Mike White: Happy Thanksgiving everyone - a day early. Chat got pushed back a day. Store is now open. Let's go.
herb pope: Surprised by how Rushell Shell's career turned out?
Mike White: No and yes. First off, I don't think people in Western Pa. realize how good a running back has to be - the talent he must have - to be a big time RB at Div. 1 level. Think of it, we don't produce a lot of them. I thought Shell would be good in college, but I didn't know how good. Did he get too big? I don't know. Maybe. He had his moments in college. Big game as a freshman at Pitt. Some decent games at WVU. But not what I think a lot of people expected.
Palko for Ringgold coach: since Ringgold doesn't want to pay their teachers a fair salary, shouldn't they use that money to give Bob Palko the coaching job at Ringgold?
Mike White: Really? You seriously think Bob Palko would be interested in going to Ringgold? Please. Why in the world would he do that? Plus, he still hasn't resigned at West Allegheny. But I'll tell you a job that I know would have him interested. Robert Morris. John Banaszak resigned. And honestly, if I'm RMU I'm giving him a serious look. Would be a good move I think. A high school coach going to that level? It can work with the right guy. Look at what Greg Gattuso did going from Seton LaSalle to Duquesne years ago.
Nigel: better high school quarterback? Tyler Palko or Phil Jurkovec?
Read More
Mike White: Great question. Have had this debate with a few people. I love Tyler Palko the player. I think he is underrated in the WPIAL as far as all-time great players. Since I've been doing this 30 some years, I'd put him in my top 6-7 players. And he was a darn good quarterback. Even in college. He and Jurkovec are different types of quarterbacks, though. I'd love to start a team with either. Remember Tyler also was a standout safety. So in high school, you get two players. But I'd give Phil the edge at QB. I hope Tyler or his brother doesn't bust me up the next time I see them after saying that.
Nigel: the title games were an overall dud this year, can you think of a worse year?
Mike White: What you don't like 2-0 games when one team has 20 penalties and there are something like 8 turnovers between them. But hey, Aliquippa vs. QV was at least close. Gateway-Penn-Trafford was very good game. Honestly, the games went pretty much to script, I think. I truly thought Quaker Valley and Aliquippa would be close. I thought Gateway-Penn-Trafford would be very good. I thought Pine would blow out Central and I thought TJ would handle Montour. That's what happened.
Mike White: Honestly, that first game in the morning every year is not very good. I know. Stan Savran and I do it every year for TV and it's rarely good. Sometimes it's close. But usually has no flow to it. No crispness. It might be because it's in the morning and hardly anybody is there.
Nigel: do you think teams today are better than teams from say the 90's? it seems like teams today are more balanced with a passing game, while teams back then seemed to just run the ball
Mike White: Well they score more because of the throwing. But I don't know if I'd necessarily say they are better. Some of those top teams from the 90s would play with some of the top teams today.
Charleroi4Life: who wins? Central Catholic 2004 or Pine Richland
Mike White: Man, that 2004 Central defense was terrific. One of best ever. Saw them hold Shady McCoy to something below 50 yards in state semifinals. I'd say this. Ask me again after states. Let's see how Pine does in states and then I'll pick a winner. I think Pine's place in history will truly be determined in the next three weeks. If they win the whole thing and continue to score, they have to go down as one of the best teams. But let's wait and see.
wpial fan boy: who would you bet on? TJ or Gateway in a matchup?
Mike White: I'd pay to see that one. And I think I might take TJ.
wpial fan boy: why doesn't AT&T Sports televise the A and AA title games? they televise regular season games so why not title games?
Mike White: What people continue to fail to understand is it takes money, lots and lots of money, to televise games, especially live. And truth be told, some of the lower class high school games in the past don't exactly get big ratings.
wpial fan boy: Dinucci looked amazing in the same offense as Phil, yet he looks horrible at Pitt, is it possible Phil won't live up to the hype?
Mike White: Yes it's the same offense. But I think they're totally different players. Jurkovec is definitely above him, and that's not meant as a knock to Ben. He had a terrific senior year. He had a good arm. But Phil is in a different class as far as athlete. Much, much better runner. I remember that was a knock against DiNucci. He didn't move well. Ben also had that weird release, winding up to throw. Remember, until Pitt came along late, DiNucci was going to go to Ivy League. But don't give up on DiNucci yet.
Spidermonkey: Hey Mike! First off, Happy Thanksgiving to you and your family! Second, Jeannette finally conquered The Clairton Curse... The Kennedy kid is for real! Your thoughts on Jeannette QB Seth Howard? The WPIAL should get to know him.
