The WPIAL has cleared an Aliquippa assistant football coach of allegedly recruiting a talented player from Beaver Falls.

The WPIAL board of directors had a hearing Tuesday with longtime Aliquippa assistant Sherman McBride over a charge that he recruited Malik Shepherd to transfer from Beaver Falls to Aliquippa in April. The WPIAL board voted, 8-0, that McBride did not recruit Shepherd, and there will be no penalties against him.

“There was nothing testified that would give an indication that Sherman recruited him to Aliquippa,” said WPIAL executive director Tim O’Malley.

If a coach is found to have recruited a player, the penalty is an automatic year’s suspension from coaching.

Advertise with us

The recruiting charge came from Beaver Falls. In a hearing last month to determine the eligibility of Shepherd, Beaver Falls athletic director Jim Carbone told the WPIAL that the school was challenging the transfer because Shepherd’s mother, Autumn Fehir, told Beaver Falls officials in January that McBride was contacting her son.

Carbone and Beaver Falls assistant principal Bryan Fabyanic attended Wednesday’s hearing and presented a timeline about when Fehir made her claims. Fehir also attended, along with McBride and Aliquippa coach/athletic director Mike Zmijanac. Fabyanic said Fehir denied telling Beaver Falls officials that McBride contacted her son.

“She said she didn’t recall,” said Fabyanic. “I know what she told me on Jan. 19 and Jan. 20 and we will stand by that.”

O’Malley said: “Beaver Falls reported to us what was said to them. We don’t doubt that it’s accurate. … But just because someone makes that allegation, doesn’t mean it’s accurate. She denied she said it. Sherman denied it happened.”

Last month, the WPIAL ruled Shepherd ineligible to play at Aliquippa, claiming he transferred for athletic reasons. He played quarterback, receiver and defensive back for Beaver Falls last year and helped the Tigers win WPIAL and PIAA championships.

Advertise with us

O’Malley said McBride and Shepherd did meet once at a Beaver Falls-Quaker Valley game.

“But Sherman said he never spoke to the mother until she moved into the district,” said O’Malley. “Sherman McBride is highly thought of in Beaver County. He’s a good person and always has been. I’ve never known him to be anything but forthright and honest. We have no reason to doubt that he never did what the mother said. I don’t fault Beaver Falls for reporting it. But to get to the bottom of it, we had to give everyone the opportunity to speak.”

The hearing Tuesday was closed to the media, except for closing statements. Fabyanic got a little testy when Zmijanac told the WPIAL board that he believes Fabyanic has “ulterior motives.”

“I think that was completely uncalled for,” said Fabyanic. “We weren’t there to attack anyone’s character. It was nothing personal against Sherman McBride. This was what a concerned parent brought to us.”

After another hearing Tuesday, the WPIAL ruled Jacob McCormick ineligible to play football and basketball at Neshannock next year after transferring from Brownsville.

Advertise with us

“The board felt that the transfer was motivated, at least in part, for an athletic purpose,” said O’Malley.

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh.