The WPIAL board of directors listened Monday to Penn Hills’ plea to reduce a penalty on football coach Jon LeDonne. But when the smoke cleared, the WPIAL still wanted LeDonne suspended for the first game of next season.

This smoky situation goes back to the WPIAL 5A championship game Nov. 23 at Norwin High School. Two smoke devices were set off by two Penn Hills players when the Indians came on the field minutes before the start of the game. Penn Hills did the same thing the week before at Norwin in the semifinals; the WPIAL sent Penn Hills a letter, telling them not to do it again. But to no avail. The smoke device put a cloud of white smoke on the Penn Hills sideline for a few minutes before the title game.

In December, the WPIAL ruled Penn Hills would be barred from the playoffs in 2019 unless the school suspended LeDonne for the first game. Penn Hills appealed the ruling, and the WPIAL had an appeal hearing Monday at league offices in Green Tree. Penn Hills superintendent Nancy Hines spoke to the WPIAL board, asking the league to reduce the sanctions because LeDonne had no idea that the players would set off the smoke device. LeDonne also attended the hearing along with Penn Hills principal Eric Kostic, athletic director Stephanie Strauss and a few assistant coaches.

In December, the WPIAL also ordered all coaches to take a sportsmanship class. Hines contended “the punishment doesn’t fit the crime.” She said the WPIAL should reduce the sanctions because the school district is going to have some players and students take a class in firework safety and smoke inhalation. Some students would also do community service for fire victims or others with reading disorders.

Advertise with us

Hines, Kostic and LeDonne were peppered with questions from some WPIAL board members. WPIAL executive director Tim O’Malley asked LeDonne a few times who is ultimately responsible for the actions of the players. LeDonne said he was, but LeDonne said the players were told the week before the title game not to set off the smoke devices again. Hines said two individuals who were not on the team gave two players the smoke devices as they exited the locker room and headed to the field.

The players who set off the devices were not identified at the hearing and punished the night of the game. Penn Hills went on to win the WPIAL title as well as the PIAA championship two weeks later. LeDonne said he instituted punishment at practice the following week, having the players push metal weight plates the length of the field for 30 minutes at practices.

When LeDonne was asked why he didn’t punish the players the night of the championship, he said, “I had the WPIAL championship on my mind.”

He then added, “Have you ever pushed plates 100 yards for a half hour?”

LeDonne declined comment about the ruling.

Advertise with us

The WPIAL board of directors voted unanimously not to lift the sanctions.

“It was based on the fact that the coach is responsible for the actions of his players. Hence the consequences for what they did,” said O’Malley. “Their refusal to follow the directives, somebody had to be responsible. … First of all, it violates the health and safety of people and it’s against their own school policy. How many people in the stands could’ve been affected and then who’s liable for that? What happens if whatever it was they started on fire dropped and it burned the turf.

When O’Malley was told the WPIAL is being criticized for its ruling and has been called a “bunch of old timers,” he replied: “There are rules in place. Maybe we are old fashioned, but it is the way it is.”

Other WPIAL matters

• The WPIAL will bring Bishop Canevin in for a hearing in the future over accusations that an assistant coach for the girls basketball team is recruiting players.

Advertise with us

“There have been some concerns raised that he has interacted with some people from the Pittsburgh City League junior high teams,” said O’Malley. “It’s all hearsay but we’re going to bring them in to be heard.”

• With Albert Gallatin dropping out of the WPIAL for football, the seven teams left in the Class 5A Big East Conference will have an open date next season because the WPIAL doesn’t have anyone for them to play. O’Malley said Penn-Trafford has filled its open date with a game against Massillon Washington, a tradition-rich program in Ohio.

• Under the PIAA’s new rule affecting those who transfer after the start of participation in a sport in 10th grade, Theodore Newhouse-Godine is not eligible for postseason competition in basketball at Avonworth after recently transferring from Central Catholic. Newhouse-Godine also is ineligible for the postseason in football in 2019 because he played football this past season at Central Catholic.

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh.