Imagine if the brackets for the WPIAL football playoffs were set before the season. Imagine the outrage if, say, two of the top three teams were matched against each other in the first round, just because the brackets were pre-determined.
It might sound strange and it might sound like a horrible system. But that’s the way the WPIAL playoffs used to run. These days, the playoffs are a seedy situation — and that’s good.
This year is the 30th anniversary of the WPIAL seeding teams for the playoffs. Seeds were first planted in the WPIAL postseason in 1988 under the direction of legendary former WPIAL czar Chuck Heberling. The seeding system has grown over the years and Friday night 64 teams enter the playoffs, each carrying a certain reputation created somewhat by the number of their seed. Those seed numbers were created by 14 men who make up the WPIAL football committee and who met all day Monday to come up with seeds and pairings.
Obviously, teams strive to get a top seed. But an examination of the history of the seeds shows that there is hope for teams seeded even in the teens. Heck, it was only seven years ago that Central Valley, in the first year of the school’s existence, got a No. 14 seed — and won the WPIAL Class 3A championship. That team featured a superb sophomore receiver (Robert Foster) who now plays for the University of Alabama.
“Do seeds matter? Yes and no,” said Central Valley coach Mark Lyons, whose team missed out of the playoffs this season, but has experienced a low seed and No. 1 seed for the postseason. “I think it does not matter if you’re playing your best football at this time of year. Then a seed can almost be irrelevant. You can just hear it in the voices of some coaches when they’re interviewed. Guys like Bob Palko [at West Allegheny] or Mike Zmijanac [of Aliquippa], they don’t care who they play if they have the pulse of their team and they know they are playing well.
“Then again, if maybe you aren’t playing your best football heading into the playoffs, then seeds do matter.”
Read More
Varsity Xtra: Picking the WPIAL Champions
WPIAL executive director Tim O’Malley has said for years that the objective of the league is to get the four best teams to the semifinals. That’s why teams are seeded. Sometimes, seeds are not “true” seeds in football because certain teams have to get a home game based on their finish in conference play. But for the most part, O’Malley said, the league tries to seed the top eight teams and then go from there.
Recent history of the seeds suggests:
• Teams seeded 1 and 2 have only a one in three chance of meeting in the championship.
• At least one No. 3 seed has a good chance of making it to a championship game.
• Teams seeded four through seven have a 36 percent chance of playing for a title.
Those conclusions can be made after examination of the brackets in all classifications since 2000. The hard facts are that the 1 and 2 seeds in each classification have played each other in the title game only 34 percent of the time since 2000. In the largest classification, the top two seeds have met only six times since 2000. The 2010 Class 4A championship was won by No. 5 seed North Allegheny.
In the next largest class, the top two seeds have met only two times since 2000.
Thomas Jefferson coach Bill Cherpak has won six championships, some as a No. 1 seed.
“But I think we’ve won more when we weren’t the No. 1 seed,” said Cherpak.
This year, Thomas Jefferson is seeded third and has one loss to No. 2 seed Belle Vernon.
“When you’re the No. 1 seed, I think sometimes your kids think you’re just going to cruise into the finals,” Cherpak said. “Maybe it’s only an underlying feeling, but it happens. Kids gets too complacent sometimes. They think it’s going to be easy.
“There is more focus with us this year, especially being only an eight-team bracket instead of 16. I think now everyone knows you’re going to have tough games. Then when you see an upset like last year when New Castle upset South Fayette, you say, ‘Oh, man.’”
Any team that is a No. 3 seed can take heart knowing that at least one No. 3 seed has made it to a championship game 16 of the past 17 years. But winning a title as the No. 3 seed is a different story. South Fayette is the only No. 3 seed to win a championship since 2000.
Also, of the 70 WPIAL championship games since 2000, 34 teams seeded fourth through 14th have made it to a championship. Eight No. 4 seeds and eight No. 5 seeds have played for titles, but also three No. 9s and two No. 11s. In 2004, West Mifflin was a No. 13 seed and made it to the Class 3A title game. West Mifflin made it to the 2012 championship as a No. 7. This year, the Titans enter the Class 4A field as the eighth and final seed in Class 4A.
“One year, we were 4-5 in the regular season and made it to the final,” West Mifflin coach Ray Braszo said. “Seedings do matter, but I think if you had a team that had some injuries and then you get things back together near the end of the season, you can sometimes get an unfair seeding.”
Braszo uses West Mifflin’s past success as a low seed for motivation.
“It’s just good for your kids to make it to the championship, no matter your seed,” said Braszo. “It just makes for great memories for the kids.”
Randy Rovesti is Gateway’s athletic director and has been a WPIAL football committee member for more than 20 years. He now is the committee chairman and said the process of coming up with seedings is different nowadays.
“It used to be the committee would break up in smaller groups for each classification,” said Rovesti. “Then you’d bring back ideas to the whole group. Now the entire committee is involved for every classification.
“Everyone knows who the worst teams are and who the better teams are. The tough part is figuring out the guys in the middle, the teams who should be seeded five, six or seven in a 16-team bracket.”
But at least there are seedings nowadays.
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.