Corban Hondru at linebacker and senior Aidan McCall at cornerback. Plack said Magnotti will likely break the school career sack record this season. McCall has started since midway through his freshman season.
Hondru started every game as a freshman and developed into arguably one of the WPIAL’s best linebackers as a sophomore last season. Peyton also returns as a starting linebacker.
“He’s extremely good,” Plack said of Hondru. “He runs our defense. We played West Allegheny early in the year and Bob Palko came over and told me, ‘I’m calling every [college] coach in my cell phone because that’s a fantastic ballplayer.’”
All five starters return in the secondary. McCall and Casilli are the cornerbacks, while Magiske, Williams and junior Donovan McMillon are the safeties.
All in all, this has the makings of being a special season for the Indians, who are now the hunted after spending many years as the hunter.
“We’ll go as far as our offensive line can take us,” said Plack. “We feel confident with our skill positions and I know our defensive line will be fine. It’s up to us to find five to eight guys who can play there. We play some good programs early. We need to find a way to win there, and progressively their confidence will get better.”
Brad Everett: beverett@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BREAL412
Coach: T.J. Plack
Years at school: 4
2018 record: 10-3
WPIAL playoff appearances: 14
Returning starters: Offense 5, Defense 8
Key returners: Josh Casilli (6-0, 180, Sr., WR-CB), Corban Hondru (6-1, 230, Jr., TE-LB), Aidan McCall (5-9, 170, Sr., WR-CB)
Keys to success: Developing an offensive line that returns only one starter. Keep the momentum of last season going.
Schedule
*Non-conference game




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.