Mike White: Hey, it’s state championship week in football. Hoops starts Friday. Good week. Good time of year. I really think there are a few great matchups in the football championships. Ask away.
JR: Is there any hope that the WPIAL will reach out to the Rooney’s and use Heinz Field on two different days next year to make the 3A playoffs right and give 2A and 1A the same opportunities to play at Heinze and on TV
Mike White: Doubtful that might happen. First off, is the cost. What people don’t realize is it costs a lot of money to just go in there one day, let alone two. Plus, there is the field. Do you think the Steelers really want six games on that field in two days?? If the weather is bad, it could be a mess. Never say never, but don’t look for six games to be there.
Plus, there are a lot of people who think the Heinz Field experience really isn’t that big of a deal. I’m not one of those, but I don’t think it’s all that bad to have two of them at Robert Morris. When Clairton and Steel Valley won, I didn’t see them moping around, saying, “Yeah, but we didn’t win these championships at Heinz Field.”
Mike White: Question: How many championships does WPIAL come back with???
MIke: Isn’t it more than past time for Pa to separate private and public schools in sports and have them play in different divisions and championships? Many states do that and it seems more fair for all concerned
Read More
Mike White: Here we go again. This subject has been discussed over and over and over. I wouldn’t say many states do that. Some do. I know many people would like it in Pa. But here’s the thing: It ain’t going to happen!!!!!! The PIAA doesn’t want it.
I have heard comments this week, though, even from some coaches. Look at the 6A, 5A, 4A finalists. Five of the six are either Catholic or charter schools. The sixth is Harrisburg, who was helped greatly my a mid-year transfer.
Mike White: FYI. That St. John’s team that handled Central in the opening game??? St. John’s went 8-4. But one of the losses was to IMG in Florida. Which is a school but I certainly wouldn’t call a high school “team”. Players come from all over the country to go there. Two losses to a real good DeMatha team and one to Gonzaga.
Nate: Mike, which game will be the best in terms of play and score? Follow up, which team has the best chance to win a PIAA championship? My pick, Steel Valley!
Mike White: I really like three of the games - Clairton-Bishop Guilfoyle, Steel Valley-Southern Columbia and St. Joe’s-Central.
I’ve said since November that the best shot for the WPIAL to win a state was in 3A. I said that because I think that class is the weakest in the rest of the state. Middletown (Beaver Falls’ opponent) obviously is good, but I don’t think as strong on a comparative level as St. Joe’s, Southern Columbia or Bishop Guilfoyle.
Nate: The private/public school thing is just dumb to me. Let it go! Its just high school football. It isn’t the end of the world!
Mike White: No, it’s not dumb. It is a big issue. But my point is that it’s not going to change.
Nate: Mike, is it just me or is Pittsburgh becoming a better basketball city? I know Philly still is king in the state, but Pittsburgh has been getting better players recently!
Mike White: I think Pittsburgh hoops is better than people think, but I don’t think it’s not just past couple years. I think it’s gotten better the past decade or so. But absolutely no way individual talent comes close to comparing with Philly. Please. Biggest reason is city schools. Many Division I players in Philly area. But not here. Then again, Philly is much bigger city than Pittsburgh.
WPIAL Joey: I saw that the wrestling star, Hong, who transferred to NA, has been ruled ineligible. I know you disagree Mike, but I think it’s totally ridiculous that the WPIAL steps in and tells a kid they can’t complete. He transferred from one public school to another, and there could be a dozen legitimate reasons for it. But somehow this council of wise men in the WPIAL can determine his intent and say he can’t compete. Baloney.
Mike White: Sorry. Wrong. There are rules. You may not agree with them but they are rules. And unless there is open enrollment, WPIAL should try to enforce rules. You don’t know all the particulars involved in a case. Many of the hearings are closed. Kids clearly transfer sometimes for athletic intent and some are recruited. That’s not what high school sports were ever intended to be. At least the WPIAL tries to stand up to some of these transfers sometimes. Much more than other parts of state. WPIAL rulings aren’t always consistent, but at least they try.
No one ever has said a kid can’t go to whatever school he wants. But playing sports isn’t a right. It’s a privilege. And if you do something that might be against the rules, then you must pay penalty.
Problem is transfer rule is not enforced everywhere.
Nate: Mike, any chance WPIAL wins a basketball state championship? Also, Westinghouse will win city. Calling it now.
Mike White: No surprise on Westinghouse. We ranked them No. 2 heading into season. They will be much improved. Wouldn’t be surprised if they won it.
As far as state titles, very doubtful in the two or three largest classes. Too many good teams in Philly area. Better chances in small classes.
Nate: Very short scouting report on the teams that are playing the WPIAL teams in the championship.
Mike White: St. Joe’s really good. RB D’Andre Swift rated one of best in country. Georgia recruit. He will be key.
Beaver Falls playing Middletown, a team with no big stars but seems really sound.
Steel Valley playing Southern Columbia, perennial power. Steel Valley is really good. But remember, Aliquippa was good last year and got handled by Southern Columbia. SC has two 1,000 yard rushers. One a freshman.
Clairton and Bishop Guilfoyle. Great matchup. BG 46 game winning streak. Really good defense. Only allow 102 yards rushing a game. Lost star RB to knee injury in summer, but he played a few plays last week. Watch Lamont Wade. He could be the difference.
Mike White: Sorry gotta cut it short today. Headed to luncheon that honors WPIAL and City champs


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.