The PIAA overturned the WPIAL in one eligibility decision Thursday, but upheld the WPIAL in another.
The PIAA had two appeal hearings Thursday in Mechanicsburg for two notable football players from the WPIAL who were ruled ineligible by the WPIAL for allegedly transferring schools partially for athletic reasons. Last month, the WPIAL ruled Kenny White ineligible for football at Pine-Richland after he transferred from West Allegheny. The WPIAL also ruled Malik Shepherd ineligible for all sports at Aliquippa after he transferred from Beaver Falls.
White and Shepherd appealed the decisions to the PIAA. By a 5-0 vote, a PIAA appeals committee overturned the WPIAL and made White eligible at Pine-Richland. The Rams are projected to be one of the top 6A teams in the state, and White will only add more firepower. At West Allegheny last season, He played running back and rushed for more than 1,000 yards for the WPIAL 5A champion.
By a 4-1 vote, the PIAA ruled Shepherd ineligible at Beaver Falls for football. But he is eligible to play other sports. Shepherd played quarterback, receiver and defensive back last season and rushed for more than 1,000 yards for the WPIAL and PIAA 3A champion. Both Shepherd and White have scholarship offers from a few Division I colleges.
The PIAA overturning a WPIAL ruling is nothing new. It has happened numerous times in recent years.
“The subjectivity of the transfer rule lends to different groups having different decisions,” said WPIAL executive director Tim O’Malley. “Therein lies the problem with the transfer rule. We have advocated for a long time that the rule needs to be changed. It needs to be objectively defined and much more restrictive.
“Our board ruled [on White] and the PIAA found by a 5-0 vote that apparently what our board ruled on doesn’t exist. Two different groups listened to apparently the same information and found differently.”
O’Malley said Shepherd likely would’ve been ineligible to play football at Aliquippa, even without the WPIAL and PIAA rulings. Shepherd had attendance issues at Beaver Falls that would’ve affected his eligibility for the fall semester at any school.
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.