When J.R. Niklos, a former NFL fullback, picks up the phone this time of year, he can foresee the conversation. He’ll probably have to calm down a high school coach — and he’s not thrilled about it.
Niklos, who runs 7-on-7 all-star tournaments for high school football players, runs into problems when his championship games roll around the same time high school practices begin. Some high school coaches won’t hesitate to kick players off the team if they play in one because they see them as distracting or as another way to produce inflated egos.
Despite some strong opposition, it’s becoming increasingly popular in the offseason for high school coaches to take their teams to 7-on-7 tournaments, in which two certified high school officials watch over players who wear helmets, mouthguards and shorts — no pads — and “tackle” by touching an opponent with one hand below the neck, and call only passing plays.
High school team-based tournaments are hosted by USA Football, while all-star tournaments are separate and made up of the best players country-wide. Generally, a group of 400-500 athletes who try out for an all-star team are narrowed down to 60-70.
“Everyone wants to be in the spotlight,” said Bill Cherpak, athletic director and football coach at Thomas Jefferson. “And this is one way to get there.”
Craving the spotlight
While North Allegheny football coach Art Walker has taken his squad to team-based 7-on-7 tournaments, he’s against all-star tournaments, which are sometimes compared to AAU tournaments in basketball. Scott Heinauer, football coach at Mars, referred to AAU tournaments as “all about you,” while Cherpak called them “AA me,” referencing the individualized nature.
“It takes away from the team aspect that this sport is founded on,” Walker said. “I don’t see the good in it.”
Lou Cerro, football coach at Montour, said taking players away from their teams during the offseason could send a negative message to their teammates.
“Unfortunately, some kids are selfish, and they’ll do that,” Cerro said.
Cherpak, in his 20th year coaching at Thomas Jefferson, penned an editorial in opposition of these tournaments, noting this is an issue “rarely reported,” encouraging more discussion about the pitfalls of 7-on-7 tournaments.
“Part of what makes high school football special is threatened by third-party entities running 7-on-7 tournaments comprised of non-scholastic teams,” he wrote. “These are simply showcases for an individual, diametrically opposed to the fabric of the game.”
Cherpak, who instead takes his players to team-based USA Football tournaments, said all-star tournaments erode the sport’s “inherent values.” He credits the motives behind all-star tournaments to the “look at me” generation, where some are believed to be overly concerned with gaining attention on social media as well as hyper-focusing on their ratings and sponsors.
But Niklos, the general manager of tournament organizer Midwest Boom, sees it as a potential teaching opportunity. Also a high school football coach — at Neuqua Valley in Naperville, Ill. — he said athletes can relay what they learned at 7-on-7 tournaments to their high school teammates and serve as leaders.
Safety in the hands of strangers
Even though Cherpak advises against attending all-star tournaments, he can’t control if his players decide to attend one. His message: “If you want to do that, it’s up to you.”
But Heinauer said if his players attend a tournament, it won’t help them earn a starting position in the fall. One of the many reasons — putting their players’ safety in someone else’s hands.
“Everyone’s looking out for the kids,” Cherpak said. “You just don’t know who’s sincere and who’s not.”
Cherpak also mentioned the expense of these tournaments. He said “paying $800 doesn't mean your kid is the best on the team.”
He and other coaches question the motives behind those running the tournaments, such as former players and personal trainers.
“Somebody’s making money,” West Allegheny football coach Bob Palko said. “It makes you scratch your head. Only time will tell.”
Having the perspective of a high school coach, Niklos understands the concerns surrounding all-star tournaments. That’s why he reaches out to doubters with a question: “We heard you’re against us. Can you please come to a practice?
“Every coach who’s come to our practice comes out and says, ‘Wow, this is pretty special.’ You’re never going to like what you don’t know about.”
But Niklos runs into some “drama” with the coaches who aren't on his side. Each summer, the championships are held around the same time high school practices begin. Niklos asks coaches to allow players to finish what they started, but some coaches insist their players will be kicked off the team if they miss practices.
“We stay flexible with those threats,” Niklos said. “Those are a lost cause.”
His solution? Multiple championship games. This year, Midwest Boom held two — one in Bradenton, Fla., and one at the Dallas Cowboys’ AT&T Stadium — and let the athletes choose which to attend.
“We don’t even want to start with that drama,” he said.
Do NCAA coaches care?
While some athletes use 7-on-7 tournaments to gain exposure, college coaches aren't allowed to attend, per NCAA rules. Cherpak said he has spoken with dozens of coaches, and none of their players has been recruited at the collegiate level from performances at 7-on-7 tournaments.
Niklos says otherwise. Just because college coaches aren't allowed to attend tournaments, he said, it doesn't mean they don’t send others to report back. It’s common for college coaches to hire recruiting services to attend practices and tournaments and then produce a list of top performers, Niklos said. College coaches often call him to ask which players in the area are standing out.
They can also find other ways into the tournaments. For example, Niklos said Florida State head football coach Jimbo Fisher attends his relative’s tournaments. Once coaches are at the event, no one can tell them what they can observe.
No unanimous decision
Brandon Sheppard, director of 7-on-7 for USA Football, laid out his organization’s mission via a statement provided to the Post-Gazette: “USA Football’s 7-on-7 events feature school-based teams exclusively — this is a hallmark of our program. A school-based structure delivers an exciting and better experience for student-athletes, coaches and our schools. USA Football shares concerns over any effort to move 7-on-7 play away from the scholastic coach.”
While some coaches discard offseason competition as “football in shorts,” Niklos said all-star tournaments take 100 percent of high school football players and weed out 97 percent, leaving only the best. As someone who runs 7-on-7 tournaments and coaches a full high school team, Niklos knows the level of competition is heightened in all-star tournaments, whereas the average high school player needs to learn the basics and fundamentals, like how to catch and run a route.
Until both sides of the spectrum come to an agreement, each school will stick to its own method for practicing during the offseason. After all, Cherpak said, if your system works — why change it?
Jill Beckman: jbeckman@post-gazette.com and Twitter: @_jillbeckman.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.