Varsity Xtra: Which WPIAL teams will make it to the PIAA championships?

Mike White: Tuesday before the final weekend of the regular season ... hello everybody. Anyone wanna talk? Playoffs to talk about. I did bigger story last week on talent in Western Pa. being down. Let's get to it.

ptfan: With it being week 9 (or 10) tis the season for coaching changes....any rumblings you've heard about potential openings?

Mike White: No I haven't.

OBSERVER: What do you think of Albert Gallatin pulling out of the WPIAL in football? I hear others are to follow, including Uniontown.

Advertise with us

Mike White: I have no idea if others are thinking about it, too. Hey, maybe they could have their own Fayette County league of teams struggling. Throw in Brownsville. As for Al Gall, I don't blame them. I know WPIAL isn't real happy because it will come in the middle of a two year cycle. Every team in that conference will now have an open week next year. WIll they be filled. But Al Gall has struggled for so long. Worst program in WPIAL last 20 years and they've won something like 53 games since mid 80s. They say they want to try and save program. I can't say I blame them.

Football Guru: In 3A, which conference do you think is the harder one to play in?

Mike White: Well there's only two so there's not a big choice. I'd probably give edge to Quad County West.

Jimmy: I saw your post about not many top level talent And I absolutely agree with you but my question is, do you see in around 5 years that talent returning but the teams will be smaller if you catch my vibe?

Mike White: Things do run in cycles, so maybe. But I will tell you this. The junior class of talent in WPIAL is no better and might be worse than this year. And there aren't exactly a number of sophomores that people are pointing at as big-time players. So if that's any indication, then I'd say we're not going to see an upward trend for at least a few years. I'm sorry I'm not real up on my 7th and 8th graders.

Advertise with us

HeyMike: Can we get a quick City Championship Game preview/prediction?

Mike White: Should be close. Actually nice to see Westinghouse back in title game. Maybe re-living some glory days. I'm going to with Allderdice.

Class A: Who u think wins the Clairton vs Jeannette game and where do u think the loser will be seeded in the playoffs

Mike White: 1 vs. 2 game. I'll give Jeannette the edge. Their defense has come up big in big games this year vs. Imani and OLSH. That might be the difference. As for where the loser will be seeded, that's a really good question. If Jeannette loses, I say Jeannette will be No. 2. The loser will be either 2 or 3. But does that really matter? Seriously. 2 and 3 will be on the same side of the bracket anyway and would be set up to meet in semifinals. I don't see loser dropping to No. 4.

David: NA v. Pine Richland Prediction?

Advertise with us

Mike White: The one most people have been waiting for. I'd give the edge to Pine. I think Pine's defense might be the difference. I think Pine's defense is pretty good. NA's defense has come on. Another thing to watch is will that big, experienced Pine offensive line be the difference. But in the end, I just want to know who has that Pine-RIchland flag? Did Phil take it Notre Dame? Will it make an appearance again and cost somebody a chance to see the field hockey championships.

WPIAL 2A: If you had to guess what would your top 4 seeds be in order for the 2A playoffs?? Would they jump a 2nd place finisher (steel valley, Washington) over a Burgettstown or Mohawk?

Mike White: The question is what do you do with Steel Valley. They are going to finish second in the conference no matter what. Steel Valley is done with conference games. I think Steel Valley gets a top three seed. Even if Washington finishes second, I don't think they are going in the top three. Washington's offense has been impressive, but boy they give up a lot of points. And Washington isn't being seeded ahead of Charleroi. So I

Mike White: To finish, I would go Shady Side No. 1 if they win, Steel Valley 2, Burgettstown 3, Charleroi 4. Then what do you do with Mohawk?

OBSERVER: I don’t blame AG, either. Is it time the WPIAL allows schools to schedule their own non-conference games?

Advertise with us

Mike White: Well, they used to let teams schedule non conference games. Then the schools came to WPIAL and asked them to schedule non conference. Some were having trouble getting games, especially the good teams. Because no one wanted to play them. So don't blame the WPIAL. At one time, schools wanted it one way. Then they wanted it another way. Now they might want a change again? Who knows. But don't blame WPIAL for this one.

Class A: In class A first round playoffs will the teams play each other if they played each other in the season

Mike White: That is a possibility. And with eight teams, that might happen. WPIAL said a few years ago that could happen.

Tim Oschmalley: The year is 2018. All games finish on Saturday. Do we dare upset the delicate genius of the WPIAL playoff committee and meet Saturday night/Sunday and get the pairings out before the week starts? Teams operate on a short week/many teacher have to take off work to get a game plan together for their kids. Why is this still the case?

