The ad­age is the play­offs are a new sea­son, a time to start over and go against new com­pe­ti­tion. But the WPIAL be­lieves old ac­quain­tances should not be for­got­ten —– at least in the foot­ball play­offs.

The WPIAL used to never put teams from the same con­fer­ence against each other in the first round of the play­offs, no mat­ter the sport. But when the league an­nounced its foot­ball play­off pair­ings at a meet­ing Mon­day night in Green Tree, 10 teams ended up say­ing “ha­ven’t I seen you be­fore.”

The WPIAL has three games match­ing teams from the same con­fer­ence. In Class 4A, it’s Trin­ity vs. Tho­mas Jef­fer­son, and New Cas­tle vs. Mon­tour. In Class 3A, it’s Free­port vs. Seton LaSalle. On top of that, the WPIAL has two match­ups be­tween teams that met in non-con­fer­ence games — Wood­land Hills vs. Gate­way and South Park vs. Aliquippa.

WPIAL ex­ec­u­tive di­rec­tor Tim O’Mal­ley said that re­matches of con­fer­ence teams in the first round are al­most in­ev­i­ta­ble for the four clas­si­fi­ca­tions that have only eight play­off teams (Class 2A and 1A have 16). But Let’s Play Again isn’t an idea wel­comed by all.

Advertise with us

“I don’t like it, but it is what it is,” Mon­tour coach Lou Cerro said. “I just think with only eight teams mak­ing the play­offs, it should be easy enough to cross over two con­fer­ences.”

Mon­tour de­feated New Cas­tle, 42-21, on the first Fri­day in Sep­tem­ber. It was New Cas­tle’s sec­ond loss to start the sea­son, but the Red Hur­ri­canes have lost only once since, to South Fay­ette. One of the rea­sons for New Cas­tle’s suc­cess has been the switch of Ohio State re­cruit Mar­cus Hooker from run­ning back to quar­ter­back. Hooker, who was play­ing run­ning back in the first Mon­tour meet­ing, has rushed for more than 1,000 yards and, al­though he doesn’t throw of­ten, he does have more than 400 yards pass­ing.

Mon­tour is the No. 4 seed and New Cas­tle No. 5. But New Cas­tle is used to a re­match with a con­fer­ence foe in the first round. A year ago, New Cas­tle lost to South Fay­ette in the reg­u­lar sea­son, but the two met again in the first round of the play­offs and New Cas­tle up­set No. 2 South Fay­ette on its way to mak­ing the WPIAL cham­pi­on­ship. A year ago, the WPIAL had five games match­ing con­fer­ence op­po­nents in the first round.

As for this year, O’Mal­ley said: “We seeded one through eight and then we took a look. In 4A, one through four wasn’t a prob­lem. But we de­bated 20 min­utes about who was bet­ter be­tween Trin­ity and New Cas­tle, who was play­ing the best and who should be the No. 5 seed. The com­mit­tee de­cided on New Cas­tle, no mat­ter who they played be­fore.”

The No. 1 seeds for this year’s play­offs are Pine-Rich­land (6A), Penn-Traf­ford (5A), South Fay­ette (4A), Aliquippa (3A), Steel Val­ley (2A) and Cal­i­for­nia (1A).

Advertise with us

One of the big de­bates for the WPIAL foot­ball com­mit­tee was whether South Fay­ette or Belle Ver­non should get the No. 1 seed in 4A. Both teams are un­de­feated and Belle Ver­non had a big win over pe­ren­nial power Tho­mas Jef­fer­son. The WPIAL gave the top seed to South Fay­ette.

“That No. 1 seed was prob­a­bly the sec­ond-most de­bated thing on the com­mit­tee,” said Randy Rov­esti, Gate­way’s ath­letic di­rec­tor and head of the com­mit­tee. “Both were very de­serv­ing, but I think the thing it came down to was South Fay­ette be­ing un­de­feated in the reg­u­lar sea­son for the last six years. In my mind, that’s sort of why I went with them.”

Rov­esti said the most de­bated sub­ject was the seed­ing of teams in Class 5A.

The Class 6A, 5A, 4A and 3A cham­pi­on­ships will be played Nov. 18 at Heinz Field. The 2A and 1A ti­tle games will be played Nov. 25 at Joe Wal­ton Sta­dium.

Here are the first-round matchups (all games at 7:30 p.m. Friday unless noted otherwise):

Advertise with us

CLASS 6A – Norwin at Pine-Richland; North Allegheny at Mt. Lebanon; Penn Hills at Bethel Park; Peters Township vs. Central Catholic at Cupples Stadium.

CLASS 5A – Fox Chapel at Penn-Trafford; Franklin Regional at Upper St. Clair; Woodland Hills at Gateway; McKeesport at West Allegheny.

CLASS 4A – West Mifflin at South Fayette; Mars at Belle Vernon; Trinity at Thomas Jefferson; New Castle at Montour.

CLASS 3A – South Park vs. Aliquippa at Ambridge; Beaver at Elizabeth Forward; Derry at Quaker Valley; Freeport vs. Seton LaSalle at Dormont Stadium.

CLASS 2A – Laurel at Steel Valley; Burgettstown at Neshannock; Frazier at Riverside; Avonworth at Charleroi; Freedom at Washington; Mohawk at East Allegheny; Brentwood vs. Cardinal Wuerl North Catholic at Mars; Beth-Center at Serra.

Advertise with us

CLASS 1A – Bishop Canevin at California; Union at Fort Cherry; Sto-Rox vs. Imani Christian, Saturday at Woodland Hills, 1:30 p.m.; Springdale vs. Our Lady of the Sacred Heart at Moon; Summit Academy at Clairton; Western Beaver at Carmichaels; Monessen at Jeannette; West Greene at Rochester.

Mike White: mwhite@post-ga­zette.com and Twit­ter @mwhite­burgh.