I’m Just Sayin’ ...
The PIAA will realign classifications in all sports for next year, based on school enrollments. WPIAL executive director Tim O’Malley says that means the league will take a good look at its football playoff format.
Good thing because the WPIAL football playoffs are in need of a fix.
With the advent of six classifications, the WPIAL was forced to come up with a new playoff system. The league tried, but after two years it should be clear that, for the sake of fairness, the system needs to be changed for the smallest three classifications. In short, too many teams make the 2A and 1A playoffs while 3A gets shortchanged.
Things don’t look as bad this year as last year when Beaver finished 7-2, was ranked among the top five 3A teams in the state, but missed the WPIAL playoffs. Still, Shady Side Academy finished 6-3 this year and didn’t go to the playoffs. Central Valley was 6-4 and beat Shady Side, but didn’t go to the playoffs.
Yet in Class 2A and 1A, four 3-7 teams, two 3-6 teams and one 3-5 team qualified. If you’re Central Valley and Shady Side Academy, that’s hard to take.
Read More
The reason for the inequities is that the WPIAL takes only eight teams to the 3A playoffs, but takes 16 to the Class 2A and 1A playoffs. There is a different system for Class 3A even though Class 3A, 2A and 1A all have three conferences. The Class 6A, 5A and 4A playoffs are fine. Each of those classifications has only two conferences and eight teams qualify (the top four in each conference). In Class 1A and 2A, fifth-place teams and one sixth-place team qualify. Yet, one third-place team and no fourth-place teams qualify in Class 3A. Therein lies the fairness issue.
One of the main reasons for the current WPIAL format is the league’s desire to have four championship games at Heinz Field in one day. It’s not cheap for the WPIAL to play at Heinz Field and having four games there helps pay the bills instead of three. The Class 2A and 1A championships are played a week later at Robert Morris.
O’Malley said it would be extremely hard to play all six games at Heinz over two days “because the Steelers and Pitt are in there first and I don’t know if they would want all six in there.” That makes sense. Can you imagine what might happen to that field if six games were played in bad weather?
Varsity Xtra: Picking the WPIAL Champions
This is not an easy problem to solve for the WPIAL. It’s good that O’Malley said the league will examine the postseason system after the PIAA releases new classifications in December. But the bottom line is this: Maybe it has come time to play three games at Heinz. Maybe the Steelers could help with costs. Play the other three championships at Robert Morris. Maybe the top three classifications go to Heinz every year because they draw the biggest crowds. If needed, rotate the games. Play 6A, 3A and 2A at Heinz one year, and 5A, 4A and 1A the next.
Now my free suggestion to the WPIAL for next season: Keep the 6A, 5A and 4A playoff fields at eight teams each. Their playoffs will conclude with championships at Heinz.
For 3A, 2A and 1A, take 12 teams to the playoffs in each class. The conference champs and one second-place team get byes in the first round. Spare me the talk that too many coaches will complain about having a bye. Tough. Other districts give byes. Plus, the WPIAL champ last year and this year has a bye after the WPIAL title game before beginning the PIAA playoffs.
An informal poll of some Class 3A coaches shows they would welcome the system of 12 teams and four teams having byes. They don’t really care if they don’t play at Heinz Field.
Six classifications are here to stay. That’s a fact. WPIAL playoff systems in other sports with six classes are fine. It’s time the football system is fixed.
• At the WPIAL playoff pairings meeting Monday night, O’Malley explained to athletic directors and coaches the league’s new rule concerning media interviews after playoff games. No member of the stinkin’ media is supposed to conduct an interview until at least 10 minutes after the game.
It just seems funny to hear the rationale behind the new rule and even O’Malley said at the meeting it is to protect the coaches from themselves.
By the way, I propose all clock operators put 10 minutes on the clock after a game, sound the horn and let the PA announcer declare, “Stinkin’ media, start your interviews!”
• Before the season started, I was going to predict that Mt. Lebanon senior Aidan Cain, despite not playing a game as a sophomore and junior, was going to catch more passes in the regular season than any player in the history of the WPIAL. But I forgot.
Cain had a WPIAL-record 93 receptions. All records are made to be broken someday, but I say Cain’s will last a long time.
Varsity Xtra: Mike and Sarah picks for this week's matchups
• Fox Chapel’s Nick Gizzo and Micah Morris both rushed for more than 1,000 yards this season, an unusual feat for a team. They are only the 11th tandem since 1981 to hit 1,000, but the second from Fox Chapel. Sean Barbour and Chad Killian did it in 1997. The first known tandem to do it was Willie Davis and James Edwards of Charleroi in 1981.
• This statistic gives a true sign of the times in high school football. Seven quarterbacks in the WPIAL threw for more than 2,000 yards this regular season, by far the most in the history of the league. The previous high was four last year and three in 2015. Since 2012, a total of 20 quarterbacks have thrown for 2,000 yards in the regular season. Now consider that in the previous 33 seasons (1979-2011), a total of 22 quarterbacks threw for 2,000 yards.
• Did you know that 16 years ago Matt Humbert, the coach at Belle Vernon, led the WPIAL in passing yardage with 2,052 yards? Humbert played at Laurel Highlands. I say he has turned into one of the better coaches in the WPIAL.
• I’d say odds are better than even that legendary coaches Bob Palko of West Allegheny and Mike Zmijanac of Aliquippa walk away from their jobs after this season. Just a hunch.
• West Virginia has landed three recruits from the WPIAL senior class. Should that be a concern for Pitt? Nah. What should be a concern for Pitt is an apparent dearth of big-time players in the junior and sophomore classes in the WPIAL.
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.