Mike White: This has been said by people before. Yes, it could be done. It might makes things a little easier. But all teams are in the same boat. No one has an advantage over the other.

Advertise with us

WestmorelandWill: It's Canon-Mac getting the last spot in 6A right? NO WAY Butler beats CM!!!

Mike White: Agree. No way Butler wins. Only way Canon-Mac doesn't get 6 is if they lose and Norwin beats Seneca. I don't think either is happening.

John: Mike has WPIAL ever had a training session on how to run a successful program? Maybe get 3 top coaches to help some of these struggling districts.

Mike White: What? You want the WPIAL to bring in a team and tell them how to run a program. That would go over well.

HeyMike: Are any schools thinking about giving up they football programs or merging schools?

Advertise with us

Mike White: No idea. I don't think any are thinking of giving up their program. But let's get the PIAA started on that 8-man league like I've mentioned. I bet you would have some schools join if you announce it in January and to start in 2020.

WashCo: 2 questions - Wash High vs. McGuffey - prediction? And, if Peters wins conf...would they have chance vs. Penn Hills, Gateway or the Port?

Mike White: The over/under for Wash High vs. McGuffey is 100, according to colleague Brad Everett. I might take the over. First one to 70 in this one wins. I'll go Wash High. ... As for Peters Township, I like their team. Saw them Friday. Like how physical they played defensively and the QB for a sophomore is very good. Slender, but like his arm. T.J. Plack has done a terrific job with that program and they could be good for a few years. Has to replace lineman next year. The Corban Hondru kid is one of the best LBers around and he's onlyu a sophomore.

Football Specialist : What is your prediction for the 3A title game?

Mike White: I'm going to go with a sleeper ... go out on a limb ... and say that Aliquppa will win it.

Advertise with us

Varsity Xtra: Tri-County South positions determined by coin flip?

Guest: Is there any reason why the WPIAL schedules non-conference games so late in the season? Ex: NA vs. West Allegheny last week (week 9). Seeing that the games result doesn't affect standings, why play the game so late in season and risk injury with playoffs only 1 week away. If game is scheduled early, and someone is injured, may have time to heal before playoff run.

Mike White: Well Guest, it's pretty simple. You look at conference breakdowns. There are nine teams in 6A. That means there are eight conference games. One team will not have a conference game every week. So you have one team every week with a non conference game. A few other conferences have an odd number of teams. Someone has to be off. That's why there are non conference games late in the season.

WashCo: 1: Prediction: wash high vs McGuffey?

Mike White: Already gave that. I'll go Wash High but take the over in this game. First team to 70 wins.

OBSERVER: I in no way blamed the WPIAL for scheduling non-conference games. I am aware schools asked them to schedule those games. Just asking your opinion. Some of these non-conference match ups are senseless. I guess we’ll see.

Advertise with us

Mike White: Well observer, the Eastern conference had to play somebody in non conference games. I know Tri-County South will get three teams in and that might not seem right. But Eastern will get three also. If Imani wins against Char-Houston, Imani will get a wild card. Laurel is most likely the team out. I know it is hard to swallow if you're Laurel, when you see three Tri-County South teams going. But those teams will probably all tie for first in the conference. Hard to tell a team that ties for first that you can't go to the playoffs.

WashCoFan: Which sport is harder to turn a struggling program into a playoff contender? Football or Basketball?

Mike White: That's pretty easy. Football. Just because it takes 11 to play football. One really good player in hoops and another pretty good player can do wonders in hoops, especially at the smaller classes.

OBSERVER: Washington will need 50 to beat McGuffey and I don’t think they’ll quite get there. Unless McGuffey makes turnovers/mistakes they’ll win because Washington will never stop them.

Mike White: Could definitely be true. But will McGuffey stop Washington?

Advertise with us

Panther MBA: I don't think John's idea is far fetched. I think he means a coaching clinic. College Coaches do it all the time. So do business's and Industry. Maybe a retired coach like soon to be Bob Palko could give a seminar on effective Program Management.

Mike White: Give it a shot. Palko could probably use some money when he retired.

Quad North Fan: A few weeks ago I speculated that Butler should pull out of WPIAL for a few cycles. Now AG has done that. Any rule preventing other districts from accepting those teams and them being eligible for playoffs in that district? Perhaps joining D8?

Mike White: Yes, any switching of districts must be approved by PIAA. Farrell wants to come back to WPIAL. PIAA hasn't approved it. No way PIAA approves a school going to another district for one sport only, just because they can't compete.

