As a score of legendary WPIAL football coaches have retired in recent seasons — names such as George Novak, Joe Hamilton and Jack McCurry who were coaches as much as they were institutions — Jeff Metheny has become one of the longer-tenured coaches in the area.
While he prepares for his 24th season leading the Bethel Park program, 18 of which have come with a playoff berth, it’s a designation that has come to his own surprise.
“It’s pretty hard to do,” he said. “I’ve had a lot of good coaches and a lot of good support from the administration. It’s been very enjoyable.”

Click here for 134 stories, covering every class in the WPIAL and City League.
In recent years, Metheny’s program has become one of the more consistent at its level, albeit with a notable caveat. That steadiness has come with ceiling. The Black Hawks have finished with a non-losing record in five consecutive seasons, making the playoffs each of those times, but they haven’t finished with more than seven wins or fewer than four losses in that time.
Last season’s 5-5 mark, its worst finish in that stretch, was perhaps the most frustrating for Metheny and his players, largely because of what it could have been. Four of Bethel Park’s five losses came by a combined 21 points, with all of those defeats coming by seven points or fewer. There was a 21-14 loss to North Allegheny to open the season, perhaps an omen of what was to come. There were squandered first-half leads, 14-0 against Pine-Richland and 21-3 against Seneca Valley, that both ended in grueling losses. The season ended in fittingly heartbreaking fashion, as Pine-Richland again defeated them in the final minute, making a 25-yard field goal with one second remaining for a 35-32 victory in the WPIAL quarterfinals.
Those close calls turned what could have been as good as a nine-win season and a Southeastern Conference championship into a painful hypothetical. Such losses, though, present a clear mandate for the 2017 season.
“We’ve just got to finish,” Metheny said. “I think depth on the line will help us in that regard. We’ve got to get more consistent and we’ve got to finish.”
As they try to make those improvements, the Black Hawks will have some level of experience carrying them.
Five starters are back on each side of the ball. On a team that lost its starting quarterback, top three receivers and top two rushers from last season, the offensive and defensive lines stand as the areas most loaded with age and talent. James Gmiter, both literally and figuratively, stands out among that group, as the 6-foot-4, 305-pound West Virginia commit figures to be an anchor on both lines, particularly on defense. He’ll have help, too, as the likes of Gavin Vargesko should provide a dynamic presence on both sides of the ball.
“We have depth in a lot of positions,” Metheny said. “We have some young kids coming that we think are going to be pretty good and all of our linemen and tight ends back from last year. We’ve got a lot of experience up front on both sides of the ball.”
There will be challenges — especially with distant trips to schools such as Hempfield, Seneca Valley and Altoona — but given what they have buoying their team in the trenches, the Black Hawks have hope.
Coach: Jeff Metheny
Years at school: 23
2016 record: 5-5
WPIAL playoff appearances: 24
Returning starters: Offense 5, Defense 5
Key returners: James Gmiter (6-4, 305, Sr., DT-OL), Gavin Vargesko (6-1, 250, Sr., OL-DL), Tanner Volpatti (5-9, 180, Sr., RB-DB)



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.