Bethel Park saw something it hadn’t seen in four years — a shutout loss.
But that’s nothing in historical terms. Peters Township now is close to seeing something it hasn’t seen in 43 years — a conference championship.
Peters Township put on an impressive performance Friday night in a big WPIAL Class 5A game. The Indians scored 21 points in the first 16 minutes and breezed to a 35-0 victory against visiting Bethel Park in an Allegheny Eight Conference game. It was the first time Bethel Park was shut out since 2014.
Now get this: Peters Township has a good shot to be a conference champ. Peters Township now is 5-1 in the conference (7-2 overall). With a win next week in the regular-season finale against Baldwin, Peters Township will win at least a share of the conference title. If two teams tie for first place, they are declared co-champs.
Peters Township versus Bethel Park
The previous conference crown for Peters Township was 1975 and the Indians won it in the final regular-season game with a victory against Fort Cherry, who happened to get a touchdown that night from Marvin Lewis, the Cincinnati Bengals coach.
Forty-three years later, Peters Township got a tremendous defensive effort and a fine performance from sophomore quarterback Logan Pfeuffer to move closer to a conference title. Pfeuffer threw for three touchdowns and also caught one from receiver Josh Casilli. Pfeuffer finished 12 of 14 for 137 yards and he now has completed 74 percent of his passes in the past five games for 1,038 yards.
Read More
This could, indeed, be a banner year for Peters Township.
“We look at that banner every time we go up there [in the gym],” said big Rob Corrado, a 6-foot-3, 305-pound senior lineman and co-captain. “It’s hiding behind the bleachers with 1975 on it. It gives us motivation.”
“You can’t hide from it,” Peters Township coach T.J. Plack said of the 43-year title drought. “We took them in the offseason and pointed to that banner. That’s our goal. … Obviously, we want the ultimate goal [WPIAL championship], but our first goal is to win the conference.”
Bethel Park-Peters Township in Game of the Week
Bethel Park also came into the game thinking conference title with a 4-1 conference mark (5-2 overall). But things weren’t good for the Blackhawks from the start as they had three penalties on their first seven plays. Then came the costliest mistake — a fumble. Peters Township recovered at the Bethel Park 22 and it was the start of good things for the Indians — especially Pfeuffer.
Five plays after that first Bethel Park turnover, Pfeuffer took a short drop and flipped the ball ahead to Casilli in the middle of the line, and Casilli easily sprinted into the end zone.

Schedules and Results
STANDINGS: WPIAL | City League
Team Pages | Sortable Statistics
Pfeuffer completed his first eight passes and threw two more touchdown passes to Aidan McCall (17 yards in the first quarter) and Jackson McCloskey (23 yards in the third quarter). Then in the fourth, Pfeuffer handed off to Casilli on an apparent end around. But Pfeuffer drifted out of the backfield and Casilli hit him with a 12-yard touchdown pass.
Ryan Magiske also scored on a 17-yard run and finished with 100 yards on 15 attempts.
Peters Township’s defense, led by sophomore linebacker Corban Hondru, held Bethel Park to 20 rushing yards and 103 total yards.
“We didn’t play well, coach well, tackle well, throw well. We didn’t do anything well,” Bethel Park coach Jeff Metheny said. “They kicked our butt and we didn’t have an answer.”
Plack said, “Bethel Park was never our rival because they always beat up on Peters. We want a rival. … That was big for us, getting on the map in their eyes.”
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.