It’s very likely that the West Greene, Monessen and California high school football teams will tie for first place in the Tri-County South Conference. So, will anyone be able to make heads or tails out of the situation?

The WPIAL.

The WPIAL will most likely have to use a coin flip to break the tie and determine first-, second- and third-place teams. If you’re interested in attending … Well, you can’t. WPIAL executive director Tim O’Malley said, if needed, the coin flip will happen at the WPIAL office in Green Tree Oct. 29 at 10 a.m., and only a representative of each school is welcome. So, no tickets will be sold to this tiebreaker game.

Let’s explain how the coin flip will likely come about:

Advertise with us

Next weekend concludes the WPIAL regular season. West Greene has finished conference play with a 6-1 record in the Class 1A Tri-County South. Monessen and California are both 5-1 and heavy favorites to win their final games and tie West Greene for the title.

The WPIAL breaks three-way ties for playoff spots by head-to-head competition. If all three teams are 1-1 against each other, the Gardner Points system is then applied to break the tie. If Gardner Points doesn’t break the deadlock, the WPIAL tiebreaker system is used, where teams earn points based on comparative scores.

The bottom line is this. If Monessen beats Avella by 10 or more Friday, and California beats Mapletown by 10 or more, then West Greene, Monessen and California will all tie in records, head-to-head competition, Gardner Points and WPIAL tiebreaker points. Considering that Avella has won only one conference game (over Mapletown) and lost four of five by 10 or more points, and considering that Mapletown is winless and lost every game by 10 points, the coin flip seems awfully likely.

It’s enough to literally make you flip. The plan is to have representatives of the three schools flipping coins at the same time. The team with the different coin will be declared the third-place team. The winner of the head-to-head game between the two remaining teams will get first place. The loser will get second.

The WPIAL must do the coin flip because the first-place teams in WPIAL Class 1A conferences get a home game in the first round, as well as two of the three second-place teams. Only two of the three third-place teams in Class 1A will make the playoffs, but will play on the road in the first round. If West Greene, Monessen and California all tie with 6-1 records, one of them is guaranteed a playoff spot as a third-place team because of their record.

Advertise with us

Some might wonder why the WPIAL would have a system where a coin flip might determine playoff spots and home fields? Well, the league does have three different ways to break ties and if they are exhausted, then what?

Also, a coin flip is not totally new to the league. Back in 2002, Upper St. Clair, McKeesport and Canon-McMillan tied for first place in the Quad West Conference of Class 4A. Only the top two teams got home games in the first round. Upper St. Clair got first place with more Gardner Points. That left McKeesport and Canon-McMillan in a tie for second. Back then, head-to-head competition wasn’t used, and McKeesport and Canon-McMillan were tied in Gardner Points and also tiebreaker points. So a coin flip was needed.

McKeesport won the coin flip and second place, even though it lost to Canon-McMillan in the regular season.

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette and Twitter @mwhiteburgh