Mike White: I have not seen Jeannette play yet. Will see them Saturday. The Kennedy kid has been terrific. The Howard kid must be good if they moved Kennedy to WR. Should be a good game vs. imani.
wpial fan boy: if your Terry Smith, are you happy Gateway finally got over the hump, or are you bitter for not winning one yourself when you had far more talented teams than this one?
Mike White: C'mon. Be happy. It's your alma mater. Don't be bitter at someone else's success. Don Holl has been tremendous for Gateway. Really. But remember also. Those Terry Smith teams played in WPIAL's largest class.
Spidermonkey: Third, Robert Morris is going to conduct a nation wide search for it’s next coach. It should start and end in Imperial, PA just minutes from their campus. Any insight to Bob Palko at least getting an interview for that job? He would have RMU nationally ranked within 3 years.
Mike White: Already addressed this earlier. See above. I think it fits. Bob for the Bobs.
Spidermonkey: One more thing regarding the Palko to RMU possibility...Larry Kehres started out as a swim coach at Mt. Union. Look how that turned out. I️ am sure Palko is a good swimmer but I️ bet he is even a better football coach. Your thoughts Mike?
Mike White: Bob Palko and Michael Phelps are one in the same person.
Bumper Pool: Mike...great job at WPIAL telecast. You have a face for newsprint.
Mike White: Thanks Bumper Pool. That's what makes these chats so good is insight and intelligence like yours.
Mike: Do you think a TJ win against Erie Cathedral will be as close to a miracle as the 1980 US Olympic Team... After all, it is a HS Team going up against a team that the best money can buy. Years ago, New Jersey, made the Catholic, Charter & Private schools compete in their own division on a State Level.
Mike White: Thomas Jefferson winning would undoubtedly be a big upset - and accomplishment. Yep, public and private operate in different worlds. But it's not going to change.
Kevin: your feelings on Catholic schools ability to recruit players. Is there any end in site? How would you resolve this problem?
Mike White: It's not going to change. No need to waste typing strokes going over it again.
Shimmed up: Any truth to the reports that West Allegheny wide receiver coach and RMU alum Tim levcik has the inside track to the job with the colonials?
Mike White: No idea.
DT: How do you see the TJ-Erie Prep game going?
Mike White: Erie Prep winning, but TJ gives them a game. Prep has kids going to Notre Dame, Penn State, Iowa, Navy, Ohio U. Loaded. Although I think this might be TJ's best chance. Only lost 28-21 two years ago.
Saints : Who do you think is going to win the games on sat and what did u think of Jeannette and imani pulling the upset
Mike White: Jeannette and Imani pulling the upset??? You mean in semifinals??? I don't really consider either of those upsets, even though Clairton blew out Jeannette in regular season. No way that was going to happen again.
Chris PSI 1978: I am a PSI alum. I watched the TJ Montour game. TJ HAS A dominating center #63 who reminds me of AQ SHIPLEY, what can you tell me about him.
Mike White: You're talking Dom Serapiglia? Well, I know he's 6-1, 280 and he does indeed play center. I know he's big and I know I am not sure how to pronounce his last name. But you're comparing him to a guy in the NFL in A.Q. So let's stop there.
Ralph: Who wins Jeannette or Imani?
Mike White: I think it's close. I'll go Jeannette.
richardmatrazzo: With Pitt having such a poor showing this year is there any hope of recruiting ant local stars
Mike White: There are really no local "stars" left in this senior class, or at least ones they want.
Mart: Noah Plack receiving interest from Pitt. Any chance the Panthers offer and he flips his commitment?
Mike White: Mart, you're talking Noah Plack of South Fayette. He's TE-LB. Really good player. In fact coach Joe Rossi he is one of the best all-around players he has ever had. He is committed to Delaware. But is now making a visit to Temple. UCOnn also offered. Coach Rossi said Pitt came to a practice a few weeks ago. Are they sincerely interested? Hard to say. But no offer. Incidentally, we picked Place to our Fabulous 22, which comes out in paper tomorrow with two page spread but is now posted on our web site.
Jonathan Baldwin : Happy turkey day Mike. Who are the top teams in 2A boys basketball this year? Any chance Jeannette, with Anthony Johnson, gets a ring in football and basketball?
Mike White: I think Jeannette will be good this year. But Sewickley Academy has to be No. 1 going into season. Defending state champ. A few starters back. A few graduated but they had a couple talented freshmen last year that will have impacts this year.
