The pint-sized players of Guyasuta of Fox Chapel Youth Football know the price they’ll pay for hitting with their heads.
“They do pushups,” said coaches representative Ron Valenty. “It makes them tougher. How many pushups do you want to do until you get it right?”
As youth enrollment in football leagues declines and concussions continue to shape the conversation around contact sports, thousands of youth football leagues and high school teams have turned to Heads Up Football, an education program from USA Football that trains coaches on health and safety matters. Heads Up Football addresses a range of issues, from concussion recognition and sudden cardiac arrest to equipment fitting and tackling techniques.
Citing a scientific study commissioned by USA Football, a recent New York Times article called into question just how effective Heads Up Football has been in reducing concussions and other injuries. But a sampling of Western Pennsylvania football coaches and officials still supports the program, even expressing surprise at the article’s findings. In their view, Heads Up Football has changed the culture around injury prevention in football for the better.
Thousands of youth football leagues and high school teams have signed up for Heads Up Football since it was launched nationwide in 2013. The Pennsylvania Scholastic Football Coaches Association has endorsed Heads Up Football for its membership, and the Steelers support USA Football’s educational programs, said USA Football spokesman Steve Alic. Participation is required for City League coaches, who are in the process of completing their Heads Up Football certifications, director of athletics Mike Gavlik said.
USA Football, football’s national governing body, touted Heads Up Football as a way to reduce concussions and other injuries, based on the preliminary results of a study by the Datalys Center for Sports Injury Research and Prevention. The Indianapolis organization initially found that Heads Up Football reduced concussions among young football players by about 30 percent and other injuries by 76 percent, the Times’ Alan Schwarz reported.
But Datalys’ completed study, published in the Orthopaedic Journal of Sports Medicine in July 2015, offered a less rosy picture: “Heads Up Football showed no demonstrable effect on concussions during the study, and significantly less effect on injuries over all, than USA Football and the [NFL, which funds the organization] have claimed in settings ranging from online materials to congressional testimony,” Schwarz reported.
The study found a lower rate of concussion for 11- to 15-year-old players in Heads Up Football leagues who also used Pop Warner practice guidelines, which curb contact and bar some heads-on drills. And players in Heads Up Football leagues — those who did and did not use Pop Warner guidelines — had a lower rate of all injury types than players who were not in those leagues. But Heads Up Football alone was less effective at reducing injury rates than the initial data suggested.
Datalys took responsibility for not alerting USA Football to the discrepancy between the preliminary and published findings.
Still, those results were greeted with a shrug or surprise from a sample of local Heads Up Football-certified coaches and officials, who credit the program with a shift in how football is taught and practiced in their own leagues.
“I’d find that surprising, if that’s truly the case,” said Brandon Caletri, president of the Mount Pleasant Area Junior Football League, when asked about the Times’ story. “Just the way the game’s played and even practiced, USA Football changed all that.”
“Back when we played, 30-some years ago, you got your bell rung, and the coaches were putting you right back in,” he said. “There’s nothing like that anymore.”
“If you go to the man-on-the-ground viewpoint, there’s no way it’s not positively impacting football,” said Ally Mahon, another coaches’ representative for Guyasuta.
In addition to being certified with Heads Up Football, all of the leagues discussed in this article have time limits on contact during practice.
Fairfax County Public Schools in Virginia, for one, has been a poster child for Heads Up Football. An early adopter of the program and a close partner of USA Football, the district has boasted a 43.3 percent reduction in concussions since 2013.
While the district made several other changes, such as reducing contact during practice, director of student activities and athletics Bill Curran said Heads Up Football has been a key ingredient of the reforms.
“How do I separate the milk and the butter from the mashed potatoes?” he said. “I don’t. It’s all part of that toolbox.”
Plenty of leagues are adopting similar measures to reduce contact. For the coming season, the PIAA has restricted hitting in high school football practices to 60 minutes each week. USA Football recommends no more than 30 minutes of full contact per practice, up to 90 minutes weekly, although following those recommendations is not a requirement of Heads Up Football certification. Pop Warner limits full contact to one-third of practice time, or 40 minutes.
“At the time of the published study, the USA Football Practice Guidelines were not yet published or available to us, and therefore were not included in the study,” Thomas Dompier, the president of Datalys and one of the study’s researchers, wrote in an email. “Only the Pop Warner guidelines were included. Based on the similarities between USA Football’s Practice Guidelines and those of Pop Warner, it is reasonable to hypothesize that similar results might be found.”
At Allderdice, coach Jerry Haslett, a recent adopter of Heads Up Football, hopes using techniques from the program will keep players healthy throughout the season, particularly during the playoff hunt. In some drills, players tackle bags instead of their teammates.
“The kids like it,” Haslett said. “Instead of beating the hell out of each other, they’re beating the bags up a little bit and staying off the ground more, so we don’t get a hip pointer or something like that by diving on the ground.”
In a separate study, Datalys researchers found that players in Heads Up Football leagues “had fewer head impacts during practices, but not during games.”
The caveat about games aside, that could be a feather in the program’s cap, since such subconcussive blows “may be a more important predictor of long-term impairments than concussion,” Dompier said, referring to research from Boston University.
Elizabeth Bloom: ebloom@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1750 and Twitter: @BloomPG.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.