ERIE, Pa. — Thomas Jefferson won the WPIAL Class 4A championship with a dominant defense that allowed 48 points in 12 games and pitched three consecutive postseason shutouts.

Cathedral Prep ended the Jaguars’ scoreless streak in a little less than seven minutes. Then the Ramblers ended their season for the third consecutive year.

Ohio University recruit Joe Mischler threw for a touchdown and ran for two others to lead defending PIAA Class 4A champion Cathedral Prep (12-0) to a resounding, 42-17 win against Thomas Jefferson (11-2) at Veterans Memorial Stadium. The loss dropped the Jaguars’ all-time PIAA playoff record to 10-4 and was their worst state playoff loss.

“He’s the difference, he is such a great player,” Thomas Jefferson coach Bill Cherpak said. “Without him, that’s a much, much different team, he is that good and, when we had him tied up, he ran it, when we had coverage he ran it and we tried to spy him and that didn’t work.”

Advertise with us

Mischler, who became the leading passer in District 10 history in the game, is one of several Football Bowl Subdivision recruits on the team. The Ramblers success also brought up the longstanding debate over private/​parochial schools versus public schools in the state playoffs.

“It is what it is, and we’re not playing on a level field and nobody wants to hear it and I’m not going to talk about it anymore,” Cherpak said. “It’s just not a level playing field, but that’s OK. I’m proud of the way that we played.”

Thomas Jefferson became the first team from Pennsylvania to take a lead on Cathedral Prep this season when junior kicker A.J. Meshanko knocked home a 32-yard field goal four minutes into the game. That lead, however, was short-lived as the Ramblers took command for good on their next drive when Billy Lucas shook loose for a 33-yard touchdown — the first of his two scores in the game — for a 7-3 advantage just 2:54 after the Jaguars’ field goal.

Thomas Jefferson’s problems worsened on the ensuing kickoff when running back Justin Vigna — who finished with 20 carries for 92 yards before leaving with an arm injury in the third quarter — was hit and fumbled on the return to give Cathedral Prep a short field at the Jaguars 35. The Ramblers capitalized on the mistake as Mischler ran in it from 3 yards for a 14-3 advantage at the end of the first quarter.

Cathedral Prep’s 14-point quarter was twice as many points as Thomas Jefferson had allowed in its previous  five games combined.

Advertise with us

“When you play a team as good and as talented as they are, you can’t make mistakes,” Cherpak said. “We had some momentum and just that and some other things … and, when you’re playing a caliber of team that they are, you can’t give them anything, and we just made too many mistakes. Now granted, they’re good and they were better than us.”

Thomas Jefferson stuck around for most of the first half.  Shane Sharp scored on a quarterback sneak with 7:06 left in the first half to get the Jaguars back within four (14-10), but Cathedral Prep responded immediately with a long kickoff return and another short field.

Starting at the Thomas Jefferson 35, it took only four plays before Mischler scored on a designed scramble from 19 yards to push the lead back into double digits. Cathedral Prep added a touchdown just before the half when Notre Dame linebacker recruit Matt Bauer went around right end from 1 yard for a 28-10 halftime lead.

“When you lose to a better team, what can you say [but] they were the better team,” Cherpak said.