Rod Rutherford gazed at his players after a recent practice and insisted these Perry Commodores don’t really know about their first-year coach, don’t realize that he was a legendary City League athlete, a standout quarterback at Pitt who had a cup of coffee in the NFL. “They can google things,” he said, “but it’s been 20 years since I played in that state championship game. They don’t know me.”

Five minutes later, as Rutherford walked toward the end zone, a Perry player stopped him and said, “Coach, how far could you throw a football in high school? Seventy yards?”

Then another player grabbed a football, darted across the back of the end zone, jumped in the air, threw the ball and said, “Look, I’m Rod Rutherford.”

Yeah, they don’t know about Rod Rutherford. What a knee slapper.

Advertise with us

Varsity Xtra: Game Hunting, Week 1

Rutherford, one of the City League’s favorite sons, is in his first season as coach at his alma mater. He will try to rebuild a program that was a City League power for years — Rutherford quarterbacked the team to a PIAA title game in 1997 — but fell on tough times the past few years. Perry is the only City school to win a PIAA football title, in 1989 under coach Gus Catanese. But as the roster size shrunk in recent years, the number of losses grew (12-24 record the past four years). This sure isn’t Rod Rutherford’s Perry, but the 36-year-old Rutherford doesn’t really care if his players know who he was. He’s more concerned about what his players can be.

“The thing is just getting them to believe,” Rutherford said. “These young men are used to guys being in and out of their lives so much. I want to get them to understand I’m here for the long haul and understand there are bigger things than football, but to use football as a vehicle to get to them.”

Rutherford brings a spotlight to City League athletics just because of his name and the Rutherford Era began Thursday night with the Commodores’ opener against Carrick. Pittsburgh Public Schools should be elated because Rutherford certainly could’ve chosen to do something else, even away from football. But this is what he wanted — because he wants to maybe make a difference in young men. Rutherford coaching at Perry is a most interesting storyline as Western Pennsylvania football gets into full swing this weekend.

Rutherford had some interesting things to say as his first game approached.

“I never really had a male figure in my life,” said Rutherford, who also works as a project assistant at Perry, mentoring students and helping in community outreach. “Football became the disciplinarian I was lacking. It helped shape me to be a respectable young man. The majority of our players come from Northview Heights, where I came from. I understand the element they’re living in every day and the things they deal with.”

Advertise with us

“Look, I don’t think my name is going to bring this program back. But I can help. That’s why I hired a number of other former Perry Commodores as coaches because they know what this program once was. … I think this is the beginning of something great. I really feel that and I tell them they need to believe that and see that. But what is great? I think it’s just competitive in every game, putting themselves into position for a championship and teaching them there is more to life than what they see every day now. As far as a [City League] championship, maybe that is a little unrealistic right now, but who knows?”

Varsity Xtra: Just Askin', Week 1

Rutherford also was a basketball star at Perry and twice won the Post-Gazette Athlete of the Year award. His days at Pitt under coach Walt Harris were life changing in his eyes.

“I was afraid to let my mom down back then because I knew if I didn’t do things I needed to do, I would let her down,” Rutherford said. “On the flip side, I didn’t know what I was getting into when I went to Pitt. Coach Harris took things to a whole different level with me in things like discipline. I might have said, ‘Why are you doing this, coach?’ But now I see. If you were five minutes late to study hall, you did 500 bear crawls. I know how that affected me. I think Walt felt like he had to tear me down to build me back up and that’s kind of the situation I have with these [Perry] guys.

“I can see they’re starting to understand things. At one point when I would tell them to do something, they would walk. Now they hop or run. I’m just trying to make them accountable. Like, if we’re supposed to practice at 8:30 in the morning and you’re not on the field at 8:30, then we’re going to do extra work.”

Who really knows what to expect from Perry on the field under Rutherford? Truth be told, it doesn’t matter your name. If there aren’t at least a few talented players, wins still can be hard to come by. But Rutherford is making players take notice.

Advertise with us

“We would listen the last few years,” quarterback David Freeman said. “But with him, there’s something a little more. You want to maybe absorb every little detail from him, so you pay attention maybe a little more.”

Because they know it’s Rod Rutherford.

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh