Gateway High School parents turned out for Tuesday’s meeting with questions regarding a “key” football player who was ruled ineligible to play in the WPIAL 5A semifinal game because of his grades.

The player, whose name was not released due to confidentiality, had a grade point average of less than the 2.0 required to play a sport at Gateway.

Parents were upset, saying the player was told he could not play at noon the day of the game last Friday. Another football player was also ruled ineligible because of grades along with players of three other sports.

“Some of these kids have nobody,” parent John Walker said at the meeting. “The school board failed. They told the boy he couldn’t play at noon Friday,” he said.

Advertise with us

Parent Anthony Hampton added that other schools abide by the PIAA (Pennsylvania Interscholastic Athletic Association) rules, which state that a student needs to be passing his or her core classes to be eligible to play a sport.

“Our community is hurting now,” said Mr. Hampton of the loss of the semifinal game to McKeesport Area High School. “We are at a competitive disadvantage,” he said.

Mr. Hampton said the student in question doesn’t have parents in his life and that the district should look at athletic eligibility on a case-by-case basis.

“We’re lucky that this kid’s not locked up,” Mr. Hampton said.

Parent Carianne Kunich said the eligibility issue has affected the football team with the loss.

Advertise with us

She said she didn’t believe the district was doing enough for the underachieving students.

“I don’t believe the resources are there for our kids anymore,” she said.

On Nov. 10 board member Valerie Warning sent an email to the rest of the board. In that email obtained from the district, she said she received a phone call from athletic director Randy Rovesti advising her that two football players had not met the 2.0 GPA needed to play in the game.

“He asked if there was anything the board could possibly do,” Ms. Warning stated in the e-mail. She also stated in the email that she talked with district solicitor Bruce Dice regarding the matter and he said that as long as the student had an individualized education plan, monitoring and conditionality, and there were five votes, the board could overturn the policy.

Ms. Warning then took a straw poll on her own and came up with six votes in favor of meeting to look at the policy.

Advertise with us

In another email obtained from the district, board President Chad Stubenbort said regarding the straw vote: “Upon talking with other board members, information given was inaccurate, misinforming and blatantly false.”

Mr. Stubenbort then conducted another straw poll vote, and it was determined 7-2 to adhere to board policy and rule the player ineligible for the game.

At the meeting, Mr. Stubenbort said the eligibility policy has been in place since 1997, with the only change since then coming in 2014. That change was to base eligibility on a nine-weeks GPA and not a cumulative GPA.

Mr. Stubenbort added that the students were told the Wednesday before the Friday game that they were ineligible to play.

“I love being on school board, but one thing that is horrible is voting to tell a student they’re not allowed to play a sport,” Mr. Stubenbort said.

Advertise with us

He added that programs are supposed to be in place to assist students who need to boost their GPA for sports, such as study halls. He said that the administration would look into why those programs were not fully in place.

“We do have a more stringent policy than other districts,” Mr. Stubenbort said. “We should not be lowering the academic standard here at Gateway.”

Board member Mary Beth Cirucci added that she supports the football program, saying her son has played since fifth grade.

“I did vote not to allow a particular player to play because it’s policy, but I am open to revisiting the policy,” Ms. Cirucci said.

Board member Steve O’Donnell said the district’s purpose is to serve the students academically with the best education possible.

Advertise with us

“We want them to attend any school on their academic merits” after graduation, Mr. O’Donnell said, adding that “99.95 percent of students leave here and don’t pursue golf or swimming or tennis, they pursue employment.”

“Whenever it came to the eligibility, things were done correctly,” superintendent William Short said.

Deana Carpenter, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.