The Baldwin-Whitehall School Board Wednesday night declared all football coaching positions open for the 2017-18 school year following the resignation, effective immediately, of Baldwin High School head football coach Pete Wagner Jr.

Superintendent Randal Lutz said Mr. Wagner’s resignation letter was submitted within the past week. He could not say if a reason was given for the resignation as it is a personnel matter.

Mr. Wagner, 34, was appointed head coach in 2013. The school competes in the WPIAL Class AAAA conference. Last year, the team compiled a 2-8 record.

He will continue in his current position as a computer teacher at the high school.

Advertise with us

The vote to open the roughly 12 positions was 5 to 1, with Martin Schmotzer dissenting, and members Louis Rainaldi, Elliot Rambo, and Janice Tarson absent. It is district policy that if a head coach is removed or resigns, all assistants are removed to allow a new head coach to choose his own staff.

Mr. Schmotzer said he believes the resignation is related to the board’s Dec. 14 removal of David Hayden as the boys’ and girls’ varsity/junior varsity tennis head coach, and which he opposed. Some players and their parents criticized the firing at the past two board meetings citing the program’s successes and the students’ excitement in participating. Mr. Schmotzer also said that a baseball coach, who was once honored as WPIAL coach of the year, was forced out a few years ago.

He said the result is that coaches are looking over their shoulders despite having successful programs in which the students are doing well.

“In my heart of hearts, I don’t think this would have happened if the board had stayed out of athletics,” he said last night.

Board member Tracy Macek said the board does not make “knee jerk” decisions to get rid of coaches, and that reasons cannot always be shared with the public due to being personnel issues.

Advertise with us

“Nobody is hiding behind [closed-door] executive session. We are following the law,” she said.

Mr. Schmotzer has been critical of the board for not requiring the athletic director to attend board meetings to provide his input on board actions related to athletics. His motion in early December to have the athletic director present at all board meetings was defeated.

Mr. Lutz said the athletic director and high school principal will be in charge of the search for a new head football coach. The new coach will be the district’s fifth in the past 14 years.

At the end of the meeting, Mr. Schmotzer made a motion to eliminate the district’s football program due mainly to concerns about concussions and other serious injuries to players. Other factors he cited were the cost to the district to operate the program, the band not wanting to play at football games, and low attendance at games reflective of the community’s non-support.

The motion was defeated by a 5-1 vote.

Margaret Smykla, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.