WPIAL Lifer: Not to beat the A-G decision to death, but I don't like the timing. I totally understand the rationale and the need to get program on better footing, but not really fair to other schools to make this decision in middle of 2-yr cycle. Any chance the WPIAL might push back on them and say "stay for one more year or leave WPIAL for all sports?" I mean, member schools have to keep other members in mind, right??

Advertise with us

Mike White: I doubt it.

2AFootballFan: Mike, don't sell Avonworth short this week vs. Shady Side Academy. They were unstoppable against McGuffey until a couple of ill time turnovers took place. I think that it will be a close game.

Mike White: I'm not selling Avonworth short. I think they have a legit chance to win. I like Avonworth. But I think Shady Side has to be the favorite. I think Skyy Moore is a legit candidate for Player of the Year. Haven't seen him play a game, but love his highlights. Has offer from Tulsa for defense. I think he is underrated as far as a college recruit. More schools should look at him. Is athletic. Has good body.

WashCoFan: Surprised at all by Mars success this season, being one of the smallest 5A schools?

Mike White: No. Scott Heinauer has won at all levels. He has a program going. Just that a few other schools are a little above them in 5A.

Advertise with us

JP: How do you see 4A TJ SF look like the top two.

Mike White: Yes, I'll go out on another limb and say TJ is one of the top teams and will get to the championship. Please don't forget Belle Vernon, even though their starting QB is done.

Raider: Some I know think Seneca can get to Heinz Field this year. I don't agree. PR just handled them easily. Your thoughts against NA if they are on their side of bracket and end up in a semi?

Mike White: Well P-R won 21-7. I wouldn't say they "handled them easily." Seneca's defense has been impressive. But their offense is lacking. I can't see them beating NA or Pine unless one of those teams makes a number of turnovers in the game.

Tim Oschmalley: Yes Michael no one has an advantage you’re very quick today. I’m not saying people have an advantage...I am just saying it would make more sense for athletics AND academic for coaches who teach to be able to get

Advertise with us

Mike White: Maybe.

Tim Oschmalley: Mike who said anything about an advantage. Always trying to start drama. Just would help teachers focus on the classroom and not take days off to gameplan.

Mike White: Please. How is "starting drama" saying no one has an advantage if you do it Monday.

Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.

Support journalism. Subscribe today.

Advertise with us

WPIAL FAN: How do you justify most conferences getting so many teams into the playoffs that have losing records but 1A only gets 8. I get you dont want blow outs in the first round but all other conferences will definitely have blow outs.

Mike White: Because WPIAL wants four games at Heinz Field. That means four classes have to have eight-team playoff fields. That's basically why.

Wpial 4 life : Hey mike what they happened to Bethel last week wow fell apart? Are there issues there?

Mike White: It was mystifying. Even coach Jeff Metheny said he was mystified. I never saw a Bethel team handled like that. But that's why you can never be sure about teenagers. And sometimes things start to snowball in a game, and it's hard to stop it. I think Bethel bounces back and this week's USC game is close. Tossup game.

C-TOWN: rumor has it the WPIAL has come down on Clairton for the events that happened last year against Summit Academy and they cannot play a home game even though will either first or second and should get a home game. Can you confirm this?

Advertise with us

Mike White: I can't confirm that.

Quad North Fan: Did Altoona play all sports in WPIAL a few years back?

Mike White: No just football. But they came to WPIAL for football because not many big schools in District 6 in biggest classification.

Jinx: Who do you see Charleroi playing in the first round if they ared seeded 3rd or 4th?

Mike White: No idea. Haven't looked that far ahead yet.

Allaroundfan: Saw the comment about Laurel. Hard to swallow is an understatement given how easily the beat California who is “tied for first”. Cmon WPIAL. You can do better.

Mike White: I agree. Certainly not the best system. I feel for Laurel.

BP Boy: will jump on wpial 4 life

Mike White: What????

Quad North Fan: Lebo have a punchers chance against PCC, with new PCC QB? I think maybe if they can score.

Mike White: This is not one of Central's best teams in the past decade. That said, this isn't one of Mt. Lebanon's best teams. Lebo can definitely play with Central, but I'd go with Central by maybe one to two touchdowns.

Football Specialist : So you pick the quips to take the tile but who do they take down?

Mike White: Derry or Beaver Falls

Mike White: Well that's it for now. Next Tuesday at 11. We can peruse all the WPIAL playoff pairings, which come out Monday night.