The adage is the playoffs are a new season, a time to start over and go against new competition. But the WPIAL believes old acquaintances should not be forgotten —– at least in the football playoffs.
The WPIAL used to never put teams from the same conference against each other in the first round of the playoffs, no matter the sport. But when the league announced its football playoff pairings at a meeting Monday night in Green Tree, 10 teams ended up saying “haven’t I seen you before.”
The WPIAL has three games matching teams from the same conference. In Class 4A, it’s Trinity vs. Thomas Jefferson, and New Castle vs. Montour. In Class 3A, it’s Freeport vs. Seton LaSalle. On top of that, the WPIAL has two matchups between teams that met in non-conference games — Woodland Hills vs. Gateway and South Park vs. Aliquippa.
WPIAL executive director Tim O’Malley said that rematches of conference teams in the first round are almost inevitable for the four classifications that have only eight playoff teams (Class 2A and 1A have 16). But Let’s Play Again isn’t an idea welcomed by all.
“I don’t like it, but it is what it is,” Montour coach Lou Cerro said. “I just think with only eight teams making the playoffs, it should be easy enough to cross over two conferences.”
Montour defeated New Castle, 42-21, on the first Friday in September. It was New Castle’s second loss to start the season, but the Red Hurricanes have lost only once since, to South Fayette. One of the reasons for New Castle’s success has been the switch of Ohio State recruit Marcus Hooker from running back to quarterback. Hooker, who was playing running back in the first Montour meeting, has rushed for more than 1,000 yards and, although he doesn’t throw often, he does have more than 400 yards passing.
Montour is the No. 4 seed and New Castle No. 5. But New Castle is used to a rematch with a conference foe in the first round. A year ago, New Castle lost to South Fayette in the regular season, but the two met again in the first round of the playoffs and New Castle upset No. 2 South Fayette on its way to making the WPIAL championship. A year ago, the WPIAL had five games matching conference opponents in the first round.
As for this year, O’Malley said: “We seeded one through eight and then we took a look. In 4A, one through four wasn’t a problem. But we debated 20 minutes about who was better between Trinity and New Castle, who was playing the best and who should be the No. 5 seed. The committee decided on New Castle, no matter who they played before.”
The No. 1 seeds for this year’s playoffs are Pine-Richland (6A), Penn-Trafford (5A), South Fayette (4A), Aliquippa (3A), Steel Valley (2A) and California (1A).
One of the big debates for the WPIAL football committee was whether South Fayette or Belle Vernon should get the No. 1 seed in 4A. Both teams are undefeated and Belle Vernon had a big win over perennial power Thomas Jefferson. The WPIAL gave the top seed to South Fayette.
“That No. 1 seed was probably the second-most debated thing on the committee,” said Randy Rovesti, Gateway’s athletic director and head of the committee. “Both were very deserving, but I think the thing it came down to was South Fayette being undefeated in the regular season for the last six years. In my mind, that’s sort of why I went with them.”
Rovesti said the most debated subject was the seeding of teams in Class 5A.
The Class 6A, 5A, 4A and 3A championships will be played Nov. 18 at Heinz Field. The 2A and 1A title games will be played Nov. 25 at Joe Walton Stadium.
Here are the first-round matchups (all games at 7:30 p.m. Friday unless noted otherwise):
CLASS 6A – Norwin at Pine-Richland; North Allegheny at Mt. Lebanon; Penn Hills at Bethel Park; Peters Township vs. Central Catholic at Cupples Stadium.
CLASS 5A – Fox Chapel at Penn-Trafford; Franklin Regional at Upper St. Clair; Woodland Hills at Gateway; McKeesport at West Allegheny.
CLASS 4A – West Mifflin at South Fayette; Mars at Belle Vernon; Trinity at Thomas Jefferson; New Castle at Montour.
CLASS 3A – South Park vs. Aliquippa at Ambridge; Beaver at Elizabeth Forward; Derry at Quaker Valley; Freeport vs. Seton LaSalle at Dormont Stadium.
CLASS 2A – Laurel at Steel Valley; Burgettstown at Neshannock; Frazier at Riverside; Avonworth at Charleroi; Freedom at Washington; Mohawk at East Allegheny; Brentwood vs. Cardinal Wuerl North Catholic at Mars; Beth-Center at Serra.
CLASS 1A – Bishop Canevin at California; Union at Fort Cherry; Sto-Rox vs. Imani Christian, Saturday at Woodland Hills, 1:30 p.m.; Springdale vs. Our Lady of the Sacred Heart at Moon; Summit Academy at Clairton; Western Beaver at Carmichaels; Monessen at Jeannette; West Greene at Rochester.
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.