Saints Nation: What are your thoughts on the 1A title game?
Mike White: Close. Interesting that both have used two kids at QB now. I'll go Jeannette in close one.
JP: Do you think TJ has a chance against Prep. I think they could give them game. Prep has only played one game in the last three weeks and it was not much of a test.
Mike White: See earlier question and thoughts.
Rick: Really have a problem with A and AA being held on a different weekend and Robert Morris is not a good facility for a title game.
Mike White: Well, that is what the WPIAL decided with their playoff system. No way all six are going to play at Heinz. Robert Morris isn't bad. It's nice, although I don't love it, either. It is a college venue, though. Honestly, I think they could play at NA and it might be better. NA bid to host these.
Jonathan Baldwin : Any truth to the rumor that Mike Tomlin is planning to step down and take over at Ringgold?? Really though, do you think Bobby Moe would consider Bobby Palko for the new head coach?
Mike White: Yes, Mike Tomlin is definitely going to Ringgold. Should announce right after Super Bowl. And both of his sons, Joey Porter's son and nephew, Jason Gildon's son and any son of any Steeler that ever played football will be transferring to Ringgold. Mark it down. You heard here first. It will happen.
Chris625: With hoops season right around the corner, watch out for West Mifflin. Even though they had down year last year they have a lot of key players returning and have a decent amount of size
Mike White: OK, I'll watch. ... Lance is one of my favorites.
TJ Burgman in TX: Happy Thanksgiving Mike! What's your prediction on TJ/Cathedral Prep?
Mike White: Erie Prep but I think TJ hangs in and makes it close. It seems like I get a feeling from others around state that many are rooting for TJ.
Hanza: What kind of a challenge will State College present to Pine Richland on Saturday, if any?
Mike White: State College isn't bad. In fact, they are decent. 10-2. They are always decent. QB is 6-4 and has thrown for about 1,700 yards. Have a little RB with close to 1,000. Can't see them staying within 3-4 touchdowns, though. Pine is that good and I don't think there will be a WPIAL championship hangover, either. They've been grounded and eyeing a state title game appearance. Everyone wants to see Pine and St. Joe's.
Joe Walton’s brother: What about the rumors that West a wide outs coach Tim levcik could be the top candidate for the Robert Morris job
Gates: Hoops practice started Friday... any early predictions for WPIAL winners?
Mike White: Early line No. 1 teams and this could change. Pine-Richland (6A) with Latrobe next. 5A decent again but maybe Mars gets first title? 4A Quaker Valley and New Castle again. 3A hard to say. Lincoln Park doesn't have Nelly Cummings any longer but still should be good. 2A definitely Sewickley No. 1. 1A I'm not sure yet. Have to look closer.
Ironman: There are two big game this weekend between Pine Richland and State College and the other game between Parkland and St. Joe's for District 12. Any thoughts on the game? I believe St. Joe
Mike White: Pine-Richland will roll. Parkland is very good. We've had them in state top five all year. I haven't seen them, but I don't think this St. Joe's team is as good as last year's, simply because they don't have the RB, who's now at Georgia.
Jeff: Mike, TJ has the same kind of kids as Erie Prep has. How many guys has Cherp put into D1? NFL? Nothing compared to Erie Prep. It comes down to who is better at playing football, nothing to do with money.
Mike White: What??? Who said anything about having to do with money??? I don't understand your comment.
Ironman: I know it is early, but there will be 9 teams in 6A. Anybody moving up? Will 8 teams make the playoffs or will there be a bye week for the top 4 teams? There are too many teams that make the playoffs with losing records.
Mike White: Ironman, sorry I don't have the answers to these questions. And neither does WPIAL. Schools have a little bit of time before informing PIAA if they are moving up. I can't predict what WPIAL will do. They don't even know yet until they get final numbers.
Ironman: Any word on Zmanijac at Quippa? Will he retire?
Mike White: Nope, no word. But birdie on my porch roof tweeted at me the other day to look for Z to stay another year.
Ironman: I've read plenty of comments here about Prep and TJ. I know it was early in the year and I saw the game, but Prep beat Central. Sorry to TJ fans and I know Cherpak is a great coach, but Prep is way too good.
Mike White: Ironman has spoken.
Mike White: OK, that's all folks. If you're interested, our Fab 22 is in tomorrow paper. But it is on line now at our web site. Hope everyone has a great and safe Thanksgiving. Be good.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.